• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Huge anti-labor reform protests rock France

TheDemSocialist

Gradualist
DP Veteran
Joined
Apr 13, 2011
Messages
34,951
Reaction score
16,311
Gender
Undisclosed
Political Leaning
Socialist





Read more @: Huge anti-labor reform protests rock France

A new labor law reform bill has been introduced in France and since March massive protests have been going underway in France. The new labor law would increase the workday to 46 hours, reduce payouts to employees, weaken worker protection laws so workers can be fired more easily. There is also talk that this movement that is sweeping France is about something bigger, that the dominant 'Socialist Party' has embraced neo-liberalism and that there is little other alternative option for the French people to embrace. Many who are a part of this movement are calling for the end to neo-liberalism and the creation of an alternate democratic system.
 
More:


French labor reform protests turn violent | Reuters
 

Few things are more hilarious than French youth angrily insisting that they remain highly unemployed :lol:


Not to challenge your source, but I'm interested in how the work day is going to be increased to 46 hours. Are they going to be flying around the world with the sun while working?
 

46 hours a week.
 
46 hours a week.

I read where they actually put in a measure that would allow unions to negotiate a work week that would allow 46 hours a week "over two weeks" (so, basically, they could surge work at some points, and let down at others). So, it didn't change the law for regular workers, it just allowed unions to negotiate that for themselves, if that's what the members wanted (after all, unions negotiate what members want - right?).



Giving greater flexibility to unions! Horrors! It'll be Randian Objectivism, next. :lol:




But more to the point - the more expensive you make it to hire someone, and the more impossible you make it to fire them, the more you simply ensure that they will never be hired in the first place. Witness the refusal of the French Public to accept that reality.
 
This is what happens when a bunch of "progressives" intellectually soil themselves and can no longer sustain such lazy and noncompetitive labor practices.

I find it funny that things resort to violence and riots when French people are asked to work like Americans.
 

Orrr. this is what happens when a population is fed up with neo-liberal bull**** and fed up with 2-3 strong political parties that dont represent them in their parliamentary democracy...
 
I find it funny that things resort to violence and riots when French people are asked to work like Americans.

Don't tell me, you work 4 jobs, go to college and only got one kidney? I've seen you on Sally.

We don't too badly for productivity:

Increasing Productivity & the National Living Wage | Starboard Thinking

indeed, many previous OECD and INSEE reports have given France the highest productivity rates in the world (be productive and look them up for yourself).

We maybe don't need to work ridiculous US hours just to scrape together a decent living like many of your compatriots do, shameful in a rich nation.

Some people can see beyond the neo-liberal claptrap and realise that there are alternatives to the laissez-faire capitalist model which is once again in global crisis. I was previously a PS supporter but they're trying to do a Tony Blair/Tony Giddens third way and it won't wash with the French. I love my work and I work hard when I'm there but I have a life too, and when it's time to go home, I'm off. I don't need to work 60 hours a week to earn a decent living.
 

Sadly the picture in the UK isn't so rosy - we're working more and more hours and becoming less productive though apparently we've always lagged behind the other G7 countries.

I'd prefer we were offered what the Swedes have been experimenting with which is 6 hour days but doing the same amount of work - tired workers doing long hours doesn't help anyone.
 

To be fair most protests of this size in France turn violent.. There are just some countries where violence and protests go hand in hand.. France and Greece lead the pack and have for decades if not centuries. Hell modern France came about based on a protest turn violent...

As for the labour reforms... they are needed pure and simple. It has nothing to do with neo-liberalism but common sense. The balance between workers and employers has always been a problem. In the US the employers have massive power where as in France it is the workers. It should not be like that. There has to be a balance.

By balance I mean no one should be happy. Take my own country of Denmark. We had the French situation before the 1980s and slowly but surely changed. Back when I was young, an unemployment of 8% was considered full employment. Now days it is near 2% which is one of the lowest in the industrialized world. What changed? Well for one it got a hell of a lot easier to fire people, both in the private and public sectors. But it also got easier to just leave a job if you wanted and that meant the employment market got far more fluid. The unions lost power yes, but not in such a way that compromised the rights of workers. Some would of course still claim that unions were still too strong in Denmark (I would be one of them), but at the same time companies dont need to get permission from a court system to fire people... like in France and Spain. The Danish system aint perfect by any means.. you still have legacy union rules that basically force people into unions in certain old companies.. this pisses me off, but having a structural unemployment fall from 8% to 2% is huge.

I would think that structural unemployment in Spain is at least 10%, where as in France it is at least 7%... and that is because of the inflexibility of the labour market and the rules around it.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…