• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Russia shells near Zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant

You stil haven't explained why Ukraine would shell the nuclear facility at Enerhodar when Ukrainians are still manning the control rooms.

And why would Ukraine desire a nuclear accident on their own soil? The area around Chornobyl is still closed 38 years after the accident there.
Did I make that claim?

I was saying the claim is a lie, and that if it was shelled, it was shelled by Ukraine. Not Russia, as the Russian troops are already there.

Maybe you can explain why the Russians would shell their own troops if the report is true...
 
I was saying that if it was shelled, it was shelled by Ukraine. Not Russia, as the Russian troops are already there.

Despite contesting claims, you automatically side with Russia. That speaks volumes. It's amazing how Tumpers always sympathize with Putin.

And you persistently always forget to mention that Ukrainians are still manning the Enerhodar control rooms.

You cannot explain why Ukraine would kill their own Enerhodar facility staff, and perhaps also unleash a nuclear-radioactive-cloud over Ukrainian land.

And I would suggest that you examine how the Russians behaved when they occupied the Chornobyl nuclear facility early-on in the invasion


Maybe you can explain why the Russians would shell their own troops if the report is true...

The Russians are shelling everything in that area. Maybe you can explain that.

 
The Ukrainian military is deliberately targeting nuclear waste storage at the Zaporozhye Nuclear Power Plant to bring about a ‘dirty bomb’ explosion and make the area uninhabitable, Yevgeny Balitsky, the head of the Zaporozhye Region’s military-civilian administration, told the Rossiya-24 TV channel on Thursday.

"They were practically targeting the nuclear waste storage facility in order to create a kind of a 'dirty bomb' on our territory, to create the situation where there will be a release. <...> [In order] to lead to air contamination and make an entire territory uninhabitable," he stressed.

Thousands of tonnes of radioactive waste are stored at the plant, Balitsky went on to say. "Their (Ukrainian troops' - TASS) goals are, of course, clear to us. They want to scare us, they want to make unusable the territory they have already lost forever," he stated.

At the moment, the concrete protection of the facility ‘holds up’, he said. "But we find hits 300 meters away from the nuclear power plant, we find the shells that have almost hit, that are 20 meters away from the storage facility with nuclear waste. <...> If they hit the concrete storage facility accurately enough, than, which is frightful to think of, it will bring about something like what happened in Chernobyl - there will be a release, it will be a 'dirty bomb,'" Balitsky explained. According to him, Zaporozhye Region authorities have developed a plan that includes the evacuation of the population if the situation around the plant develops under a negative scenario.


The nuclear power plant in Energodar is under the control of the Russian troops. Over the past few days, Ukrainian forces have conducted several strikes on the premises, using drones, heavy artillery and multiple rocket launchers. Air defense systems repel attacks in most cases, but in some episodes, shells do hit infrastructure facilities, as well as the storage area.

As earlier reported, on Thursday, Ukraine’s armed forces conducted a massive shelling of the Zaporozhye NPP and the city of Energodar for the second time in one day. Previously, Russian air defense systems deflected all Ukrainian attacks with strike drones and heavy artillery on the city and the NPP overnight and on Thursday morning. Since early August, the Ukrainian army attempted to strike the NPP’s premises and the city at least five times. On August 5, the Ukrainian armed forces shelled a railway station three times, on August 6, they bombarded the NPP’s healthcare facility and a water supply facility in Energodar, and on August 7, another strike on the NPP hit the area where a storage facility for spent nuclear fuel was located.


In the Russia-Ukraine conflict, Ukraine's propaganda machinery has emerged a winner.
 
Last edited:
The Ukrainian military is deliberately targeting nuclear waste storage at the Zaporozhye Nuclear Power Plant to bring about a ‘dirty bomb’ explosion and make the area uninhabitable, Yevgeny Balitsky, the head of the Zaporozhye Region’s military-civilian administration, told the Rossiya-24 TV channel on Thursday.

"They were practically targeting the nuclear waste storage facility in order to create a kind of a 'dirty bomb' on our territory, to create the situation where there will be a release. <...> [In order] to lead to air contamination and make an entire territory uninhabitable," he stressed.

Thousands of tonnes of radioactive waste are stored at the plant, Balitsky went on to say. "Their (Ukrainian troops' - TASS) goals are, of course, clear to us. They want to scare us, they want to make unusable the territory they have already lost forever," he stated.

