The concept of a national ID, similar to the driver's license at the state level, just at the federal level, has been met with lots of opposition from those who think that a national ID system is the hallmark of a totalitarian system.
However, the Passport Card - which allows you to travel to and from Canada and Mexico without tourist visas, and is $40 cheaper than a full-fledged passport - has been a lot better received, largely because it is voluntary. Don't want the Passport Card? Fine, just don't expect to go to Canada or Mexico without a tourist visa. Simple as that.
Ok, so, voluntary national IDs are a lot better received, eh? Well, let's take that approach.
You will need a national ID before you can participate in any optional government programs. Any at all.
You want to sue someone in federal court? Show your national ID along with your complaint.
Subject to federal criminal charges, and want a public defender? Flash your national ID.
Want welfare money? Show your national ID with the application.
You can file your taxes without a national ID, but, if you want to claim ANY deductions, even yourself as a dependent, you'll need a national ID.
Want to apply for any federal job? We're talking, just APPLYING for the job, even if you don't get a formal job offer. Guess what you'll need?
Thoughts?