• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

NSA collection of phone info illegal, court rules[W:25]

Ockham

Noblesse oblige
DP Veteran
Joined
Oct 12, 2009
Messages
23,909
Reaction score
11,003
Location
New Jersey
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Libertarian - Right

NSA collection of phone info illegal, court rules - WTOP


This is hot off the presses.... USAToday and Politico is corroborating the story. Ultimately the vast collection of big data which is being collected for possible use in the future, is not legal according to the 2nd Circuit appeals court. IMO it never was and is lazy and unconstitutional. Let's see if this gets escalated further and finally ends up on the SCOTUS desk.
 
Federal Court: Bulk Collection Of Phone Metadata Is Illegal



Read more @: Federal Court: Bulk Collection Of Phone Metadata Is Illegal

:applaudWoah! Did not see that one coming! But hey, great news for privacy! Hope this gives some momentum for more lawsuits and rulings that are similar in the future!
 
Re: NSA collection of phone info illegal, court rules

Conservatives will be outraged at this ruling defending American privacy no doubt.
 
Re: NSA collection of phone info illegal, court rules

Conservatives will be outraged at this ruling defending American privacy no doubt.

Why would conservatives be outraged? This is something that has only gotten worse under Obama.
 
Re: Federal Court: Bulk Collection Of Phone Metadata Is Illegal

More info here: Appeals Court Rules NSA Phone Program Not Authorized by Patriot Act - WSJ
 
Re: NSA collection of phone info illegal, court rules

Conservatives will be outraged at this ruling defending American privacy no doubt.

I haven't seen this particular case break on partisan lines. It seems to be more of a "statist/libertarian" thing, to use the terms loosley. Lefties and Righties come in both flavors.
 
Re: NSA collection of phone info illegal, court rules

Why would conservatives be outraged? This is something that has only gotten worse under Obama.
Thanks for proving my point and ignoring that "foot in the door" principle.
 
Re: NSA collection of phone info illegal, court rules

Thanks for proving my point and ignoring that "foot in the door" principle.

Unless your point was that liberals perform even worse on unconstitutional matters than conservatives, think again.
 
Re: Federal Court: Bulk Collection Of Phone Metadata Is Illegal


Finally, the voice of reason. Too bad that ole (D) and (R) have found so many ways around the Bill of Rights that it has almost become a worthless addition to the Constitution.
 
Re: Federal Court: Bulk Collection Of Phone Metadata Is Illegal

Good start. Now, let's repeal the rest of the so called "Patriot Act" and restore the Fourth Amendment. Perhaps when we're through, we can start on the Fifth, maybe even the Tenth.
 
Re: Federal Court: Bulk Collection Of Phone Metadata Is Illegal

Good start. Now, let's repeal the rest of the so called "Patriot Act" and restore the Fourth Amendment. Perhaps when we're through, we can start on the Fifth, maybe even the Tenth.

yea and we will repeal obamacare for violating the limited powers clause of the constitution as well. won't happen.
 
Re: Federal Court: Bulk Collection Of Phone Metadata Is Illegal

yea and we will repeal obamacare for violating the limited powers clause of the constitution as well. won't happen.

And what moron would wish to do that?

The ACA was enacted to increase the quality and affordability of health insurance, lower the uninsured rate by expanding public and private insurance coverage, and reduce the costs of healthcare for individuals and the government. It introduced mechanisms like mandates, subsidies, and insurance exchanges.[1][2] The law requires insurance companies to cover all applicants within new minimum standards and offer the same rates regardless of pre-existing conditions or sex.[3] Additional reforms were increased competition, regulation, and incentives to streamline the delivery of healthcare. In 2011 the Congressional Budget Office projected that the ACA would lower both future deficits[4] and Medicare spending.
 
Re: Federal Court: Bulk Collection Of Phone Metadata Is Illegal

Yes indeed. But will this see an end to it?

What it means is that the ACLU suit against NSA, rejected by the lower court, will now be able to proceed. That's the way I understand it anyway.
 
Re: Federal Court: Bulk Collection Of Phone Metadata Is Illegal

Moderator's Warning:
Threads merged.
 
Re: Federal Court: Bulk Collection Of Phone Metadata Is Illegal

What it means is that the ACLU suit against NSA, rejected by the lower court, will now be able to proceed. That's the way I understand it anyway.

Great. Glad to hear you're a supporter of the ACLU.
 
Last edited:
Re: Federal Court: Bulk Collection Of Phone Metadata Is Illegal


I'm no moron however I support repeal of Obamacare. It does not fall with in any of the powers of Congress.


US Constitution Text
 
Re: Federal Court: Bulk Collection Of Phone Metadata Is Illegal

I'm no moron however I support repeal of Obamacare. It does not fall with in any of the powers of Congress.



US Constitution Text

The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act was essentially written by a right wing think tank, the Heritage Foundation, was practiced by a republican governor in Massachusetts, and received the blessings of the Supreme Court. What's your beef, hmm?
 
Re: Federal Court: Bulk Collection Of Phone Metadata Is Illegal


please read what was responding to.

PS still waiting on my 2500 premium reduction instead of the 50% plus increase I have had in the past 2 years.
 
Re: Federal Court: Bulk Collection Of Phone Metadata Is Illegal


No, Obamacare Wasn't a "Republican" Proposal
yet another lie from the left.

Is the ACA the GOP health care plan from 1993? | PunditFact
That said, the Senate plan from 1993 was not identical to the health care law that passed in 2010. The Republican bill did not expand Medicaid as Obamacare does, and it did have medical malpractice tort reform, which the current law does not. In contrast to the current employer mandate, the Chafee bill required employers to offer insurance, but they were under no obligation to help pay for it.

this so called bill was scuttled and never even made the rest of it is nonsense from politifact bias.
no one voted for the 90's bill that was introduced.

so can we finally stop with the liberal lie that obamcare is a republican idea?
 
Re: Federal Court: Bulk Collection Of Phone Metadata Is Illegal

Deleted as it does not pertain to the topic.
 
Re: NSA collection of phone info illegal, court rules

Moderator's Warning:
Lets get back on topic people. Which is not Obamacare. Sorry that I also let myself be drawn into it also.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…