• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it cou

Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it

I assume he won't be impeached for this...but I am guessing the Obama administration thought this would be a no-brainer, vote grabber but now might be having some second thoughts about the whole thing.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it


Agreed. The president is the "executive branch" not the judicial branch. If he feels a law is unconstitutional, he can forward his alleged case to the judicial branch (US Supreme Court). He cannot cherry pick which laws he chooses to enforce.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it


Or, is he derelict in his duty to "preserve, protect and defend" the Constitution by signing a law he believes is unconstitutional?
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it


No, Bill Clinton issued more than twice the amount of signing statements than Bush 43, although Bush's statements affected more than 1000 provisions of law, because he used multiple objections.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it

He will not be impeached. No one is willing to deal with the fallout that would occur if he was. We are all going to just keep walking on eggshells until he is out of office, and then try to repair the damage he has done to this country.
If he is not impeached by the House then the damage will be permanent. Belize is looking better every day.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it

Name for me the democrat senators that will vote for impeachment. In fact, name one.
Senators do not vote for impeachment. That is the House's responsibility.

So impeach the SOB and then arrest him for the felony (or two, or three or more) that he has committed.
Personally aid and comfort to a terrorist organization is enough for a life behind bars.
I would prefer the death penalty. Some say I aim too high.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it

If what I understand to be going on is correct, it is illegal because congress cannot pass a law that limits executive power.
Why do you believe that? Every law limits executive branch power.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it


Senators vote to remove an impeached president from office.

The rest of your post is lunacy.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it


A lynching?
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it

It requires no senate votes to impeach the president. Impeachment occurs in the House of Representatives.
Impeachment proceedings may be commenced by a member of the House of Representatives on their own initiative, either by presenting a listing of the charges under oath, or by asking for referral to the appropriate committee​

and...

A simple majority of those present and voting is required for each article or the resolution as a whole to pass. If the House votes to impeach, managers (typically referred to as "House managers", with a "lead House manager") are selected to present the case to the Senate.​

So impeach the SOB. Then arrest him for breaking the law. Put him in prison until the trial. He is a flight risk. And finally find the SOB guilty and lock him up for life.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it


As anyone dared ask the question, "Why would you promote a PFC to Sgt while held in captivity if said PFC was a deserter? I'm familiar with battlefield promotions, but PFC Bergdahl wasn't on the battlefield when the promotion was given. So, why promote a "deserter"?
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it

Senators vote to remove an impeached president from office.
Great. Confirmed.

The rest of your post is lunacy.
Perhaps only because of your love of tyranny as long as it is exercised for your team.

I would like to see a firing squad for this offense. Is that too much to ask?
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it

A lynching?
I prefer firing squad but a hanging (remember this would be legal--lynching were not) would be fine.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it

Perhaps only because of your love of tyranny as long as it is exercised for your team.

I don't think you know what "tyranny" means.

I would like to see a firing squad for this offense. Is that too much to ask?

Yes. In fact, it's utterly insane.

The fact that you think, over a prisoner-for-prisoner swap, we should shoot the twice duly elected President of the United States, then you have left Earth's gravitational pull and are headed at cruising speed toward Planet Crazy.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it

I don't think you know what "tyranny" means.
I know quite well. We are living in a soft tyranny. The hard part usually comes later.

He appears to have committed treason, offering aid and comfort to our enemy during war. He needs to be tried, convicted and then executed.

If we can only get him on a lesser charge then life in prison would be barely acceptable.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it

He appears to have committed treason, offering aid and comfort to our enemy during war. He needs to be tried, convicted and then executed.

If we can only get him on a lesser charge then life in prison would be barely acceptable.

The idea that Obama has committed treason is weapons-grade stupid.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it

The idea that Obama has committed treason is weapons-grade stupid.
Cool. I am not surprised that you defend the traitor. How much more aid and comfort could he provide than to return their top people?
Impeach the SOB. Then arrest him, try him, convict him. I want the death penalty. You just want him to remain your king. Got it.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it


:roll:
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it

The idea that Obama has committed treason is weapons-grade stupid.
Treason is not a word that I would use to describe his actions in this case. I would, though, characterize those actions as "tactically symbolic".

I truly believe that he believes he is poking a stick in the eye of everyone who supported our military actions post 9-11 and by making a defacto hero out of a deserter he is saying that the real heroes are the ones who refused to support our post 9-11 policies.

You can't tell me that he didn't know every single little piece of dirt on this guy before he agreed to this deal.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it


Because he's not a deserter - yet. He's simply AWOL. To be guilty of desertion he has to have intended to be away from his post permanently, which I don't think they can ascertain without actually talking to him. It also requires a court martial.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it


You do know that we've been doing prisoner exchanges with the enemy since the Revolution don't you? If those weren't treasonous acts, if those didn't give aid and comfort to the enemy how is this any different?

And as practical matter you also do understand that no former President will likely ever see the inside of a jail.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it

If there is a God.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it


Time will tell what the military will classify him as, but he seems to have given aid to the enemy and cost US service men's lives.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it

If there is a God.

Please, PLEASE attempt to impeach Obama over this.
 
Re: Taliban prisoner swap was ILLEGAL claims GOP as former federal prosecutor says it


He was suspect of desertion and treason almost immediately according to his platoon critics. You don't need a court martial not to promote someone under suspicion.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…