• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Is communism possible in the USA?

Is communism possible in the USA?

  • Yes, Soviet type of communism

    Votes: 9 9.1%
  • Yes, community type of communism

    Votes: 10 10.1%
  • Yes, religious type of communism

    Votes: 2 2.0%
  • Yes, other type of communism

    Votes: 12 12.1%
  • No, not possible

    Votes: 57 57.6%
  • Dunno

    Votes: 3 3.0%
  • Other

    Votes: 6 6.1%

  • Total voters
    99

Canell

Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
Mar 7, 2011
Messages
3,851
Reaction score
1,170
Location
EUSSR
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Libertarian
To save the poll from influence, I will spare my opinion for the time being. :)

So, is communism possible in the USA?
 
So, is communism possible in the USA?

Only if it's called something else with a conservative ring to it...like say....Christianity.
 
If the Constitution is not upheld at all then anything is possible, but I think that it would be more likely that a Fascist Regime would be more probable than a Communist one.
 
To save the poll from influence, I will spare my opinion for the time being. :)

So, is communism possible in the USA?

Extremely unlikely I would say. In any event, a Communit USA would no longer be the USA since it would mean doing away with pretty much the whole US Constitution.
 
Extremely unlikely I would say. In any event, a Communit USA would no longer be the USA since it would mean doing away with pretty much the whole US Constitution.

Thats true, it wouldn't the USA anymore. It would be an authoritarian theocracy with all the communist bells and whistles. And since Jesus preached socialism....it would be an easy switch......if only it weren't for that darn constitution and separation of church and state.
 
Thats true, it wouldn't the USA anymore. It would be an authoritarian theocracy with all the communist bells and whistles. And since Jesus preached socialism....it would be an easy switch......if only it weren't for that darn constitution and separation of church and state.

Actually, Jesus didn't preach socialism since he preached that His Kingdom was not of this world.

Besides, Communists tend to very intolerant towards religion.
 
Actually, Jesus didn't preach socialism since he preached that His Kingdom was not of this world.
Yes, but you have to die to get there. Is Christianity a religion of death? No, Jesus preached social justice for the poor here on earth.

Besides, Communists tend to very intolerant towards religion.
They can still call themselves communists.....all 50 or 60 of them. lol

"....The Communist Party is not against religion, but instead regards positively religious people's belief in justice, peace and respectful relations among the peoples. To build good relations with supporters of religion, the party has its own Religious Commission..."
Communist Party USA - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

What is the world coming to when communists have their own religious commission? I think that kinda shows how desperate they must be getting to even exist in the US. But, if they changed their name to something with a christian ring to it....like say.... faithers.........they'd probably get a lot more takers. Then they could start planting. By the time people realized they were communists in sheep clothing, it will either be too late or it won't matter.
 
Yes, but you have to die to get there. Is Christianity a religion of death? No, Jesus preached social justice for the poor here on earth.

They can still call themselves communists.....all 50 or 60 of them. lol

Communist Party USA - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

What is the world coming to when communists have their own religious commission? I think that kinda shows how desperate they must be getting to even exist in the US. But, if they changed their name to something with a christian ring to it....like say.... faithers.........they'd probably get a lot more takers. Then they could start planting. By the time people realized they were communists in sheep clothing, it will either be too late or it won't matter.

The idea of claiming that Christ espoused a particular ârty political ideology is ridiculous.
 
The idea of claiming that Christ espoused a particular ârty political ideology is ridiculous.
First you said, it was communism that was intolerant of religion. I showed you that it is possible for communism to espouse religion.
 
The idea of claiming that Christ espoused a particular ârty political ideology is ridiculous.

True, but that doesn't mean that Christianity hasn't been or can't be abused for political ends. And Christian believers often go through great length to legislate their interpretation of Christian morals.

As a European, you'll probably be aware of the "christian democratic" parties in Europe, which at least initially based their support for social systems or their demand even for "Christian socialism" (German Christian Dems ca. 1945-48 i.e.) on Christianity.
 
First you said, it was communism that was intolerant of religion. I showed you that it is possible for communism to espouse religion.

