• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!
  • Welcome to our archives. No new posts are allowed here.

Overturning the ACA Could Result in 68,000 Deaths

Rogue Valley

Lead or get out of the way
DP Veteran
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
94,327
Reaction score
82,707
Location
Barsoom
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent

10/29/20
As many as 68,000 people may die in a single year if the Supreme Court overturns the Affordable Care Act, according to research published Thursday. The study, published by Health Affairs, found that some 2.3 million people have already lost health insurance coverage during the first three years of the Trump administration and that between 3,399 and 25,180 people died as a result of losing that coverage. The growth in the number of uninsured between 2016 and 2019 likely resulted from several steps the administration has taken to shrink health care coverage, such as cutting spending for a program that helps people sign up for health insurance, according to the study’s authors. The administration also supported the repeal of the individual mandate by Congress in 2017. The loss of health insurance has well-documented financial, medical, and psychological consequences. In general, the uninsured tend to be sicker because they receive less preventive care. In part because they delay and forego both diagnoses and treatments, those without health insurance coverage run a greater risk of dying.

Far more deaths are expected if the Supreme Court overturns the Affordable Care Act. The authors of the study use the Urban Institute’s estimate that 19.9 million people will likely lose their health insurance, as well as several studies tying a lack of insurance to premature death, to calculate that the massive loss in health coverage will likely cause between 22,892 and 68,345 deaths per year among adults under 65. On November 10, the Supreme Court is scheduled to hear arguments in California v. Texas, a case that could result in the court striking down the entire Affordable Care Act in the midst of a global pandemic that has already resulted in more than 227,000 deaths in the U.S. Amy Coney Barrett, Donald Trump’s recently installed justice, is expected to vote with conservatives against the law. Trump appears not to have a plan for making sure that those who lose coverage as a result of the Supreme Court decision will have continued access to health care.


This is the healthcare platform that Donald Trump and the GOP are running on in 2020 ... removing healthcare insurance from 20 million Americans and removing protections on pre-existing conditions from everyone.

VOTE! Your life and/or the life of your loved ones may depend on defeating Donald Trump and the Republican Party at the polls!

How Much Has The Number of Uninsured Risen Since 2016 — And At What Cost To Health And Life?
 
It could result in universal healthcare. Who knows.
 
The GOP really has become the Party of Death. The indifferent response to the pandemic, the continuing obsession with taking away tens of millions of Americans' health care at the worst possible time. The stakes are quite high this year.

They support only a particular kind of government intervention, the kind of intervention that benefits themselves and their contributors and their supporters:




Republicans are fakes, frauds, and hypocrites.
 
This is the healthcare platform that Donald Trump and the GOP are running on in 2020 ... removing healthcare insurance from 20 million Americans and removing protections on pre-existing conditions from everyone.VOTE! Your life and/or the life of your loved ones may depend on defeating Donald Trump and the Republican Party at the polls!

The consequences of not attending to the growing U.S. health disadvantage and reversing current trends are predictable: the United States will probably continue to fall further behind comparable countries on health outcomes and mortality. In addition to the personal toll this will take, the drain on life and health may ultimately affect the economy and the prosperity of the United States as other countries reap the benefits of healthier populations and more productive workforces.

Why is it that the US refuses to spend money on making sure all Americans have good health and good education. It's actually cheaper to do that than the cost of dealing with the personal and social problems of poor health, lack of education and the poverty they create.
 
This is the healthcare platform that Donald Trump and the GOP are running on in 2020 ... removing healthcare insurance from 20 million Americans and removing protections on pre-existing conditions from everyone.

WHOA! Hold on there for just a goldang minute! Did you happen to catch the 60 Minute interview where trump stormed out due so many unfair questions? Of all things, being grilled on where he was at with the plan to repeal and replace the ACA?

Well by golly, after he stormed out of the studio he had that Barbie Doll cutie what's-her-name strut back in, struggling to carry a REALLY BIG BOOK the contents of which would certainly shame any/all critics who doubted the existence of his master plan!

I mean, it was a REALLY big book with LOTS, and LOTS, and LOTS of pages. Well... uh, yeah it turns out that if someone were to actually read through this massive tome that it had many official looking documents with serious sounding names and absolutely nothing about any kind of health plan, but c'mon-- it was a REALLY REALLY big book after all!
 
This is the healthcare platform that Donald Trump and the GOP are running on in 2020 ... removing healthcare insurance from 20 million Americans and removing protections on pre-existing conditions from everyone.

VOTE!
Your life and/or the life of your loved ones may depend on defeating Donald Trump and the Republican Party at the polls!

You are flat out lying in order to try to win an election.

Trump has now verified, at two debates, HE WILL NOT REMOVE PROTECTIONS ON PRE-EXISTING CONDITIONS.

If you want to win the election, you need to use honest tactics. If you use dishonest tactics, and Biden is elected, his Presidency will be an absolute mess.
 
kicking people with preexisting conditions out of the health care system could be fairly catastrophic. COVID is also a preexisting condition, and the US is up to 100,000 new cases a day.
 
You are flat out lying in order to try to win an election.

Trump has now verified, at two debates, HE WILL NOT REMOVE PROTECTIONS ON PRE-EXISTING CONDITIONS.

If you want to win the election, you need to use honest tactics. If you use dishonest tactics, and Biden is elected, his Presidency will be an absolute mess.

That’s not what his filings with the Supreme Court say!
 
That’s not what his filings with the Supreme Court say!
Do you think it's ethical to pretend that you are unaware of the fact that Trump has clearly stated, including at the last debate, that he WILL PROTECT PREEXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE NEW PLAN?
 
