• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

US "Surprised", Wasn't Pre-Consulted On Poland's Announcement Of Jets For Ukraine

VySky

Supporting Member
DP Veteran
Joined
Sep 12, 2019
Messages
32,566
Reaction score
11,939
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Moderate
Why Poland kept Biden out of the loop is likely obvious to most of us.

-------------------------

Update(17:24ET): This level of huge contradiction among allies on such a big development is just a bit awkward and even embarrassing. The Biden administration is saying it was caught completely by "surprise" at Poland's declaration hours ago that it would send all its Russian-produced MiG-29 jets to Ramstein Air Base in Germany for the United States to be able to transfer them to Ukraine.

While the possible plan was reportedly under consideration for days, it doesn't appear the White House was notified of Warsaw's final decision prior to the announcement being declared as a 'done deal' via the Polish Ministry of Foreign Affairs website. Apparently for Washington, there was no done deal at all.

"Poland's decision to put all its MIG-29 jets at the disposal of the United States was not pre-consulted with Washington," State Department Undersecretary Victoria Nuland said Tuesday in the wake of Poland's statement. And more:

 
Why Poland kept Biden out of the loop is likely obvious to most of us.

-------------------------

Update(17:24ET): This level of huge contradiction among allies on such a big development is just a bit awkward and even embarrassing. The Biden administration is saying it was caught completely by "surprise" at Poland's declaration hours ago that it would send all its Russian-produced MiG-29 jets to Ramstein Air Base in Germany for the United States to be able to transfer them to Ukraine.

While the possible plan was reportedly under consideration for days, it doesn't appear the White House was notified of Warsaw's final decision prior to the announcement being declared as a 'done deal' via the Polish Ministry of Foreign Affairs website. Apparently for Washington, there was no done deal at all.

"Poland's decision to put all its MIG-29 jets at the disposal of the United States was not pre-consulted with Washington," State Department Undersecretary Victoria Nuland said Tuesday in the wake of Poland's statement. And more:

Zerohedge never gets anything wrOng.
 
Soi what is the US going to do. Reject the offer???? I don't think so. Still think it was a slick move by Poland as I expressed in the "No Fly Zone" thread.
 
Why Poland kept Biden out of the loop is likely obvious to most of us.

-------------------------

Update(17:24ET): This level of huge contradiction among allies on such a big development is just a bit awkward and even embarrassing. The Biden administration is saying it was caught completely by "surprise" at Poland's declaration hours ago that it would send all its Russian-produced MiG-29 jets to Ramstein Air Base in Germany for the United States to be able to transfer them to Ukraine.

While the possible plan was reportedly under consideration for days, it doesn't appear the White House was notified of Warsaw's final decision prior to the announcement being declared as a 'done deal' via the Polish Ministry of Foreign Affairs website. Apparently for Washington, there was no done deal at all.

"Poland's decision to put all its MIG-29 jets at the disposal of the United States was not pre-consulted with Washington," State Department Undersecretary Victoria Nuland said Tuesday in the wake of Poland's statement. And more:

Wait...what? The Biden pukes aren't in control?

LOL!!
 
Smart. Gives Biden plausible deniability.
 
Smart. Gives Biden plausible deniability.
Well if the reporting is accurate it does not go quite that far. Apparently Poland is going to turn the jets over to the United States and let the US repaint them and delivery them to Ukraine. Still pretty slick IMO.
 
Zero Hedge linked this as their source:

Statement of the Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Poland in connection with the statement by the US Secretary of State on providing airplanes to Ukraine​

 
So following in bold is what is at the Polish web site in question. Still sounds like there is some work to be done. But there should not be much dickering which again suggests a pretty slick move by Poland.

The authorities of the Republic of Poland, after consultations between the President and the Government, are ready to deploy – immediately and free of charge – all their MIG-29 jets to the Ramstein Air Base and place them at the disposal of the Government of the United States of America.

At the same time, Poland requests the United States to provide us with used aircraft with corresponding operational capabilities. Poland is ready to immediately establish the conditions of purchase of the planes.

The Polish Government also requests other NATO Allies – owners of MIG-29 jets – to act in the same vein.
 
