• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

The US controlled by Ruling Class

By Bernie Sanders

"Since 1975, there has been a massive redistribution of wealth in America that has gone in exactly the wrong direction. Over the past 47 years, according to the Rand Corporation, $50tn in wealth has been redistributed from the bottom 90% of American society to the top 1%, primarily because a growing percentage of corporate profits has been flowing into the stock portfolios of the wealthy and the powerful.

We now have more income and wealth inequality than at any time in the last hundred years. In the year 2022, three multi-billionaires own more wealth than the bottom half of American society – 160 million Americans. Today, 45% of all new income goes to the top 1%, and CEOs of large corporations make a record-breaking 350 times what their workers earn.

Meanwhile, as the very rich become much richer, working families continue to struggle. Unbelievably, despite huge increases in worker productivity, wages (accounting for real inflation) are lower today than they were almost 50 years ago.

Today, half of our people live paycheck to paycheck and millions struggle on starvation wages. Despite a lifetime of work, half of older Americans have no savings and no idea how they will ever be able to retire with dignity, while 55% of seniors are trying to survive on an income of less than $25,000 a year.

Let’s be clear. The most important economic and political issues facing this country are the extraordinary levels of income and wealth inequality, the rapidly growing concentration of ownership, the long-term decline of the American middle class and the evolution of this country into an oligarchy.

We know how important these issues are because our ruling class works overtime to prevent them from being seriously discussed. They are barely mentioned in the halls of Congress, where most members are dependent on the campaign contributions of the wealthy and their Super Pacs. They are not much discussed in the corporate media, in which a handful of conglomerates determine what we see, hear and discuss.

Let us stand together and fight back against corporate greed and a corrupt political system that serves the top 1%."


 
I don't believe in confiscation of wealth, but I do believe that there is a reason for high MARGINAL taxation.
Wealth confiscation is an authoritarian version of socialism I don't agree with, but marginal taxation incentivizes reinvestment in the American economy and it allows the wealthy to go on enjoying their wealth.
Marginal high taxes encourage the wealthy to reinvest instead, in their businesses, in society and in better pay and conditions for labor.
It harnesses capitalism as a tool to serve the working class first and foremost.
I don't believe in the confiscation of wealth and that's not the answer. The gov needs to institute price and wage controls. Top out the mass hoarding of earnings with a ceiling on personal and corporate income and wealth. It's far too excessive right now with corporations actually controlling governments thru campaign contributions, lobbying, and PACS. And raise the collective floor of poverty by providing the impoverished with their basic needs.

We'd have a much healthier economy and less financial disparity.
 
No, he's not. Though this goes to the root of the capitalist and gov systems being ethically challenged, corrupt and broken. It's so comprehensive that nobody knows where to start or how to sink their teeth into it. And, frankly, it doesn't fire people up like the smaller, more emotional and divisive issues.
I think Bernie's got it wrong.

It isn't capitalism nor free markets which are the 'controlling ruling class', it's the political elite class.

The same political elite class which has been failing the nation and it's peoples progressively worse for the last 30 years, and are now much more so worried about being reelected and lining their own pockets at the nation's expense than legislating and leading in the nation's best interests, both short term and long term.

Capitalism and free markets are based on, and founded on, a mutually beneficial free exchange of money for goods and services. If you don't like the price for the goods and services rendered, don't buy them. Rather simple.

It's when government, i.e. the political elites, entangle themselves in this, where it always goes seriously wrong.
(To be honest there are a rare few exceptions, in which the 'light touch' legislation improves matters, but these are the exceptions to the general rule)

Blaming the ills of society on capitalism goes all the way back to Marx, so coming from Bernie, it's no surprise in the least, him being a progressive Marxist, or near as close to one not to be able to tell the difference.
 
Last edited:

“The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.”​


No truer words.
Oh, yes. I always look to Margaret Thatcher for my deep-thinking needs.
 
I think Bernie's got it wrong.

It isn't capitalism nor free markets which are the 'controlling ruling class', it's the political elite class.

The same political elite class which has been failing the nation and it's peoples progressively worse for the last 30 years, and are now much more so worried about being reelected and lining their own pockets at the nation's expense than legislating and leading in the nation's best interests, both short term and long term.