At the moment, the concrete protection of the facility ‘holds up’, he said. "But we find hits 300 meters away from the nuclear power plant, we find the shells that have almost hit, that are 20 meters away from the storage facility with nuclear waste. <...> If they hit the concrete storage facility accurately enough, than, which is frightful to think of, it will bring about something like what happened in Chernobyl - there will be a release, it will be a 'dirty bomb,'" Balitsky explained. According to him, Zaporozhye Region authorities have developed a plan that includes the evacuation of the population if the situation around the plant develops under a negative scenario.


The nuclear power plant in Energodar is under the control of the Russian troops. Over the past few days, Ukrainian forces have conducted several strikes on the premises, using drones, heavy artillery and multiple rocket launchers. Air defense systems repel attacks in most cases, but in some episodes, shells do hit infrastructure facilities, as well as the storage area.

As earlier reported, on Thursday, Ukraine’s armed forces conducted a massive shelling of the Zaporozhye NPP and the city of Energodar for the second time in one day. Previously, Russian air defense systems deflected all Ukrainian attacks with strike drones and heavy artillery on the city and the NPP overnight and on Thursday morning. Since early August, the Ukrainian army attempted to strike the NPP’s premises and the city at least five times. On August 5, the Ukrainian armed forces shelled a railway station three times, on August 6, they bombarded the NPP’s healthcare facility and a water supply facility in Energodar, and on August 7, another strike on the NPP hit the area where a storage facility for spent nuclear fuel was located.


In the Russia-Ukraine conflict, Ukraine's propaganda machinery has emerged a winner.
1. Yevgeny Balitsky is a Russia-installed puppet in Zaporizhzhia.
2. You are linking to Tass.com...a Russian mouthpiece.

FAIL LESS
 
The Ukrainian military is deliberately targeting nuclear waste storage at the Zaporozhye Nuclear Power Plant to bring about a ‘dirty bomb’ explosion and make the area uninhabitable, Yevgeny Balitsky, the head of the Zaporozhye Region’s military-civilian administration, told the Rossiya-24 TV channel on Thursday.

"They were practically targeting the nuclear waste storage facility in order to create a kind of a 'dirty bomb' on our territory, to create the situation where there will be a release. <...> [In order] to lead to air contamination and make an entire territory uninhabitable," he stressed.

Thousands of tonnes of radioactive waste are stored at the plant, Balitsky went on to say. "Their (Ukrainian troops' - TASS) goals are, of course, clear to us. They want to scare us, they want to make unusable the territory they have already lost forever," he stated.

At the moment, the concrete protection of the facility ‘holds up’, he said. "But we find hits 300 meters away from the nuclear power plant, we find the shells that have almost hit, that are 20 meters away from the storage facility with nuclear waste. <...> If they hit the concrete storage facility accurately enough, than, which is frightful to think of, it will bring about something like what happened in Chernobyl - there will be a release, it will be a 'dirty bomb,'" Balitsky explained. According to him, Zaporozhye Region authorities have developed a plan that includes the evacuation of the population if the situation around the plant develops under a negative scenario.


The nuclear power plant in Energodar is under the control of the Russian troops. Over the past few days, Ukrainian forces have conducted several strikes on the premises, using drones, heavy artillery and multiple rocket launchers. Air defense systems repel attacks in most cases, but in some episodes, shells do hit infrastructure facilities, as well as the storage area.

As earlier reported, on Thursday, Ukraine’s armed forces conducted a massive shelling of the Zaporozhye NPP and the city of Energodar for the second time in one day. Previously, Russian air defense systems deflected all Ukrainian attacks with strike drones and heavy artillery on the city and the NPP overnight and on Thursday morning. Since early August, the Ukrainian army attempted to strike the NPP’s premises and the city at least five times. On August 5, the Ukrainian armed forces shelled a railway station three times, on August 6, they bombarded the NPP’s healthcare facility and a water supply facility in Energodar, and on August 7, another strike on the NPP hit the area where a storage facility for spent nuclear fuel was located.


In the Russia-Ukraine conflict, Ukraine's propaganda machinery has emerged a winner.
That's F'n crazy. I wonder if this if fact or not.
 
On the banks of the Dnipro River, it's possible to see the Zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant 10 miles across the water.
It's a place which has seen heavy shelling over the past couple of weeks, with up to 120 rockets being reported in a single night.
They come from the direction of Enerhodar, the city where the plant is situated.

Enerhodar - and the power station - have come under heavy fire.
On Saturday, there was shelling of the nitrogen-oxygen station, which caused a fire. By some miracle, the people working there survived.

The UN's nuclear watchdog claims there's a "real risk of nuclear disaster" unless the fighting stops and inspectors are allowed access.

