In a way what you’re advocating is direct democracy. We know for the most part how Republicans and democrats will vote on the bills before congress. Partisanship reigns. Each party must convince a certain amount of swing voters to vote for them. The party’s bases are loyal and will vote for their party’s candidates regardless of who that candidate is or what stances on the issues they hold.
If a state constitution has voter referendums in it let the citizens of that state get together and have the abortion issue placed on the ballot. The problem is those for legal abortion all have different opinions on it, not whether abortion should be legal, but what restrictions should be placed on when and how abortion is legal.
Examples, 80% of all Americans think abortion should be legal in the case of rape, the health of the mother, incest. That falls to 60% of all Americans who think abortion should be legal in all circumstances during the first trimester. Only 28% of al all Americans think abortion should be legal up to the end of the second trimester. 19% think abortion should be legal with no restrictions or during the third trimester. Which one do you place on your ballot? There no consensus among democrats or those who think abortion should be legal.
https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/where-americans-stand-on-abortion-in-5-charts/
Graham’s bills on abortion, banning abortion after 15 weeks falls into the 60% approve category of all Americans. But both Democrats and most Republicans are totally against it. The Democrats want no restriction, abortions being legal until birth witch has the support of only 19% of the population. Republicans basically want all abortion illegal, that is but 13% of all Americans. Which category or restriction do you support, and which one should be on the ballot?
For me, I’ve always said the woman should decide. But abortion has never been a hot issue or an issue that decides how I’ll vote. I voted for pro-life and for pro-choice candidates in the past. This year I plan on voting for a pro-life candidate for governor, a pro-choice candidate for the House of Representatives and third party, Chase Oliver for the senate. I have no idea whether he’s pro-choice or pro-life. I just disliked the heck out of both Walker and Warnock, so I’ll vote against both. On the ballot, I’d vote for option A abortion legal only in the case rape, the health of the mother, incest. I’d also vote for option B abortion should be legal in all circumstances during the first trimester. Option C, I’d probably vote for, but with some reservations and deep thought, abortion should be legal up to the end of the second trimester. Option D abortion should be legal with no restrictions or during the third trimester to include partial birth abortions. Probably not. But it seems most Democrats only want option D.
I’m a swing voter, not loyal to either major party. In fact, I highly disdain both major parties as I think they’re responsible for all the problems this country not getting solved with their no compromise attitude and unwillingness to play the game of give and take or moderate their views to suit most Americans. Both major parties have become way too extreme for my blood and for more and more Americans as both major parties are shrinking. Independents, swing voters has risen from 30% of the electorate in 2006 to 42% today if Gallup and Pew Research are to be believed.