- Joined
- Jun 12, 2014
- Messages
- 11,283
- Reaction score
- 6,958
- Location
- https://www.debatepolitics.com
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Communist
Specialization of labor is promoted by supporters of capitalism, e.g. von Mises and Adam Smith.
Marx believed specialization of labor leads to alienation.
Right, but when he's hungry he has to go out and find someone who both wants arrows and has food to trade. This why barter markets are so inefficient, and why money is used instead. If he's really good at making arrows he can sell them to other tribes, and then he will start to accumulate capital for himself.
There are no socialist ideals here.
Specialization of labor does lead to alienation - Marx also believed that capitalism was a necessary step on the evolution of society towards a post-scarcity economy where society can support the health, happiness and liberty of humanity with a minimum amount of labor. There are some branches of socialism that reject the concept of money, indeed, but the base premise of socialism is a rejection of capitalist ruling classes who generate wealth entirely through ownership. You're arguing against a strawman.
It's also worth pointing that Adam Smith supported the labor theory of value, just as Karl Marx did. The man would most likely have been an anarchist if he'd lived to witness the industrial revolution.