• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!
  • Welcome to our archives. No new posts are allowed here.

More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of war

K

KidRocks

DP Veteran
Joined
Aug 17, 2005
Messages
1,337
Reaction score
16
Location
right here
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Liberal
All the more reason to start withdrawing our troops sooner than later, this war is done with, over and out!










More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of war - USATODAY.com

WASHINGTON (AP) — More American troops were killed in combat in Iraq over the past four months — at least 334 through Jan. 31 — than in any comparable stretch since the war began, according to an Associated Press analysis of casualty records.

Not since the bloody battle for Fallujah in 2004 has the death toll spiked so high.

The reason is that U.S. soldiers and Marines are fighting more battles in the streets of the Iraqi capital, Baghdad, and other cities. And while hostile forces are using a variety of weaponry, the top killer is the roadside bomb.

In some respects it is the urban warfare that U.S. commanders thought they had managed to largely avoid after U.S. troops entered Baghdad in early April 2003 and quickly toppled the Saddam Hussein regime.

And with President Bush now sending thousands more U.S. troops to Baghdad and western Anbar province, despite opposition in Congress and the American public's increasing war weariness, the prospect looms of even higher casualties...
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

:roll:

More US soldiers died in the first hour of D-Day.
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

Goobieman said:
:roll:

More US soldiers died in the first hour of D-Day.
Click to expand...





Oh, so does that make our troops death rate in Iraq trivial in comparison to WW2 and D-Day? Is that what you mean? Is that what, in effect, you're saying?

If more of our troops died in record numbers in accordance with D-Day would that justify the war in your mind?

Think, Goobieman, before you downgrade the sacrifice of the lives of our brave troops in Iraq. That you think American troops dying is of very little importance or value speaks volumes of you conservatives.

Their deaths are not insignificant when compared to WW1, WW2, D-Day, Vietnam or any other comparison your minds can conjure up!
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

He's not saying it's insignificant, you just like to spin everything people say in your threads and expect the posters that come into this thread to say "oh, look what Bush has done, he's murdering our American soldiers, damn idiot.".Sorry, but that's not the case, and it's not as if they died fighting for nothing.My condolences to their families, but what is there to say, people pass in wars.
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

FierceEnigma12z said:
He's not saying it's insignificant, you just like to spin everything people say in your threads and expect the posters that come into this thread to say "oh, look what Bush has done, he's murdering our American soldiers, damn idiot.".Sorry, but that's not the case, and it's not as if they died fighting for nothing.My condolences to their families, but what is there to say, people pass in wars.
Click to expand...

That is exactly what he is saying and I am sick and tired of you r-wingers, with your sad comparisons, in effect saying that our troops deaths in Iraq are inconsequential.

Shame on you extremists!
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

KidRocks said:
Oh, so does that make our troops death rate in Iraq trivial in comparison to WW2 and D-Day? Is that what you mean? Is that what, in effect, you're saying?
Click to expand...
Compared to any of those, our death rate in Iraq is miniscule.

In fact, our KIA rate in Iraq is -easily- the lowest for any long-term large-scale military operation in history.

If people like you had any historical perspective at all, you'd see just how inane you sound to those of us that do.
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

FierceEnigma12z said:
He's not saying it's insignificant, you just like to spin everything people say in your threads and expect the posters that come into this thread to say "oh, look what Bush has done, he's murdering our American soldiers, damn idiot.".Sorry, but that's not the case, and it's not as if they died fighting for nothing.My condolences to their families, but what is there to say, people pass in wars.
Click to expand...



Et tu Brute?
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

KidRocks said:
That is exactly what he is saying and I am sick and tired of you r-wingers, with your sad comparisons, in effect saying that our troops deaths in Iraq are inconsequential.

Shame on you extremists!
Click to expand...

Well I'm not saying they are inconsequential or irrelevant, and I'm no r-wing extremist, but soldiers will always die in war, that's just the facts, but the fact that your ready to bash any Con. who comes to your thread to say anything other than Bush is a murderer and a war monger, in one of your threads like this, is quite silly of you.
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

KidRocks said:
Et tu Brute?
Click to expand...

Except, he still hasn't said "it doesn't matter because more soldiers have died in other wars, so who cares".It's called comparing, buddy.
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

KidRocks said:
Oh, so does that make our troops death rate in Iraq trivial in comparison to WW2 and D-Day? Is that what you mean? Is that what, in effect, you're saying?

If more of our troops died in record numbers in accordance with D-Day would that justify the war in your mind?

Think, Goobieman, before you downgrade the sacrifice of the lives of our brave troops in Iraq. That you think American troops dying is of very little importance or value speaks volumes of you conservatives.

Their deaths are not insignificant when compared to WW1, WW2, D-Day, Vietnam or any other comparison your minds can conjure up!
Click to expand...

What he is saying is that the title of this thread is an out-and-out lie.

It is a lie to say that more US troops have died in Iraq in the past four months than any similar period of war.

It's a stupid lie that is easily shown to be a lie.

Because he pointed out that lie, you launch a personal attack on him by accusing him of not caring about the sacrifice of our troops.
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

Because he pointed out that lie, you launch a personal attack on him by accusing him of not caring about the sacrifice of our troops.
Click to expand...
Welcome to KR's MO.
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

MrFungus420 said:
What he is saying is that the title of this thread is an out-and-out lie.

It is a lie to say that more US troops have died in Iraq in the past four months than any similar period of war.