 
The Ukrainian military is deliberately targeting nuclear waste storage at the Zaporozhye Nuclear Power Plant to bring about a ‘dirty bomb’ explosion and make the area uninhabitable, Yevgeny Balitsky, the head of the Zaporozhye Region’s military-civilian administration, told the Rossiya-24 TV channel on Thursday.


TASS is the media arm of the Russian government. Ergo... propaganda
 
98% of Ukrainians believe in victory in war with Russia.

According to a poll conducted by the Center for Insights in Survey Research, 91% of Ukrainians approve of President Volodymyr Zelensky's work.


As they should.
 
On the banks of the Dnipro River, it's possible to see the Zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant 10 miles across the water.
It's a place which has seen heavy shelling over the past couple of weeks, with up to 120 rockets being reported in a single night.
They come from the direction of Enerhodar, the city where the plant is situated.

Enerhodar - and the power station - have come under heavy fire.
On Saturday, there was shelling of the nitrogen-oxygen station, which caused a fire. By some miracle, the people working there survived.

The UN's nuclear watchdog claims there's a "real risk of nuclear disaster" unless the fighting stops and inspectors are allowed access.


The Russians are using the Enerhodar nuclear facility as a shield for their on-site artillery.

They are firing across the Dniepro River at the city of Nikopol and surreounding towns.
 
The Biden administration says it is giving Ukraine the weapons, ammunition and training it needs to win this battle to regain occupied territory in the south. On Monday, the Pentagon announced a new $1 billion arms package that includes additional rockets for the 16 HIMARS launchers now in Ukraine, 75,000 rounds of artillery ammunition, and advanced antiaircraft missiles.

Ukrainian Maj. Gen. Vadim Skibitsky, the country’s deputy chief of military intelligence, said that “we use real-time information” from the United States in targeting attacks by HIMARS rockets on Russian fuel and ammunition supplies.

Ukraine’s real lifeline is the Black Sea coastline. If Ukrainian forces can push the Russians back from Kherson and Zaporizhzhia, to the east, it would relieve pressure along the coast and could eventually protect Ukraine’s maritime access to global markets.

Ukraine’s timetable for the southern campaign is driven partly by its desire to beat a planned Russian referendum in Kherson and neighboring areas.

 
Yes blackmail and extortion is always tough to fight but the results of giving in to Putin's threats are intolerable. We can't let him take back most of Europe because we are scared that he might launch nukes can we? His ultimate stated goal is taking back every country in the former Soviet Union.

No, we drew the line at NATO long ago.
Ukraine is their sphere of influence.

BTW, the shelling seems to be coming from the Ukraines not the Russians at the plant.
 
The Russians are using the Enerhodar nuclear facility as a shield for their on-site artillery.

They are firing across the Dniepro River at the city of Nikopol and surreounding towns.

Exactly. It is the Ukraines firing at the plant for this reason.
 
The armed forces of Ukraine have launched dozens of attack drones and fired dozens of rockets from multiple-launch rocket systems (MLRS) towards the Russian-controlled Zaporozhye nuclear power plant (NPP) this month, Vladimir Rogov, a member of the main council of the region's military-civilian administration, told TASS on Friday.

"Dozens of MLRS rockets, heavy artillery rounds, strike drones have been launched towards the territory of the NPP," he said, when asked how many times the Kiev forces attacked the facility in August.

In his words, air defenses of the plant have been reinforced following latest attacks.

"The results are already seen: during the shelling that began at about 10 p.m. [on Wednesday] and continued throughout Thursday, all rockets and drones have been intercepted and destroyed," he said. "The Russian artillery, Russian forces are countering the enemy’s fire."

The Kiev government forces have repeatedly launched strikes targeting the territory of the Zaporozhye NPP, the largest nuclear power plant in Europe with six operating reactors. In March 2022, the Zaporozhye NPP was placed under the Russian army’s control. On August 7, the Ukrainian military shelled the plant, targeting, in particular, the spent nuclear fuel repository. The military-civilian administration of Energodar where the nuclear power station is located, said that the Kiev regime had fired a 220mm Uragan rocket with a cluster warhead. Its striking elements damaged the station’s administrative buildings and the repository’s adjacent territory. Prior to that, the Ukrainian military bombarded the Zaporozhye NPP on August 5 and 6.


The Ukrainian nuclear power operator, Energoatom, says that as of Friday, the nuclear power plant in Zaporizhzhia "operates with the risk of violating radiation and fire safety standards."

