• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Taliban say they now control 85% of Afghanistan's territory

These wars are impossible to win unless using ancient tactics and the tactics Mohammed himself used to covert people all the way to France and India.

The method? Killing 200,000,000 - the equal to well over a billion today. Ancient war was war of terror and no tolerance. If any city or village didn't do everyone demanded, turn over they young males to serve in their military, pay and do anything demanded, did not convert, everyone would be killed - no exceptions - and the city destroyed. Then move on to the next. There was little tolerance for other religions and if allowed, highly oppressed and taxed.

This was how war was done. Unless willing to kill and mass kill at the slightest opposition, making it clear the way you deal with insurgents hiding out is to kill everyone that may possibly be related, their entire clam, their village and just keep killing. Torture. Rape. That was the practice of every empire and nearly all ancient warfare - and it works if the goal is conquest, occupation and PERMANENT submission generation to generation - those people literally becoming one of your own nationality and military service.


Take it easy, Joko, dont blow your cover, buddy.

😁
 
If we had stayed one year, ten years, or one hundred years; the end result would be the same. Multiple "empires" have passed through Afghanistan only to leave it the same as when they first arrived.
Lets look back at Joko's evolving opinion of removing troops from Afghanistan, shall we?







It is like he does not even bother to hide how he was for whatever Trump did, and against whatever Biden does, even when it is the exact same thing.
Joko only exists here to troll, he gets his rocks off doing it. Taking him seriously at his word about anything is foolish. He opinion is as useless as an 8 track player.
 
This thread took a right wing turn somewhere and the OP started talking about raping, killing and torturing people in a merciless religious war, without care for the toll on a region... cause you gotta be like the Khans or Mohammedians or Barbarosa types to really get stuff done.

Think about that for a bit.
 
ladies and gentlemen, our poster here loves nation building that goes on FOREVER!

Right. We pull our troops out and what we leave behind lasts for all of a couple of weeks.

It shows how good we are at "nation building" and what a colossal waste of money and material we spent to put together a group (for decades mind you) that then surrendered everything without any real attempt at a fight.
 
This thread took a right wing turn somewhere and the OP started talking about raping, killing and torturing people in a merciless religious war, without care for the toll on a region... cause you gotta be like the Khans or Mohammedians or Barbarosa types to really get stuff done.

Think about that for a bit.

There aren't historical examples of long term stable states being run in Afghanistan.

Not Persia, not Alexander the Great, Not the Mongolian Kans, not the Soviets, not America.
 
Lets look back at Joko's evolving opinion of removing troops from Afghanistan, shall we?







It is like he does not even bother to hide how he was for whatever Trump did, and against whatever Biden does, even when it is the exact same thing.

That is a well researched post. None of it has to do with Trump, but does have to do about Biden.

Skip the rest, but this it my actual opinion.

Yes, I oppose an occupying military force in Iraq on the ground. President Biden should have ordered the destruction of American military equipment, weapons and munitions subject to being captured - and did not. We can destroy anything anywhere in Iraq from the air. Except for what we are certain is safely in the government held areas, destroy all military equipment and assets of the Taliban territory - until either an accord is made between them, the Iraq government defeats the Taliban, or the Taliban defeats the government. Iranians? Kill ever Iranian we can find in Iraq and any other foreign militarily adversarial group or force.

It was Reagan who came to understand the way to deal with terrorism is greater counter terrorism. After the bombing in Lebanon, he had the USS Missouri battleship fire salvo after salvo into where people were cheering the deaths of our personnel. The point made was they had no defense against that battleship. War is hell and wars in that region have always been fought this way. Now, our military air power vastly equates many battleships, for any part of Iraq with also near immunity.

It becomes a poker game. With Biden shifting hundreds of billions to Russia by shutting down American oil and gas exploration - and removing the obstacles for Russia to have all of EU's oil and gas money for still far more hundreds of billions, Biden is totally financing Russia's military rebuild and to be capable of engage us in proxy wars - using the money Biden literally gave them by Executive Order.

