• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Russia Detains American in Moscow Over Suspected Spying

Rogue Valley

Lead or get out of the way
DP Veteran
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
94,343
Reaction score
82,729
Location
Barsoom
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
Russia Detains American in Moscow Over Suspected Spying




Although the Kremlin would never reveal as much, this was without doubt approved by Vladimir Putin.

The KGB Colonel probably needs some US trade-bait for Russian spy Maria Butina who has plead guilty to being an undeclared foreign agent.
 
The American's name is Paul Whelan. No other information was offered by the FSB. This could be a "Checkpoint Charlie" grab. Someone that was handy to be used as a bargaining chip.

The purpose? Some possibilities:

1) A conveniently added incentive for Trump to meet again personally with Putin and conveniently secure Whelan's release or trade. (the great dealmaker and all that nonsense).
2) Simply a warm American body snatched to trade for the Russian spy Mariya Butina. A tit for tat trade so to speak.
3) Provide Trump an [artificial] excuse to flex "presidential muscle" over this travesty and help mute the wide impression that Trump is Putin's boy.

A problem is that Trump's image vis-a-vis Russia is so compromised at this point that no matter what he does (or doesn't do) it will seem mighty suspicious.
 

And that it happens now is a sign to the NRA loving Russian that she need not tell too much.
 

American Paul Whelan of Novi, Michigan. Imprisoned in Moscow.

It seems that American Paul Whelan (48) of Novi, Michigan is a retired Marine and director of global security for Michigan-based automotive components supplier BorgWarner. According to his twin brother David, Paul was in Moscow attending the wedding of a fellow ex-Marine and a Russian woman. Paul never made it to the wedding. Although born in Canada, Whelan is an American citizen and served multiple tours in Iraq with the Marine Corps. Whelan travels the world in his job capacity (physical plant security), but this was a private trip. BorgWarner has no facilities in Russia. The Russian FSB Security Service has charged Mr. Whelan with violating Article 276 (espionage). Conviction carries a sentence of 15-20 years.

It's looking more and more like the Kremlin needed an American hostage.
 
U.S. Demands Immediate Return of Ex-Marine Detained in Russia on Spy Charges




According to the Vienna Convention which Moscow signed, arrested foreign nationals are allowed visits by their embassy/consular officials. Moscow typically denies this right to Ukrainian/Tatar prisoners.
 
It seems Whelan is a bit of a Russophile, visiting Russia numerous times (Moscow and St. Petersburg) and taking Russian language lessons.

He has a VK page (Russia's version of Facebook). One of his VK friends is a Russian soldier, and another is a Russian Frontier Guard, both are stationed in Moscow.

No doubt the Russian FSB has a file/dossier on Paul Whelan.
 

Exactly what I was thinking. With Mueller indicting all the Russians who interfered in our election process, this is a "warning shot" from Putin not to mess with his spies and vandals.
 

Whelan’s brother was interviewed this morning and states that he did not know that his brother was discharged under less than honorable conditions in the USMC in 2008. But he was emphatic that brother was not a spy. How can he be so sure?
 
Whelan’s brother was interviewed this morning and states that he did not know that his brother was discharged under less than honorable conditions in the USMC in 2008. But he was emphatic that brother was not a spy. How can he be so sure?

I don't think he can be sure. Moscow says US Consular officials were allowed to visit with Whelan (there is a 72 hour window for this). He enlisted in the USMC in 1994, rose to the rank of Staff Sergeant, did two tours in Iraq (2004/2006), and was dishonorably discharged (theft/larceny) in 2008. He has been visiting Russia since 2007. It seems he has a working command of Russian. The US military language school at Monterey rates Russian as a Class III language (mid-to-high level difficulty). Since he received less than an honorable discharge from the Corps, I'm wondering how he was hired as Corporate Security Director for BorgWarner. He must know some people who pulled some strings.
 
U.S. Envoy to Russia Visits American Detained on Spy Allegations | The Moscow Times


Lefortovo Prison in Moscow where Paul Whelan is being held.


It's highly unusual for an ambassador, the highest ranking US official in a foreign land, to engage in a consular mission such as this.

On the face of it, Putin needed an American hostage to trade for Maria Butina.
 
Moscow Accuses Washington of Detaining Russian Citizen After Whelan's Arrest


The plot thickens further. What goes around comes around.

Related: Moscow accuses Washington of detaining Russian citizen after arresting ex-US Marine
 
Guess what - two can play that game and there are many more US citizens in Russia than vice versa.

Remember also - according to you guys, Russia can ignore its laws.

Still want to play stupid games?

It's not me Ivan. I'm just a bystander.
 
It's not me Ivan. I'm just a bystander.


I don't think that this kind of game is constructive for anybody.


How many passports does this guy have :shock:? I guess that nationality means nothing any more in the west, so who cares?
 
I don't think that this kind of game is constructive for anybody.

How many passports does this guy have :shock:? I guess that nationality means nothing any more in the west, so who cares?

I guess he should have used GRU issued fake passports which are all the rage for Russian "tourists".
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…