Energoatom alleged the shelling of the Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Power Plant (ZNPP) by Russian forces last week, and over ten "arrivals" near the plant, close to the first power unit on Thursday, "caused a serious risk to the safe operation of the plant."

"As a result of the attack on the Zaporizhzhia NPP, the emergency protection on one of the power units was activated; one of the three operating power units is now disconnected," Energoatom said on its Telegram channel.


Russia is maximizing the risk of a nuclear disaster and turning the Zaporizhzhia NPP into a battlefield.
 
The Biden administration says it is giving Ukraine the weapons, ammunition and training it needs to win this battle to regain occupied territory in the south.

The Biden Admin is delivering the requisite heavy weapons in dribs and drabs and are still holding back on items such as as ATACMS.

In order to drive the Russians from all occupied aress (the south/Crimea/Donbas) UAF will require at least 30 HIMARS/M270 MLRS.

Biden is delivering enough weaponry so that Ukraine isn't overrun, but not enough to entirely expel the Russians.

Whatever plans the Ukrainians have for their southern offensive, it must be completed before winter sets in.
 

TASS is owned by the Russian govt. and is not a valid source.

Overall, we rate the Russian News Agency (TASS), Questionable based on the consistent promotion of Russian Propaganda, conspiracies, and poor sourcing of information.
 
In Odessa during winter average daily high temperatures are level around 38°F and it is overcast or mostly cloudy about 61% of the time.

Yalta subtropical Mediterranean climate is characterized by mild and wet winter.

Month High / Low(°F) Rain


December 47° / 38° 9 days


January 45° / 35° 10 days


February 45° / 35° 8 days
 
The Russian military’s control over the Zaporozhye Nuclear Power Plant (NPP) is a key to the regions’ nuclear security, leader of Russia’s Liberal Democratic Party and Chairman of the State Duma (the lower house of parliament) Foreign Affairs Committee Leonid Slutsky said on Friday.

"The Russian military’s ongoing control over the Zaporozhye NPP is a key to nuclear security in the region, it’s obvious. The IAEA sees the need to send a mission to the Zaporozhye NPP and Russia is ready to provide full assistance, which has been made clear. However, Ukraine must stop its attacks on the nuclear facility. This is what the G7 countries should be concerned about," he wrote on Telegram.

According to Slutsky, otherwise, Ukrainian President Vladimir Zelensky and his Western sponsors will have to bear responsibility for a potential nuclear disaster.

The senior lawmaker slammed an initiative to transfer control over the NPP to Ukraine to ensure access for IAEA inspectors as "sheer mockery." "It is even similar to making concessions to ‘nuclear terrorists.’ All the statements that the foreign ministrers of G7 countries have made in support of these demands are nothing but attempts to sponsor nuclear terrorism," Slutsky noted.

The Zaporozhye NPP in the city of Energodar is controlled by Russian troops. The Ukrainian military carried out a series of attacks on the facility in the past several days, which particularly involved drones, heavy artillery and multiple rocket launchers. Most attacks were repelled by air defenses but some infrastructure facilities and the nuclear waste storage area were hit.

The NPP, the largest in Europe, has six reactors with a total capacity of 6,000 megawatts. The facility currently operates at 70% of its full capacity because of excess electricity production in the liberated areas of the region.


The United States and Ukraine hope to make Russia look like a ‘nuclear terrorist’
 
The Russian military’s control over the Zaporozhye Nuclear Power Plant (NPP) is a key to the regions’ nuclear security, leader of Russia’s Liberal Democratic Party and Chairman of the State Duma (the lower house of parliament) Foreign Affairs Committee Leonid Slutsky said on Friday.

"The Russian military’s ongoing control over the Zaporozhye NPP is a key to nuclear security in the region, it’s obvious. The IAEA sees the need to send a mission to the Zaporozhye NPP and Russia is ready to provide full assistance, which has been made clear. However, Ukraine must stop its attacks on the nuclear facility. This is what the G7 countries should be concerned about," he wrote on Telegram.

According to Slutsky, otherwise, Ukrainian President Vladimir Zelensky and his Western sponsors will have to bear responsibility for a potential nuclear disaster.

The senior lawmaker slammed an initiative to transfer control over the NPP to Ukraine to ensure access for IAEA inspectors as "sheer mockery." "It is even similar to making concessions to ‘nuclear terrorists.’ All the statements that the foreign ministrers of G7 countries have made in support of these demands are nothing but attempts to sponsor nuclear terrorism," Slutsky noted.

The Zaporozhye NPP in the city of Energodar is controlled by Russian troops. The Ukrainian military carried out a series of attacks on the facility in the past several days, which particularly involved drones, heavy artillery and multiple rocket launchers. Most attacks were repelled by air defenses but some infrastructure facilities and the nuclear waste storage area were hit.