You showed no such thing. Communism has a proven track record of bloody suppression of religion. Googling some phantasy-texts o the internet doesn't change that.
 
To save the poll from influence, I will spare my opinion for the time being. :)

So, is communism possible in the USA?

I imagine that much depends on exactly how you define “Communism”.

Strictly-speaking, I would have to define Communism as the social order that Marx envisioned; and on that basis, I would argue that Communism is not possible at all, here in the U.S., nor anywhere else—at least not on any kind of scale. There have been quite a few nations that have declared themselves to be Communist-based, and have tried to implement a Communist society; and without so much as a single exception, they have all gone very, very far astray from what Marx envisioned. I think we've seen enough attempts to implement Communism, all fail in the same ways, that I can safely predict that there never will and never can be a true Communist society.
 
Last edited:
True, but that doesn't mean that Christianity hasn't been or can't be abused for political ends. And Christian believers often go through great length to legislate their interpretation of Christian morals.

As a European, you'll probably be aware of the "christian democratic" parties in Europe, which at least initially based their support for social systems or their demand even for "Christian socialism" (German Christian Dems ca. 1945-48 i.e.) on Christianity.

Any religion can be abused for political ends.

As for christian-democracy, this is a political current which is pretty old (mid 19th century in some countries) and which does not purport to be synonymous with a religion.
 
Absolutely possible. It will not be called "Communism", it will be called something else. But the envy, the lust for power, the collectivism...they are simply elements of our human nature. The ones we have to suppress, if we want to stay civilized - and, in the long term - survive.
 
Any religion can be abused for political ends.

As for christian-democracy, this is a political current which is pretty old (mid 19th century in some countries) and which does not purport to be synonymous with a religion.

Yeah smartass, and exactly that is what the OP asked for.
 
Yeah smartass, and exactly that is what the OP asked for.

I can't help you deal with your feelings of inadequacy. Seek professional help for that.
 
You showed no such thing. Communism has a proven track record of bloody suppression of religion. Googling some phantasy-texts o the internet doesn't change that.
Oh ye of little faith. My source was the "Communist Party USA".


"Communists are not against religion. We are against capitalism. In fact, the Party has its own Religion Commission which seeks to build positive relations with religious people and communities in the struggle to make life better for working people. Most religious people believe in justice, peace, and respectful relations among the peoples of the world, and many are motivated by their faith to work for those goals.

Membership in the Communist Party is open to all who agree with our program, regardless of religious beliefs."

FAQ » cpusa
 
Oh yea of little faith. My source was the "Communist Party USA".

FAQ » cpusa

I can provide you with quotes from Hitler saying he was only interested in peace. I guess that would prove conclusively to you that he was a pacifist?
 
No... It's highly unlikely. the possibility of communism returning to any country in the Free World is limited.

We must remember that communism never sprung out by itself in any free country. Russia was an absolute monarchy when it was overtaken by the reds. China was also a dictatorship when the first revolts sprung. Cuba wasn't really a democracy,etc.

So no. No country that has a tradition of freedom and liberty ever turned to communism without external "help".

The most powerful of communist countries, China, doesn't have the influence or power to spread it's communism around the world since it very much depends on the free world for its continuous growth.
 
We must remember that communism never sprung out by itself in any free country. Russia was an absolute monarchy when it was overtaken by the reds. China was also a dictatorship when the first revolts sprung. Cuba wasn't really a democracy,etc.

Communism is not a trade mark of Mr. Karl Marx, you know. ;)
In fact, what he proposed is just the opposite of Communism.
 

That's not communism. it's communualism (people living in a very tight community with very strong traditions). And it's a type of society that can never be adopted by the masses since it's backwards and anti-progress... which means that even if it is adopted (by miracle) by the masses, it's lifespan will be short. And the people who adopt it will, in time, fall behind the rest of the world which will overtake them.
 
Communism is not a trade mark of Mr. Karl Marx, you know. ;)
In fact, what he proposed is just the opposite of Communism.

For better or for worse, the term Communism refers to a specific ideology that does have Karl Marx as one of its main theorists.

I understand you want to use it to refer to other forms of societal arrangements, but that only obscures the discussion.
 
Back
Top Bottom