So, we, Biden surrendered and in a way that gives Iraq to Iran, and will have turned that region over to a Russian, Syrian, Iraq, and Iranian alliance that he thus will have created.

Additionally, by eliminating the USA being independent in relation to oil and gas, economic forces will cause us to remain in battle in the region, or we again have Jimmy Carter's cry of "WE HAVE AN ENERGY CRISIS" so can't light the White House Christmas tree. All for the pipedream of shifting at light speed to other ways to make electricity, vehicles, boats, aircraft, plastics and all the things oil and gas do and are required for. Gamble the fate of the nation of that fantasy and a believe that if we are nice and give them whatever they want, Russia, China, Iran and all other countries will be nice and generous to us.

AGAIN, my highest praise for your research and messages. On face value, you gunned me down. I have a kid who has repeatedly been in combat missions over both both war countries and most in the region. Thus, it is a topic area of interest to me. Also many discussions with a Marine squad leader who was in combat in Afghanistan. We can never win an enduring war there by presence on the ground. No matter our justification, we are a foreign invader and occupier, of different races, intolerable immoralities, and nearly all are infidels. Instead, we back the side we want to win otherwise if we think possible or - if possible - make it a quagmire endless stalemate, one that we are not occupying the country, not an invading army and with virtually no casualties on our side.
 
This thread took a right wing turn somewhere and the OP started talking about raping, killing and torturing people in a merciless religious war, without care for the toll on a region... cause you gotta be like the Khans or Mohammedians or Barbarosa types to really get stuff done.

Think about that for a bit.

The OP started on a right wing track.

Almost every word of his post was false, sometimes ridiculously so.
 
MOSCOW (AP) — The Taliban claimed on Friday that they now control 85% of Afghanistan’s territory amid a surge in wins on the ground and as American troops complete their pullout from the war-battered country.

The announcement came at a press conference at the end of a visit by a senior Taliban delegation to Moscow this week — a trip meant to offer assurances that the insurgents’ quick gains in Afghanistan do not threaten Russia or its allies in Central Asia.


The first Biden did was shut down American oil and gas exploration to give all that national wealth to Russia. Next, he lifted sanctions to give Russia all of the EU's gas and oil business - trillions for his pal Putin and Russia.

He also ordered shutting down gas pipeline and pushing ending using fossil fuels - as all energy costs to Americans - and pushing electric cars - to benefit China by giving China a massive low energy costs for their industries and people - as China is building dozens of new coal burn plants.

He is open that he will allow Iran to get nuclear warheads to put on their missiles.

Did anyone doubt he would give Afghanistan to the Taliban?

It seems obvious he will comply with his instructions from Kim Jung Un

Biden is the most traitorous president possible, essentially a foreign agent of Russia and China. It's just a lie to fly the American flag over the White House. It should be the Chinese flag above the Russian flag, and the White House should be painted red. Stop the lies. He is converting the USA to being nothing but one of China's provinces, while completely rebuilding Russia's economy - and therefore military - ultimately trillions from the American economy to the Russian economy. He gave Russia control of world oil and therefore energy, and is giving China the last of American industry.

Basically the future of the USA is that economy is Big Tech, Amazon, WalMart and other big box international companies - all of which are the advertising agencies and retailers for Chinese products made in Chinese factories in joint Chinese plutocrats - American plutocrats global monopoly. The guardians of freedom, the middle merchant class, was destroyed by the covid-19 bioterrorism campaign on TV, in newspapers and and online - that the plutocrats 90+% control. The propaganda was that all small low traffic businesses must be ordered illegal and permanently eliminated (over half a million so far) - claiming you are not safe unless packed into a WalMart, other big box store, or from Amazon Prime with 20,000 covid-19 postive employees mailing covid 19 all over the country. In fact, they would get covid-19 to you often within a day to assure maximum remaining covid-19 on the packaging and product.

