• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Supreme Court blocks vaccine mandate for large businesses

nobody claimed they would 100% be able to.

you can in no way support this statement.

why would you care if there were more mail in voting? We know from literally every single investigation every done, mostly by republicans, that voter fraud is statistically zero. So why is mail in voting a problem for you? I'll answer it for you. More people voting means republicans lose.

Lmao.

If vaccines don't stop variants, then we're going to have variants whether everyone is vaccinated or not. That statement is common sense and supports itself.

As for mail in ballots? I assure you as the midterm elections get closer and democrat party fails to federalize elections or end fillibusters the lunatics will ramp up the howling for mail in voting and relaxed I'd laws and less election security.

It's just the new normal with the democrat party playbook.
Democrat party Wacko's don't like who gets put on the supreme court or a law vote doesn't go thier way, we all have to board up the windows and watch the freaks get set off the leash.
 
Lmao.

If vaccines don't stop variants, then we're going to have variants whether everyone is vaccinated or not. That statement is common sense and supports itself.
yet you couldn't support it lol.
As for mail in ballots? I assure you as the midterm elections get closer and democrat party fails to federalize elections or end fillibusters the lunatics will ramp up the howling for mail in voting and relaxed I'd laws and less election security.
elections are quite secure. why are mail in ballots a problem? Why is voter ID needed? every single investigation every done shows voter fraud simply isn't an issue.
It's just the new normal with the democrat party playbook.
what playbook? allowing people to vote? lol
Democrat party Wacko's don't like who gets put on the supreme court or a law vote doesn't go thier way, we all have to board up the windows and watch the freaks get set off the leash.
as opposed to when cry baby trumpers don't get their way, and they commit sedition? lol
 
yet you couldn't support it lol.

elections are quite secure. why are mail in ballots a problem? Why is voter ID needed? every single investigation every done shows voter fraud simply isn't an issue.

what playbook? allowing people to vote? lol

as opposed to when cry baby trumpers don't get their way, and they commit sedition? lol

🙄

Wow. Just wow.
 
In other words, I didn't get the shot and I'm fine with anyone else who did or didn't for thier own reasons.

In other words, **** errbody else. I don't care how contagious I am. If it's going to inconvenience me, I'm not interested, despite the fact that you may or may not end up on a ventilator.

Stay classy, dude.
 
In other words, **** errbody else. I don't care how contagious I am. If it's going to inconvenience me, I'm not interested, despite the fact that you may or may not end up on a ventilator.

Stay classy, dude.

Yeah, I don't feel the need to dictate what anyone else does for thier own health and lives.

And I don't pretend anybody but me is responsible for my own health and life.



So yeah I'll stay classy.
 
Yeah, I don't feel the need to dictate what anyone else does for thier own health and lives.

And I don't pretend anybody but me is responsible for my own health and life.



So yeah I'll stay classy.


*SMMFH*

I'm going to speak very slowly here - then I'm walking away.

If ... you ... are ... contagious ... then ... you ... DO ... dictate ... the ... lives ... of ... others ...

You are basically a living, breathing Typhoid Mary, and you don't give a ****.

Well done, you.
 
"You can't debate with stupid, they'll just drag you down to thier level and beat you with experience" - Mark Twain
It's not my fault you post moronic conspiracy theories that are easily disproven lol.
 
Hmmm, sure sounds like manipulation of statistics.

If Republicans didn't believe lies, why did they follow Trump and why do they watch Fox, OAN, etc., that's basically 24/7 B.S.?

In reality, science is not perfect, nor are medical institutions like the CDC that strive to give us public health data for policy. Accepting and correcting mistakes is part of being a big boy/girl. Grow the **** up.
 
“Never argue with stupid people, they will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience.” Mark Twain
That is exactly why I decided to not reply to anything the rahl ever posts again. No matter how stupid it is.
 
Another day, another Biden failure.





Obviously the legal issues at stake here are getting overlooked due to paranoia and irrationality surrounding the issue at hand.
 
If Republicans didn't believe lies, why did they follow Trump and why do they watch Fox, OAN, etc., that's basically 24/7 B.S.?

In reality, science is not perfect, nor are medical institutions like the CDC that strive to give us public health data for policy. Accepting and correcting mistakes is part of being a big boy/girl. Grow the **** up.
Funny you should even bring up those news agencies. The article I posted was from Newsweek.

CDC is not perfect? Say it ain't so.
Mistakes is one thing. Intentional manipulation is something else. Incentivize hospitals that they receive more money if they are treating more covid patients and guess what you will create every reason to report a patient as covid regardless of the reason they are there. It ain't complicated to understand if you truly want to, wise up.
 
Incentivize hospitals that they receive more money if they are treating more covid patients
Oh lordy, I wish our education system was better.
 
