• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!
  • Welcome to our archives. No new posts are allowed here.

U.S. Supreme Court Ruling: ATHEISM IS RELIGION

No, I just don't care enough. As I stated earlier, I don't really care about what an atheist is or is not. But I feel bad about being sarcastic. I apologize and owe you a beer. However, sarcasm is pretty much my "A" game. FWIW, I think your views on atheism are well considered and well constructed. Others should follow your lead, but that would be less entertaining.

:beer:


So no rebuttals then.
You concede?
 

Indeed, I thought that this meme died a long time ago.
 
As usual, Alter2ego isn't interested in facts. This is the stereotypical bi-weekly bickering session started by christians trying to classify atheism as a religion so they can bring it down to their level of witchcraft and wizardry.

The ones that make me smile are the 'Atheism is JUST a religion crowd'; As if it being a religion would be a negative thing.
 

Curbing the entitlement culture of religions to level the playing field is NOT the same as discriminating.
 
The ones that make me smile are the 'Atheism is JUST a religion crowd'; As if it being a religion would be a negative thing.

Yes, lets have more of those lovely crusades and inquisitions.
 
Curbing the entitlement culture of religions to level the playing field is NOT the same as discriminating.

The issue isn't an entitlement culture. Freedom to practice religion is a right, that congress shall pass no law prohibiting. I will not prohibit your preference from being practiced and you shouldn't try to prohibit my practice, as long as the practice of our respective religions do not run afoul of law and public safety ie human sacrifice etc... It's not enough to claim offence, and cast out all religion, that leaves secularism / Atheism as the publically promoted religion. That's not any different that promoting Christianity or Judaism, what we need from our government (meaning laws and statutes) on the issue is silence; what we need from our citizens (including government employees) is free practice.
 

You've falsely attributed a causal relationship between atheists and their actions based on it. It is as meaningless as saying "baseball fans have themselves committed human rights violations....." The fact that people that are baseball fans only matters in a conversation when talking specifically about baseball.

2. Atheists routinely argue they do not belong to a religion. According to them, non-belief in God is proof positive that they are not religious. Do you agree with the atheists' position? Why so or why not?

The word at issue here is "religion". The problem is that English has words that morph over time leading to a great deal of confusion....

The modern definition:



The last definition in modern dictionary would include atheism, but the older definition would not as there are no "rules of conduct" that atheists must conform to. Atheist share 1 opinion, that they do not believe in god.

Even if you call that a "religion" that opinion cannot be equated with theistic religion.

3. Based upon numerous court rulings that Atheism is Religion, it is obvious that belief in a supernatural God or gods is not a requirement for being considered part of a religion. What arguments can you present along this line?[/color]

See above.
 

You do realize the atrocities committed under Communists were not under the "banner of non-belief", but rather the banner of absolute State Power. It's not an atheist war or atheist killing, atheism was not the cause of any of that. This whole thing is just some ignorant rant meant to deflect away from critiques and questions you cannot answer.
 

And I stated that I wanted to curb religious freedom where in my posts?

The issue is entitlement culture, equal freedom to practice religion or lack a belief. Like I said, complete disestablishment.
 

It is arguable that the CP became a cult like religion under these authoritarian regimes.
 
:yawn:

Why on Earth should I give a sh!t?

IMO, the SCOTUS should not be wasting it's time ruling on such silliness.

What's next?

Will it rule that God exists?

That Sunday is 'God Day'?

That the Dallas Cowboys suck?
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…