The NPP, the largest in Europe, has six reactors with a total capacity of 6,000 megawatts. The facility currently operates at 70% of its full capacity because of excess electricity production in the liberated areas of the region.


The United States and Ukraine hope to make Russia look like a ‘nuclear terrorist’

Commandeering a civilian nuclear facility and using it as an active military base from which to launch attacks into territories Russia aims to conquer does a pretty good job of making Russia look like a terrorist state, nuclear or not.
 
The Ukrainian attack on the Zaporozhye nuclear facility was, in typical Orwellian fashion, forecasted by the United States four days before it took place. During an August 1 news conference at the United Nations, US Secretary of State Antony Blinken accused Russia of using the nuclear facility as a base from which it conducted artillery strikes against Ukraine. Blinken declared that the act of firing artillery rockets from proximity to the nuclear power plant was “the height of irresponsibility,” implying that these rockets could land on the power plant itself. Blinken also added that the Russians were using the nuclear facility as a “nuclear shield” which prevented any Ukrainian attack out of fear of striking the nuclear reactors.

Blinken’s brazen parroting of Ukrainian government talking points was made more absurd by the absolute dearth of evidence to back up his powerful pronouncements. Normally, when someone of the stature of the Secretary of State speaks in such a public manner about issues of this importance, there is some intelligence information that is released – for instance, overhead imagery showing Russian troop locations near the Zaporozhye nuclear plant – to sustain the allegation. No such data was provided, however, because Blinken had ceased functioning as the head of the American diplomatic service, and instead was functioning as little more than a Ukrainian propagandist.

For its part, Russia has made it clear that there were no Russian forces located in the vicinity of the Zaporozhye nuclear facility save for a small contingent of troops for security purposes (it is, after all, an active nuclear power plant.) Again, while Russia can clearly provide overhead imagery of its force disposition in the vicinity of the plant, operational security precludes it from doing so. It is, after all, the job of the accuser to provide the evidence of a crime, not the accused.

Blinken’s August 1 statement served as the initiation of a public relations campaign which culminated in the Ukrainian artillery attack on the Zaporozhye nuclear facility. The goal of this campaign appears to be twofold – first, to put Russia in a bad light, and second, to allow Ukraine to accomplish that which it could not achieve through military force – the eviction of Russian troops from Zaporozhye. The calls for international intervention emanating from the West point to a concerted effort in promoting a pro-Ukrainian narrative even when all parties know the underlying facts sustaining this narrative are not true. To counteract that, Russia has extended its own invitation to IAEA monitors to visit the powerplant and summoned a UN Security Council meeting to discuss the situation.

This is far more serious than simply another information warfare campaign gone bad. While the Zaporozhye nuclear facility is constructed to standards which would be able to survive a direct hit from an artillery rocket, the disruption of power and/or damage to safety equipment could lead to the kind of runaway event that preceded the Chernobyl nuclear disaster. The Russian Defense Ministry noted that the Ukrainian attack on the power plant had caused a power surge which triggered an emergency shutdown. The head of the Ukrainian company operating the plant further noted that all but one power line connecting it to Ukraine’s energy system had been destroyed, declaring that any power blackout could be “very unsafe for such a nuclear facility.”


Antony Blinken's provocative nuclear rhetoric is the height of irresponsibility.
 
For its part, Russia has made it clear that there were no Russian forces located in the vicinity of the Zaporozhye nuclear facility save for a small contingent of troops for security purposes (it is, after all, an active nuclear power plant.) Again, while Russia can clearly provide overhead imagery of its force disposition in the vicinity of the plant, operational security precludes it from doing so. It is, after all, the job of the accuser to provide the evidence of a crime, not the accused.


There is one thing that is absolutely certain: Ukraine is as stressed as can be. This stress is masked to the world thanks to the tweets of big successes by Ukraine. On tweeter and in the western media Ukraine is winning hands down. But the reality on the ground is probably very different. The wonder weapons Ukraine had been howling for have all been delivered; but it does not look like it is changing much. The much announced Kherson counter offensive is all but postponed. Have the wonder weapons been deployed in the Donbass? If they have been, then they are not making much of a difference; Ukraine has not signaled any drop in Russian shellings at all. The slugfest continues without any sign that the bear is out of breath at all.

Widening the conflict and somehow getting Nato/Eu actively involved may be Ukraine's only hope. And may explain the shellings at the Zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant.
 
Back
Top Bottom