TRUMP and IMMIGRATION
Part I
Mostly I find his positions to be incredibly unAmerican.
Banning Muslims. Even though I understand the reasoning behind it, it's too unAmerican for my blood. Also worth mentioning, to use Trumpian terms, it's a disaster.
Experts Say Trump'''s Muslim Ban Would Cripple Immigration System - NBC News
Deporting Millions of Mexicans: Again, although I understand the reasoning behind it, the plan would be a disaster.
Economic costs of deporting all undocumented immigrants - Business Insider
Building a wall: Same argument
Trump?s Wall: Impractical, Impolitic, Impossible
Sorry for the delay, but I was addressing other issues on the order presented by the members.
You noted that I already addressed your concern about Trump v. NATO in a joint response. The other issues were all related to immigration so I'll try to address them in this one post.
1. Banning Muslims. Even though I understand the reasoning behind it, it's too unAmerican for my blood. Also worth mentioning, to use Trumpian terms, it's a disaster.
Here is his quote, read from his campaign statement:
Donald J. Trump is calling for a total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States until our country's representatives can figure out what is going on.
Donald Trump speech in full: What the Republican presidential candidate said about Muslims | Americas | News | The Independent
So he originally made this statement and as the facts presented later show (from your citation) it would be a difficult, if not impossible issue to enforce...based solely on religion. So when he made this original statement to win points after a recent spate of terrorists attacks in Europe, it was not a well-thought out position. So some concerns are valid.
Having said that, I must point out that while denial until we "figures things out" based solely on religion is unrealistic; asking a religion question as part of the immigration vetting process accompanied by thorough background checking might help the process of minimizing easy-access to terrorists from Muslim dominated countries. I have no expertise in the area of immigration, so I can't assert how feasible this would be.
2. Deporting Millions of Mexicans: Again, although I understand the reasoning behind it, the plan would be a disaster.
This is a hard issue to address,
because whether or not we can effectively deport Illegal Mexican aliens and what effect it can have on the American economy is a matter or pure opinion. For example, in your citation referring to jobs an argument is made that "using estimates of output per worker in each of those industries, that the cost in lost output would be in the hundreds of billions of dollars. 'Overall, removing all undocumented immigrants would cause private sector output to decline by between $381.5 billion and $623.2 billion. This translates to a 2.9 percent to 4.7 percent reduction in total annual output from the private sector.'"
But the counter-argument is that this would open up a vast job market for American labor. People often insist that illegals do jobs that American's don't want, but that is an
argumentum ad populum. At least one of our Forum members, whom I respect for his intelligent posts,
is a free-lance jack-of-all-trades laborer from Texas. There are over 750,000 Americans working in Farm jobs, and this site (quoting 2009 Bureau of Labor Statistic figures) show there are many American just like him who would be willing to put in a hard days work for a fair days wage in jobs most Illegals are hired to do.
https://www.numbersusa.org/pages/jobs-americans-wont-do
The only people who would be negatively affected (aside from the illegals) are the businesses who increase their profit margins by hiring illegals for an unfair and untaxed wage.
Furthermore, the INS can do, and has done in the past, a fairly good job of rounding up and deporting illegals. The problems seem to lie in keeping them out once deported, or having amnesty/release programs interfere in the process due to political agendas.
Moreover, it has worked in the past:
Operation Wetback was an immigration law enforcement initiative created by Director of the U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service Joseph Swing in cooperation with the Mexican government.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Wetback
Trumps position is feasible.