You may want to convert any money and accounts you have to necessities of life. Inflation is going to erase money and savings. Also liquidate stock, that will not be able to keep up with increasing inflation rates. It isn't long before the world and petro monetary system will not longer be the American dollar. When that happened the value of the dollar falls thru the floor - permanently - and there is no domestic production to even try to fall back on. The USA already is a beggar to China for goods and products paid for on IOUs and by American land and businesses.

BIden fully surrendered to Russia and China, the easiest colonization of another country probably in known history.
Attack Biden using the spaghetti method of arguing — Afghanistan failure; Russian puppet; Kim Jung Un puppet; Chinese puppet; inflation!

The OP is merely ranting about things he got from who-knows-where. Fortunately, none of it is true. I’m not going to debate nonsense.
 
In a country where, even under the Americans, Sharia law was in force... um... are you serious?
A democracy only for men from destroyed clans? This is something new.
Afghanistan is a deeply religious country, what kind of democracy are we talking about?
A generation of women grew up going to school and living less restrictive lives. They’re not going to take it.
 
And trump surrendered to Erdogan and left the kurds guarding our terrorist prisoners THOUSANDS OF THEM letting them back on the battlefield. ALSO YOU KNOW TRUMP WOULD HAVE PULLED OUT OF AFGHANASTAN AS WELL - GET REAL.

I have a strong suspicion that Joko’s real source for his OP was RT, or some other Russian site. The group that would turn into the Trump crowd has been fed a lot of Russian propoganda over the last decade or so. Some of them have been parroting this stuff for nearly a decade now.

Some of them actually boasted when Trump did what Erdogen and Putin wanted him to do and abandoned northern Syria and Western Iraq.
 
The Taliban are pretty similar to the Trump Cultists.

They also come mostly from rural, backwards areas and think they are entitled to overthrow their governments by use of force.
 
I have a strong suspicion that Joko’s real source for his OP was RT, or some other Russian site. The group that would turn into the Trump crowd has been fed a lot of Russian propoganda over the last decade or so. Some of them have been parroting this stuff for nearly a decade now.

Some of them actually boasted when Trump did what Erdogen and Putin wanted him to do and abandoned northern Syria and Western Iraq.
 
I have a strong suspicion that Joko’s real source for his OP was RT, or some other Russian site. The group that would turn into the Trump crowd has been fed a lot of Russian propoganda over the last decade or so. Some of them have been parroting this stuff for nearly a decade now.

Some of them actually boasted when Trump did what Erdogen and Putin wanted him to do and abandoned northern Syria and Western Iraq.
I hate to say it but I agree. His OP stinks like Russian propaganda. So horrible the GOP formerly our protectors, are now on their knees before Putin.
 
The Taliban are pretty similar to the Trump Cultists.

They also come mostly from rural, backwards areas and think they are entitled to overthrow their governments by use of force.
Oh look! A politically incendiary post!
 
Let's see if I get this right:

When Trump was drawing down troops in Afghanistan and promising to bring all the troops home, the Right were saying "about time, not our job to police the world."

Now Biden has done the same, and we get threads that Biden has " fully surrendered to Russia and China ".

You just can't make this kinda stuff up, this is the thinking process of those on the Right.
 
The Taliban are pretty similar to the Trump Cultists.

They also come mostly from rural, backwards areas and think they are entitled to overthrow their governments by use of force.
BINGO!
 
MOSCOW (AP) — The Taliban claimed on Friday that they now control 85% of Afghanistan’s territory amid a surge in wins on the ground and as American troops complete their pullout from the war-battered country.

The announcement came at a press conference at the end of a visit by a senior Taliban delegation to Moscow this week — a trip meant to offer assurances that the insurgents’ quick gains in Afghanistan do not threaten Russia or its allies in Central Asia.


The first Biden did was shut down American oil and gas exploration to give all that national wealth to Russia. Next, he lifted sanctions to give Russia all of the EU's gas and oil business - trillions for his pal Putin and Russia.