It doesn't matter how many times you trumpers parrot this lie. The overwhelming VAST majority of the unvaccinated are trump supporters or right wingers.
Who are these "you Trumpers"? Why do you on the left always assume that anyone who questions the group think which comes from the left, are automatically "Trumpers".
you can not in any way support this claim
https://english.elpais.com/usa/2021...reeding-ground-for-coronavirus-mutations.html

https://www.theguardian.com/comment...ovid-variant-rich-countries-hoarding-vaccines

So, more batshit crazy conspiracies. lol
Like I said, do a little research on the illegal activity, and other civil lawsuits against big pharma companies, Pfizer being one of the worst

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pfizer#Legal_issues

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_pharmaceutical_settlements


nope. It wasn't to appease political interests, it was done to try and get the ****ing moronic anti vaxx trumpers to get vaccinated.
Biden's administration KNEW before they made a mandate that it wasn't constitutional.

I don't agree with a govn't mandate by the way. The govn't has exactly zero authority to do so, other than for govn't employees.
Good. Now place some needed blame on Joe Biden and company for the current problems. Why keep blaming Donald Trump? He has been out of office for a year.

this isn't questioning authority. this is total science denial, and partisan hackery.

Until you admit the partisan hackery coming from the left, then you cannot really claim that any hackery on the right is unique.

when the entire medical community is telling you that you need to get vaccinated, because of the dozens and dozens of peer reviewed studies showing their efficacy, and the data showing that the majority of the current spike is among the unvaccinated, if you have more than 2 brain cells to rub together, you would get vaxxed.

I trust my own doctor. When I had questions about the risk vs reward of getting the vaccine he took the time to explain to me how based on my age, and a couple of factors, that it was in my best interest to be vaccinated. When boosters became available, he cautioned me to wait, but then said to go ahead and get boosted---which was right around the time we were hearing about omicron and in the weeks before fall/winter. And now he is saying NOT to continue to get boosted, and shift to therapeutics administered in the event of a cross over infection. So, to assume people like me are not listening to science/doctors is false.

I am not comparing our government to the PRC. But do you actually believe our government/leaders are not capable of deceit?

Gulf of Tonkin incident
The Pentagon Papers
Watergate
Iraqi WMDs
Patriot Act will be used to spy on citizens
"If you like your doctor you can keep your doctor"
"Your President is not a crook"-- Richard Nixon
"I did not have sexual relations with that woman" - Bill Clinton
Donald Trump saying he had no knowledge of payments by his lawyers to ex porn star Stormy Daniels

All lies


of course we would. lots of vaccines require boosters.

Yeah, after 10-20 years maybe. But expecting to take mRNA boosters for covid 19 every 6 months is a very bad idea. One which has not been researched, and one which may not be reversible later on.
why are you asking me questions about a position I am not supporting?
Probably because you insist on claiming that only Trump supporters are "antivax" when in fact many people are resisting or opting out for other reasons, many of them very good reasons.


I agree that is all you've done. You jumped in and quoted my post, which was a direct response to @Taylor blaming biden. I simply called out that laughably moronic bit of hypocrisy.
I believe there is blame to go around a lot of places, including Donald Trump for some things. However, Trump isn't the guy in charge now, that guy is Joe Biden

I have never stated anything to the contrary.
But you are blaming Trump supporters. They didn't create this virus.
 

Supreme Court blocks vaccine mandate for large businesses​

In the United States, the Supreme Court ruled in Jacobson v. Massachusetts (1905) that states have the authority to require vaccination against smallpox during a smallpox epidemic. All fifty U.S states require that children be vaccinated to attend public school, although 47 states provide exemptions based on religious or philosophical beliefs.


1) How does the Supreme Court reconcile its current decision with the 1905 decision granting states the authority requiring the parents enrolling their children in school to produce proof that they've received the prescribed vaccinations for infectious diseases?

2) Given that this applies to both public and private schools - what is the legal principle that would explain as to why a private business with over 100+ employees should be exempt from legislation requiring compulsory vaccination from a private school with over 100+ students where vaccinations have been mandatory for decades?

If you read the ruling, the Court said that the reason the hold was reinstated was because the virus had spread beyond the workplace and was thus beyond the jurisdiction of OSHA.

As the dissent noted, the Court's majority did not dispute the fact that COVID-19 fell under OSHA's authority, but rather they argued because it's so widespread OSHA can't claim responsibility for handling it.

SCOTUS is in effect taking an active role in forming national policy, rather than actually doing what it is supposed to do; interpret statutes.
 
Perhaps Kavanaugh isn't as much of an originalist as all the screechers thought he was? He's certainly been a mixed bag on the court.

More than anything Kavanaugh is just a bad justice.
 
I thought It was brilliant considering the individual didn’t know that so…was it pointless ?

To be brilliant it would have to have been a good point.

Claiming "we're a constitutional republic, not a democracy", is a pointless distinction because those points do not contradict each other.
 
To be brilliant it would have to have been a good point.

Claiming "we're a constitutional republic, not a democracy", is a pointless distinction because those points do not contradict each other.
Well, when someone is saying it’s a failure of “democracy” when we aren’t…it’s correcting a bad point to began with. Appreciate your “feedback” for a “pointless” distinction though…
 
Well, when someone is saying it’s a failure of “democracy” when we aren’t…

You're right, it's not a failure of democracy. It's a failure of judicial action done by Court that has become increasingly batshit stupid.
 
Back
Top Bottom