Why Poland kept Biden out of the loop is likely obvious to most of us.

-------------------------

Update(17:24ET): This level of huge contradiction among allies on such a big development is just a bit awkward and even embarrassing. The Biden administration is saying it was caught completely by "surprise" at Poland's declaration hours ago that it would send all its Russian-produced MiG-29 jets to Ramstein Air Base in Germany for the United States to be able to transfer them to Ukraine.

While the possible plan was reportedly under consideration for days, it doesn't appear the White House was notified of Warsaw's final decision prior to the announcement being declared as a 'done deal' via the Polish Ministry of Foreign Affairs website. Apparently for Washington, there was no done deal at all.

"Poland's decision to put all its MIG-29 jets at the disposal of the United States was not pre-consulted with Washington," State Department Undersecretary Victoria Nuland said Tuesday in the wake of Poland's statement. And more:

Why? Maybe they didn't want China to be told so they could tell Putin. Or maybe the Biden administration was told and didn't bother to take action. Or possibly the Biden administration hasn't been watching the news where this development has been discussed for numerous days now. I guess it's just another case of Biden knows best when he know nothing at all.
 
Well if the reporting is accurate it does not go quite that far. Apparently Poland is going to turn the jets over to the United States and let the US repaint them and delivery them to Ukraine. Still pretty slick IMO.

Yep, Pole and Ukrainians, my favorite crafty Slavic peoples. Poland put the Biden Administration on the spot, "Here are you planes...looking forward to our replacements". The message is "Just do it and do it now".
 
Why? Maybe they didn't want China to be told so they could tell Putin. Or maybe the Biden administration was told and didn't bother to take action. Or possibly the Biden administration hasn't been watching the news where this development has been discussed for numerous days now. I guess it's just another case of Biden knows best when he know nothing at all.
More likely, the Pols just did not want to dicker about the price AND wanted to pass the planes over to the US and let them take the heat.

However, all this "heat" being discussed is more media histrionics. We are already providing arms that are landing in Ukraine. A weapon is a weapon is a weapon. Putin has not started WW3 over Javelins and Stingers and all this other crap.

Joy Reid who should stay in her lane....whatever that is....going ballistic and other IDIOT guests of hers going ballistic as well. JUST STOP. Please just stop Joy. I imagine CNN is doing no better. I am almost afraid to change the channel and look.
 
Yep, Pole and Ukrainians, my favorite crafty Slavic peoples. Poland put the Biden Administration on the spot, "Here are you planes...looking forward to our replacements". The message is "Just do it and do it now".
Biden is trying as hard as he can to make Putin happy. He was literally forced into banning Russian oil by Congress and public sentiment. He's negotiating with Iran for nukes and give Russian their current nuclear stash, in exgage we get iranian oil, and Iran gets free of sanctions plus new nuclear program in 2 years. Then theres Venezuela that Joe want's to buy oil from, another dictator who abuses his people. All the while Biden could just let America pump up the volume. Only problem there is it offends his progressives. Spineless Joe, bends to the Communist and the marxist progressives.
 
Biden is trying as hard as he can to make Putin happy. He was literally forced into banning Russian oil by Congress and public sentiment. He's negotiating with Iran for nukes and give Russian their current nuclear stash, in exgage we get iranian oil, and Iran gets free of sanctions plus new nuclear program in 2 years. Then theres Venezuela that Joe want's to buy oil from, another dictator who abuses his people. All the while Biden could just let America pump up the volume. Only problem there is it offends his progressives. Spineless Joe, bends to the Communist and the marxist progressives.
Wow there is so many lies in this post. Good job Marxist!
 
Biden is trying as hard as he can to make Putin happy. He was literally forced into banning Russian oil by Congress and public sentiment. He's negotiating with Iran for nukes and give Russian their current nuclear stash, in exgage we get iranian oil, and Iran gets free of sanctions plus new nuclear program in 2 years. Then theres Venezuela that Joe want's to buy oil from, another dictator who abuses his people. All the while Biden could just let America pump up the volume. Only problem there is it offends his progressives. Spineless Joe, bends to the Communist and the marxist progressives.
Way better than having dipshit Donny
 
Well, will the Media finally now get off this particular story for a bit. Have US diplomates learned their lesson about answering every IDIOT question the media has regarding issues that a simply should not be discussed.