It's a stupid lie that is easily shown to be a lie.

Because he pointed out that lie, you launch a personal attack on him by accusing him of not caring about the sacrifice of our troops.
Click to expand...




How so?

How is the title of this thread is an out-and-out lie?

Did you consult with Goobieman? Are you his spokeman? Or are you just assuming Goobieman ?
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

KidRocks said:
Oh, so does that make our troops death rate in Iraq trivial in comparison to WW2 and D-Day? Is that what you mean? Is that what, in effect, you're saying?
Click to expand...


ummmm.....no

I believe he was saying that simply politicizing the deaths doesn't mean jack squat. It's not about the # of casualties, but if the cause is worthly***








***Distinction must be made that ARealConservative does not approve of this military campaign.
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

We should just pull leave Iraq and let the rape squads take control again, start up the torture factories again, let people be oppressed into the stability that only the dead and cowering have. Yeah, that's it. Freedom for Americans and to hell with everyone else. :roll:

<sarcasm off>
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

faithful_servant said:
We should just pull leave Iraq and let the rape squads take control again, start up the torture factories again, let people be oppressed into the stability that only the dead and cowering have. Yeah, that's it. Freedom for Americans and to hell with everyone else. :roll:

<sarcasm off>
Click to expand...

We shouldn't care if our views of representative government are popular with those we wish to free. We should ignore a long history of failed attempts to revolutionize nations that don't wish our aid and provide it anyway.</sarcasm>
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

Yes everyone, don't you see? Congress is making more and more cries that Bush is wrong and we must pull out immediately because there are so many deaths. The media is crying and crying that we must pull out immediately because there are so many deaths. And WOW, low and behold...more deaths happen.

Now lets see...that HAS to just be a coincidence. It couldn't be because that just tells those on the other side that "Hey, if we ramp things up and give it a last gas, we may be able to get them to leave early". Nah, that'd be to logical and focus on common sense. We're not allowed to use that.
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

ARealConservative said:
We shouldn't care if our views of representative government are popular with those we wish to free. We should ignore a long history of failed attempts to revolutionize nations that don't wish our aid and provide it anyway.</sarcasm>
Click to expand...
The premise here is based on the idea that the Iraqi people dont want to be "Revolutionized" -- that is, in this case, they dont want to have a functioning western-style democracy over what they had under Saddam.

You'd be hard pressed to find many non-Sunnis to go along with that statement.
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

Zyphlin said:
Yes everyone, don't you see? Congress is making more and more cries that Bush is wrong and we must pull out immediately because there are so many deaths. The media is crying and crying that we must pull out immediately because there are so many deaths. And WOW, low and behold...more deaths happen.

Now lets see...that HAS to just be a coincidence. It couldn't be because that just tells those on the other side that "Hey, if we ramp things up and give it a last gas, we may be able to get them to leave early". Nah, that'd be to logical and focus on common sense. We're not allowed to use that.
Click to expand...

And they say their anti-war rhetoric doesnt embolden the enemy. :roll:
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

CurrentAffairs said:
Kidrock is always looking to celebrate.
Click to expand...






Sure CurrentAffairs, we know you don't want to be bothered with such low numbers either.

Now, take Hiroshima, I'm sure you are well more impressed with the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and the 140,000 Japanese who were fried there. Now those are numbers of dead you can respect!

7 dead Americans? I'm sure that that number is too small to be important to you CurrentAffairs!


I posted the following reply to you on another thread but it applys here as well CurrentAffairs
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

Goobieman said:
The premise here is based on the idea that the Iraqi people dont want to be "Revolutionized" -- that is, in this case, they dont want to have a functioning western-style democracy over what they had under Saddam.

You'd be hard pressed to find many non-Sunnis to go along with that statement.
Click to expand...

the premise is that our actions can lead to a functioning government that is somehow better. It matters not if they want to be "revolutionized". The argument is if their ideas of a revolution are worthy of American lives.


Now that we assisted removing Saddams shackles, the fight is in who gets to take over this "honor". I refuse to risk my life for such a revolution so I will be damned if I'm going to use my voice to risk someone elses life.

Now please excuse me. I was thanked by KidRocks and must now take a very very long shower


~unclean..scrubscrubscrub....unclean....~
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

ARealConservative said:
Now please excuse me. I was thanked by KidRocks and must now take a very very long shower


~unclean..scrubscrubscrub....unclean....~
Click to expand...


LOL... and I love it! :rofl
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

ARealConservative said:
the premise is that our actions can lead to a functioning government that is somehow better. It matters not if they want to be "revolutionized". The argument is if their ideas of a revolution are worthy of American lives.
Click to expand...
And how is that premise flawed? You seem to assume that our actions -can't- lead to that government. Why?

Like I said - if you asked the Iraqis, I think you'd find it difficult to fiond non-Sunni support for returning to what they had under Saddam.
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

I don't think anyone is making light of the lives lost in Iraq but in comparison to other wars the numbers a very low. To act as though this war is the worst ever in terms of human lives is simply false and inaccurate.
 
Re: More U.S. troops died in Iraq over past four months than in any similar period of

Goobieman said:
Like I said - if you asked the Iraqis, I think you'd find it difficult to fiond non-Sunni support for returning to what they had under Saddam.
Click to expand...
Your premise is ridiculous. No, they aren't going to want a return to Saddam. That in no way means the form of government they do want is deserving of risking life and limb.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom