Surenderer
Active member
- Joined
- Jun 29, 2005
- Messages
- 469
- Reaction score
- 0
I also hear that the worse of the pictures didnt even get released but are soldiers in the pictures we havent seen also being prosecuted? Why not if they arent?
mixedmedia said:It's very simple. Because all I read is excuses and remarks about "our enemies" and no correlating outrage on how our prisoners were treated while in our care. It hardly matters where we are or who we are mistreating when you purport to be a country that upholds the principles of human rights. Let's leave it at that though. Tom DeLay just resigned as House Majority Leader. It's party time.
Surenderer said:I also hear that the worse of the pictures didnt even get released but are soldiers in the pictures we havent seen also being prosecuted? Why not if they arent?
GySgt said:Where are the excuses? Where are the remarks? They are guilty and wrong for what they did and they have lost rank, pay, military service, careers, and they are serving prison time over it. There is the justice.
Now, as the upstanding Americans with higher morals and ethics that we are, we have punished the accused. Will this make a difference to the extremists? Will they follow our example? Doubt it. I doubt they even care. In fact, they would have preferred that we did nothing. That would give them their next "excuse" to murder civilians.
The most positive impact that this Court Martial should have is the millions and millions of Muslims around the world that was paying attention to it. Because, ultimately, American civilization and Middle Eastern civilization is struggling for their hearts and minds.
Navy Pride said:So let me understand what your saying.........You think that what happened on 9/11/01 was justified?
Stinger said:No statments such as your are what give terrorist and insurgence motivation for their mission to destroy us.
Lyndie England gets three years. Well i think that should do it.
mixedmedia said:Then we can agree. Somewhat. I somewhat agree with most of your views on Middle Eastern conflict. One thing that often sets me back though, is your insistence on comparing our actions to the actions of Islamic militants as if to say, "Well at least we didn't chop their heads off." I do believe that America represents an ethic that is vastly different than the Islamic terrorists' - thus it is totally useless and perhaps even disadvantageous to compare them. It's like constantly re-drawing the line in the sand if our actions are always being recalibrated and re-judged in comparison to those who obviously don't bother much with drawing lines in the first place. Our standards should be resolute in the face of resolute inhumanity.
I thought I already stated that 9/11 was not justified. Did you read my posts? What I am saying, is the US did bring it on itself, because the US has a history of participating in terrorism. If you don't participate in terrorism, you won't be the target of terrorists. It's a simple way to fight terrorism. Don't participate in it. Terrorism is never justified whether it be the actions of a government or a terrorist organization like Al-Queda.
TimmyBoy said:We have to talk and deal in truth and not nationalist fantasies. Our most powerful weapon is the ideas of freedom. However, we are not using our most powerful weapons, we are using bombs and tanks, which give terrorists more power.
jamesrage said:Sound like you are justifying what the terrorist did.Do you wear a "I heart Osama Bin Laden" t-shirt?[/QUOTE]
Haha. I don't believe that he is trying to "justify" what the terrorist did persay.....but that was funny.
Navy Pride said:What happened there was not torture............Real torture is what happened at the Hanoi Hilton............
GySgt said:I believe, despite a few instances that were beat to death in the media for poitical gain, that our standards are still resolute.
GySgt said:You see? This is where you fall short. For the sake of argument..take away our foreign policy in the Middle East. What is left is Arab Islam. With our foriegn policy no longer in the picture...is Israel safe from Muslims? Will the violence against infidels cease to exist? Will Bin Laden tell "Allah" (His other proclaimed reason to murder Christians, Buddhists, and back-slidden Muslims), that he no longer subscribes to the idea of punishing the world for not praising his god? Will Bin Laden and millions of others tell "Allah" that they no longer wish to destroy Israel and vanquish infidels from their "holy lands?"
The answer is no. This is bigger than our foreign policy. Their blasphemy of Islam and their convictions to adhere to it is very real and it needs no American "help."
mixedmedia said:So what is the answer? I'm a cut to the chase kind of person. What do we do? Do you truly believe that invading Iraq was the right move at the right time? Truly?
GySgt said:Unless we are willing to do something about the House of Saud, terrorism will persist.
GySgt said:Sure. I don't think it mattered. Unless we are willing to do something about the House of Saud, terrorism will persist.
mixedmedia said:Well, I'm going to take a stab at interpreting this and say that in other words we are ****ed? Am I far off?
kal-el said:Exactly. So this stupid "war on terror" is in fact, useless.
GySgt said:If you want to say that. There is still the Iraq aspect. It offers us great strategic value.
GySgt said:I didn't say that. Any action in the Middle East is in the right direction. The problem is that we got bogged down in Iraq and didn't continue into Syria.
mixedmedia said:I don't want to say that. It just seems that the Saudi royalty are a pretty intractable bunch. Not to mention the fact that our own administration seems to take a pretty tolerant stance towards their rule.
A peaceful Iraq offers great strategic value perhaps.
GySgt said:I didn't say that. Any action in the Middle East is in the right direction. The problem is that we got bogged down in Iraq and didn't continue into Syria.
GySgt said:Don't stop with today's President. We are pledged to protect the Sauds. We have protected them with our military and civilian blood in order to protect the world's oil supply for decades. Economies around the globe would be a mess if it depended on an unstable existence between the bigotted Shi'ites and the biggoted Sunni in the Middle East. Until, we can get an alternate energy source, we're stuck. In the mean time, the Srabs treat their people like ****, people like Bin Laden blame us for ALL of their problems, they distort and practice a blashemous form of Islam and lash out at anyone in the western world. America get's the heat of it, because we do the dirty work that the rest of the world benefits from.