Capitalism and free markets are based on, and founded on, a mutually beneficial free exchange of money for goods and services. If you don't like the price for the goods and services rendered, don't buy them. Rather simple.

It's when government, i.e. the political elites, entangle themselves in this, where it always goes seriously wrong.
(To be honest there are a rare few exceptions, in which the 'light touch' legislation improves matters, but these are the exceptions to the general rule)

Blaming the ills of society on capitalism goes all the way back to Marx, so coming from Bernie, it's no surprise in the least, him being a progressive Marxist, or near as close to one not to be able to tell the difference.
That's a simplistic and Pollyannaish view of capitalism which totally ignores the reality.
 
And I don't see Bernie Sanders redistributing his own wealth from book sales
Right, because all socialists must be dirt poor. Fact of the matter is, Berne has 1/100th the net worth of Rick Scott, the wealthiest senator. And he doesn't take yacht vacations or escape to Cancun when his state is in a crisis.
 
I think Bernie's got it wrong.

It isn't capitalism nor free markets which are the 'controlling ruling class', it's the political elite class.

The same political elite class which has been failing the nation and it's peoples progressively worse for the last 30 years, and are now much more so worried about being reelected and lining their own pockets at the nation's expense than legislating and leading in the nation's best interests, both short term and long term.

Capitalism and free markets are based on, and founded on, a mutually beneficial free exchange of money for goods and services. If you don't like the price for the goods and services rendered, don't buy them. Rather simple.

It's when government, i.e. the political elites, entangle themselves in this, where it always goes seriously wrong.
(To be honest there are a rare few exceptions, in which the 'light touch' legislation improves matters, but these are the exceptions to the general rule)

Blaming the ills of society on capitalism goes all the way back to Marx, so coming from Bernie, it's no surprise in the least, him being a progressive Marxist, or near as close to one not to be able to tell the difference.
The political elite class is bought for and controlled by the capitalist extremists, or other words, the extremely wealthy and leveraged. Capitalism is fine but not open-ended, where there's an increasing disparity in finances between people. That kind of economy erodes the middle class to extinction.
 
The political elite class is bought for and controlled by the capitalist extremists, or other words, the extremely wealthy and leveraged.
All the more reason to kick the political elite class to the curb. One of the reasons Trump was so hated was that he couldn't be controlled by the political elites, nor their patrons - mind not all capitalist are extremists nor are all capitalist controlling, or trying to control, the political elites.

Capitalism is fine but not open-ended, where there's an increasing disparity in finances between people.
That's 'Capitalism is fine but not open-ended, just as long as none of the capitalists make more money that I think they should'.


That kind of economy erodes the middle class to extinction.
The Biden economy and inflation is what's eroding the middle class to extinction at the moment.
Continued government tax hikes are what erodes the middle class to extinction.
Continued government excessive and expensive regulations are what erodes the middle class to extinction.
 
Here is what has killed the working/middle class. Tax cuts for the rich has allowed them to keep it all and they have.


MARGINAL-TAX-RATES.webp

download.webp


10-21-10inc-f3.webp
 
If the choice is ruling class or Trumpers, I'll take ruling class. We can call it oligarchy is it makes anyone happy, I'll still take it over fascism.
Is you answer the same if a choice of "Democracy as we now know it" is one of the options?
 
Is you answer the same if a choice of "Democracy as we now know it" is one of the options?

I'm rather satisfied with the free world and wish to actively see it exported to the oppressed. I'm the opposite of a nationalist, a globalist. I'm not a socialist, but they're not as bad as nationalists.

Democracy as we know it now is fine. It functions. Every generation, more rights are recognized and protected. Every generation, we become more inclusive more diverse and stronger. The tyrants, not free men, will fall.
 
I'm rather satisfied with the free world and wish to actively see it exported to the oppressed. I'm the opposite of a nationalist, a globalist. I'm not a socialist, but they're not as bad as nationalists.

Democracy as we know it now is fine. It functions. Every generation, more rights are recognized and protected. Every generation, we become more inclusive more diverse and stronger. The tyrants, not free men, will fall.
Any concerns about a Civil war screwing everything up?
 
Any concerns about a Civil war screwing everything up?

The South has Risen. It will be put down again, this time without bloodshed.
 
Back
Top Bottom