• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

There are no longer any groups whose voting rights are automatically denied except for people under 18.....

Razoo

Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
Dec 1, 2017
Messages
24,476
Reaction score
7,808
Gender
Undisclosed
Political Leaning
Undisclosed
There are no longer any groups whose voting rights are automatically denied except for people under 18. It’s a matter of social progress. When other groups demanded the right to vote, many treated their cause with hesitation or ridicule, but eventually social progress prevailed. But the evolution of suffrage is not complete until it is extended to everyone who deserves it, and we’re working to move closer to that goal."

 
Last edited:
There are no longer any groups whose voting rights are automatically denied except for people under 18. It’s a matter of social progress. When other groups demanded the right to vote, many treated their cause with hesitation or ridicule, but eventually social progress prevailed. But the evolution of suffrage is not complete until it is extended to everyone who deserves it, and we’re working to move closer to that goal."

-Teen Vote http://teenvote.us/why

http://www.youthrights.org/voteproposal.php


None of your links appear to work.
 

Youth Voting: Lower the Voting Age to 16​

Ralph Nader favors lowering the voting age to 16 years old. He recognizes that 16 year olds work, pay taxes, and are increasingly subjected to the passage of criminal laws which sentence them as adults. If 16 year olds perform the civic duties of adults, they should receive the civic privileges of adults. Working teens currently experience taxation without representation.

Additionally, democracy in the United States needs to be re-invigorated. Allowing youth the right to vote will increase voter participation, not only of 16 to 18 year olds, but also in the longer term as youth would learn at an early age the importance of voting. Alongside this change in law, the Nader campaign also favors increased education about civics, government, and the importance of voting.

Consider these words by supporters of youth voting, which eloquently explain the importance of this historic movement:

"At the founding of our nation, only rich, white, land-owning men over the age of twenty-one could vote. Later, it was any white man over twenty-one. Following the Civil War, the Fifteenth Amendment gave the vote to African American men. Next, in 1920, women’s suffrage finally paid off with the passage of the Nineteenth Amendment. Finally, in 1970 the voting age was lowered to 18 due to the counter-cultural movements of the 1960’s. Over hundreds of years, the vote has spread from the clutches of an elite few to an ever-greater percentage of the population. Youth are simply the next item on the timeline of Democracy’s growth."

- Brad Vogel, "Youth Suffrage," Between the Lines, www.btlmag.org

"What kind of twisted message do we send when we tell youth they are judged mature, responsible adults when they commit murder, but silly, brainless kids when they want to vote? This is a double standard, no different than during the Vietnam War. War isn’t a dead issue now either, leaders who youth can’t vote for today may send them to war tomorrow. Lowering the voting age is the just, fair way to set things straight."

-NYRA, National Youth Rights Association, youthrights.org

"For several reasons lowering the voting age will increase voter turnout. It is common knowledge that the earlier in life a habit is formed the more likely that habit or interest will continue throughout life. If attempts are made to prevent young people from picking up bad habits, why are no attempts made to get youth started with good habits, like voting? If citizens begin voting earlier, and get into the habit of doing so earlier, they are more likely to stick with it through life.

-NYRA, National Youth Rights Association, youthrights.org

A 1996 survey by Bruce Merrill, an Arizona State University journalism professor, found a strong correlation between youth voting and increased adult voter turnout. Merrill compared turnout of registered voters in five cities with Kids Voting, a mock-election program, to turnout in five cities without the program. Merrill found that between five and ten percent of respondents reported Kids Voting was a factor in their decision to vote. This indicated that 600,000 adults nationwide were encouraged to vote by the program.

-John Stuart Hall, "Elections and Civic Education, the Case of Kids Voting USA," National Civic Review, Spring 1998, 79.

"When the USA was founded, suffrage was restricted to white male landowners. Over time, it was extended to non-landowners, women, lower-class people (through the elimination of the poll tax), and minority races. There are no longer any groups whose voting rights are automatically denied except for people under 18. It’s a matter of social progress. When other groups demanded the right to vote, many treated their cause with hesitation or ridicule, but eventually social progress prevailed. But the evolution of suffrage is not complete until it is extended to everyone who deserves it, and we’re working to move closer to that goal."

 
There are no longer any groups whose voting rights are automatically denied except for people under 18. It’s a matter of social progress. When other groups demanded the right to vote, many treated their cause with hesitation or ridicule, but eventually social progress prevailed. But the evolution of suffrage is not complete until it is extended to everyone who deserves it, and we’re working to move closer to that goal."


Couldn’t those same arguments be made to give taxpaying (and legally accountable for any criminal acts) non-citizen residents the right to vote?
 
Perhaps because under 18 are considered minors/children?
 
There are no longer any groups whose voting rights are automatically denied except for people under 18. It’s a matter of social progress. When other groups demanded the right to vote, many treated their cause with hesitation or ridicule, but eventually social progress prevailed. But the evolution of suffrage is not complete until it is extended to everyone who deserves it, and we’re working to move closer to that goal."

How and who determines "everyone who deserves it"?
 
Are any of you aware of the documents required for voter registration?

What is the fear?
 
Are any of you aware of the documents required for voter registration?

What is the fear?
Each state can set it's own standards. Problems arise when voters move within the state without notifying the Govt. as official addresses then change. Some people have documents with different names, i.e. some with middle names, some without...The fear of course is the ability to vote multiple times.
 
Each state can set it's own standards. Problems arise when voters move within the state without notifying the Govt. as official addresses then change. Some people have documents with different names, i.e. some with middle names, some without...The fear of course is the ability to vote multiple times.
Are there examples .......?

it's republicans doing the voter fraud .......
 
Relatively few people under 25 vote with any consistency. Lowering the age isn't going to change that much.

We as a society have set the age of majority at 18 for most purposes. Granted that laws are somewhat inconsistent about this... some things are reserved to 21yo's, certain responsibilities or privileges can come earlier (like driving or being tried as an adult).

One of the fundamentals in a system like ours though is that Citizens vote, and non-citizens do not, and you're not a citizen until you're 18. At 18 you can do all the things (join the military, be drafted if that happens, marry, contract, etc) *without parental permission*. You're a free citizen at 18... before that, you are subject to your parent or guardian.

We have to draw the line somewhere.

Recent studies show that brain development isn't complete until you're about 21-23yo, particularly impulse control and emotional filters. While this makes a good argument for not prosecuting minors as adults, it argues against lowering the age of citizenship.
 
Back
Top Bottom