Apparently the talks with Poland regarding the MIG29's has stalled over how to delivery them to Ukraine. Quite possibly both the media and the State Dept should have been smarter.

Remember it was Blinken that answered the media literally saying that we are working with Poland to negotiate a way forward regarding the jet fighters which of course shifted the pressure back to Poland. Has the media learned that there are some questions you simply cannot probe at like some petulant child at a time when bombs are falling and people are dying.

Earth to media:
Cover what you can see with your eyes and then comment on that. You are ours eyes. YOU are not our minds. Never mind speculating about what you can't see or should not see. You are treading on dangerous ground here media and I have seen it repeated over and over again in the last two weeks. Do not report on what you cannot see or comment on it as you are only speculating and do not report or comment on possible consequences of what you cannot see or comment on it because you are again SPECULATING in a space that is fraught with risk of actually affecting outcomes that you have no business affecting.

Earth to State Dept:
Shut the fugg up. If there are media representatives too stupid to know a question they should not be asking then throw them out of press conferences. Get the press in a room and tell them you do not even want to offer a "no comment" to these dumbass questions that are an effort to learn the sensitive aspects of negotiations that may or may not be in progress and the next IDIOT reporter that asks me one of these dumbass questions is losing his press credentials. Its NONE OF THEIR business as members of the media and NONE OF MY business as a member of the media consuming public. It is none of our business. We are not part of what should be a "need to know" standard.

We have simply all of us forgotten how to act in an environment where actual 20th century large scale warfare is being waged or we are too young to have experience with it and too STUPID to figure it out how to act for ourselves.

We can specula amongst ourselves as we are not officially part of anything other than the "citizenry". The 4th estate is called the 4th estate for a reason. They have privileges, duties and responsibilities. Its high time they learned them again and quickly. Go check the work of war correspondents and the WH Press Corp during Vietnam. They knew how to do it even at that late date. Don't talk to me about the Pentagon Papers either. That was an event. It happened. Elisberg did steal them and was going to release them one way or the other. That is an actual news story. It was not speculation.

Hopefully talks between Poland and whomever regarding the MIG29's can pick up again with a little less sniffing around by the media and a little more sense exhibited by the State Dept.
 
Oh my God...it just doesn't stop. STOP TALKING TO THE MEDIA about these jets:
- stop Blinkin
- stop NATO
- stop Poland
- stop everybody

Never seen anything so ridiculous in my life
 
So now the media is simply parroting the US line regarding these MIG29 jets that Poland has.

"Oh we see why the US and NATO are saying that we cannot even allow Ukrainian pilots to fly these planes into Ukraine. Why they could be shot down."

Holy Fugging Shit. They are sounding this mantra with a straight face.

Great Job. Both the media and the US/NATO have covered themselves in shit now. NOW do you clowns at the State Dept and in the Media see why you should have been keeping your big fat stupid mouths shut????

And what the hell was VP Harris doing in Poland today. Had her plane even landed at the point when DOD and the State Dept were rejecting the Polish offer?

Really really badly done. John Kerry level stupid.
 
Last edited:
Now that we are past the MIG29 jets fiasco brought to you courtesy of your state department and your utter oblivious media, its on to high altitude mobile ground to air missiles and missiles launchers. Hopefully the state department gets its head screwed on straight for this next potential clown car show and the media stops acting like some petulant child constantly now devoted to speculation as opposed to reporting and journalistic commentary.

In the MIG29 jets fiasco, MSM after having contributed mightily to that foul up simply parroted the absurd state department line apparently a bit down in the mouth about the whole miserable affair and their contribution to the fiasco that it was.

Personally I do not want to know a thing about how these negotiations for ground to air missiles and missile launchers is going. I don't what to know who is talking to whom about what. I have no interest in talking heads speculating about the results or the consequences. Get it done and tell me when missiles are being shoved up the rear ends of Russian pilots and bringing down planes. Until you can tell me that.....SHUT THE FUGG UP!
 
Back
Top Bottom