Do you think it's ethical to pretend that you are unaware of the fact that Trump has clearly stated, including at the last debate, that he WILL PROTECT PREEXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE NEW PLAN?

Do you think it’s ethical to pretend he’s not trying to take away those protections via the courts right now? Or to imply there’s a “new plan” when there obviously is not?

His crowning “achievement” on health care thus far is taking executive action to allow the proliferation of junk plans that don’t cover pre-existing conditions. Trump is no friend of those with health conditions. Including millions of COVID survivors.
 
Do you think it’s ethical to pretend he’s not trying to take away those protections via the courts right now? Or to imply there’s a “new plan” when there obviously is not?
Greenbeard, I do not believe for a minute that this is one bit authentic.

You know that he has promised, repeatedly, including in the last debate, to preserve the pre-existing condition guarantee in whichever new plan is passed, and has given Azar oversight authority pertaining to this issue.

This thread is incredibly dishonest. We might as well be accusing Biden of intending to transform the nation into a socialist state. And eliminating local policing.

 
Do you think it's ethical to pretend that you are unaware of the fact that Trump has clearly stated, including at the last debate, that he WILL PROTECT PREEXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE NEW PLAN?

Yep, the only problem is that “new plan” (aka TrumpCare) has yet to be shown to exist in legislative form. We have been assured, on multiple occasions, that such a plan will cost less, cover everyone, protect pre-existing conditions and is “coming soon”.
 
Yep, the only problem is that “new plan” (aka TrumpCare) has yet to be shown to exist in legislative form. We have been assured, on multiple occasions, that such a plan will cost less, cover everyone, protect pre-existing conditions and is “coming soon”.
He first has to be re-elected. And has to devote all his time and energy to this goal.

The Supreme Court will not rule on the ACA until the Spring.

Trump has issued an EO putting Azar and HHS in charge of overseeing that Congress passes a replacement bill, preserving pre-existing condition guarantees, BEFORE the ACA is potentially repealed.
 




This is the healthcare platform that Donald Trump and the GOP are running on in 2020 ... removing healthcare insurance from 20 million Americans and removing protections on pre-existing conditions from everyone.

VOTE! Your life and/or the life of your loved ones may depend on defeating Donald Trump and the Republican Party at the polls!

How Much Has The Number of Uninsured Risen Since 2016 — And At What Cost To Health And Life?

Just another goofy cherry picked study from a goofy left wing biased source.
 
Greenbeard, I do not believe for a minute that this is one bit authentic.

You know that he has promised, repeatedly, including in the last debate, to preserve the pre-existing condition guarantee in whichever new plan is passed, and has given Azar oversight authority pertaining to this issue.

This thread is incredibly dishonest. We might as well be accusing Biden of intending to transform the nation into a socialist state. And eliminating local policing.



He also promised to get coverage for everybody four years ago. Then he spent most of 2017 trying to take coverage away from 20+ million people. Now he’s back at it again. He lied.

He is a threat to the health care of every American. Particularly those who have experienced a health issue.
 
He first has to be re-elected. And has to devote all his time and energy to this goal.

The Supreme Court will not rule on the ACA until the Spring.

Trump has issued an EO putting Azar and HHS in charge of overseeing that Congress passes a replacement bill, preserving pre-existing condition guarantees, BEFORE the ACA is potentially repealed.

What a load of BS. Trump has been determined to repeal and replace PPACA since he started running for POTUS.
 
What a load of BS. Trump has been determined to repeal and replace PPACA since he started running for POTUS.

I pray that he is successful in doing so. The ACA has been a disaster.
 
I pray that he is successful in doing so. The ACA has been a disaster.

Wrong. 20+ million Americans gained coverage (and millions more enjoy additional benefits and financial protections under their coverage), even as health care cost growth hit historic lows, saving nearly $3 trillion over the past decade. Health care quality has gone up, even as more people are accessing better care and experiencing demonstrably better health outcomes as a result. The last decade has been an extraordinary one for the American health system by virtually any metric.
 




This is the healthcare platform that Donald Trump and the GOP are running on in 2020 ... removing healthcare insurance from 20 million Americans and removing protections on pre-existing conditions from everyone.

VOTE! Your life and/or the life of your loved ones may depend on defeating Donald Trump and the Republican Party at the polls!

How Much Has The Number of Uninsured Risen Since 2016 — And At What Cost To Health And Life?
It could result in 250 million deaths also. Have you pressed your panic button yet?
 




This is the healthcare platform that Donald Trump and the GOP are running on in 2020 ... removing healthcare insurance from 20 million Americans and removing protections on pre-existing conditions from everyone.

VOTE! Your life and/or the life of your loved ones may depend on defeating Donald Trump and the Republican Party at the polls!

How Much Has The Number of Uninsured Risen Since 2016 — And At What Cost To Health And Life?
They
Do
Not
Care
 
Wrong. 20+ million Americans gained coverage (and millions more enjoy additional benefits and financial protections under their coverage), even as health care cost growth hit historic lows, saving nearly $3 trillion over the past decade. Health care quality has gone up, even as more people are accessing better care and experiencing demonstrably better health outcomes as a result. The last decade has been an extraordinary one for the American health system by virtually any metric.

Stop lying.

Millions lost their shared employer plans. 7 million lost their plans.

Millions lost their doctors who dropped out of the network.

Millions paid more and got less.
 
They
Do
Not
Care
You're right, and with good reason. However during the 1950's, 60's. 70's, 80's and 90's there was no ACA and yet people somehow survived. Hard to understand, isn't it?
 
Back
Top Bottom