He also ordered shutting down gas pipeline and pushing ending using fossil fuels - as all energy costs to Americans - and pushing electric cars - to benefit China by giving China a massive low energy costs for their industries and people - as China is building dozens of new coal burn plants.

He is open that he will allow Iran to get nuclear warheads to put on their missiles.

Did anyone doubt he would give Afghanistan to the Taliban?

It seems obvious he will comply with his instructions from Kim Jung Un

Biden is the most traitorous president possible, essentially a foreign agent of Russia and China. It's just a lie to fly the American flag over the White House. It should be the Chinese flag above the Russian flag, and the White House should be painted red. Stop the lies. He is converting the USA to being nothing but one of China's provinces, while completely rebuilding Russia's economy - and therefore military - ultimately trillions from the American economy to the Russian economy. He gave Russia control of world oil and therefore energy, and is giving China the last of American industry.

Basically the future of the USA is that economy is Big Tech, Amazon, WalMart and other big box international companies - all of which are the advertising agencies and retailers for Chinese products made in Chinese factories in joint Chinese plutocrats - American plutocrats global monopoly. The guardians of freedom, the middle merchant class, was destroyed by the covid-19 bioterrorism campaign on TV, in newspapers and and online - that the plutocrats 90+% control. The propaganda was that all small low traffic businesses must be ordered illegal and permanently eliminated (over half a million so far) - claiming you are not safe unless packed into a WalMart, other big box store, or from Amazon Prime with 20,000 covid-19 postive employees mailing covid 19 all over the country. In fact, they would get covid-19 to you often within a day to assure maximum remaining covid-19 on the packaging and product.

You may want to convert any money and accounts you have to necessities of life. Inflation is going to erase money and savings. Also liquidate stock, that will not be able to keep up with increasing inflation rates. It isn't long before the world and petro monetary system will not longer be the American dollar. When that happened the value of the dollar falls thru the floor - permanently - and there is no domestic production to even try to fall back on. The USA already is a beggar to China for goods and products paid for on IOUs and by American land and businesses.

BIden fully surrendered to Russia and China, the easiest colonization of another country probably in known history.

Thank you for another great example of "mindlessly following what FOX News and OnAN tell you to think".

PS - If you are against the Chinese buying up "American Land" and/or "American Businesses" - have you ever asked yourself "Who is selling to them?"? (HINT - It isn't the Lithuanians). And if you are against Americans being so in debt to the Chinese - have you ever asked yourself "Who is borrowing from them?"? (HINT - It isn't the Burmese).
 
Oh... are you saying his opinions are batshit crazy and contradictory?

Well, he's not gonna like that.

Sir!

As the duly authorized representative of "Bats Of The World United", I demand that you immediately retract that scurrilous and demeaning specist claim.

PS - I also represent "United Bedbugs of the World", and "Amalgamated Jaybirds and Loons" so don't go there either.
 
If after 20 years of trying to build up an Afghan force that could hold back the Taliban we couldnt do it, then you can only conclude that the Afghans arent all that unhappy with Taliban rule.

Welcome to "Blind Pig Time".

The Taliban govern the way that the Afghans have always been governed and are (generally speaking) more honest, effective, and tuned in to local needs (and feelings) than the "legal" government of Afghanistan is.

Now I wouldn't want to live in a country governed by the Taliban, but that doesn't mean that some other people wouldn't.
 
It was Reagan who came to understand the way to deal with terrorism is greater counter terrorism.

Is that why the Middle East stopped being a problem after 1988?
 

Everyone already knows the Democratic Party openly hates all rural people, all small town people, all blue collar workers and anyone else who isn't rich. The Democratic Party and the plutocrats see YOU as nothing, ignorant and backwards for which you agree you need them to tell you what to think, do, emotionally feel and say because you agree with them about yourself according to your messages.
 
Back
Top Bottom