• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

How many here belong a union in the public or private sector? Why? or Why not?

How many here belong to a union?


  • Total voters
    67
  • Poll closed .
My step mother like you was a teacher and retired doing it. She always hung with the unions, supported democrats, and now wishes she had taken the time to think for herself.

My mother-in-law was a teacher and hated the union but had no choice but to belong. If you don't belong, you don't work. She fought the union from the inside her entire career.
 
Really? she could send her retirement back to the state every month. Geeze...

And why should she do that unless everyone else that is part of the problem did as well?

By that same token, since liberals wanted everyone to have health insurance, they should have taken on themselves to pay for it and left the rest of us out of the equation
 
My mother-in-law was a teacher and hated the union but had no choice but to belong. If you don't belong, you don't work. She fought the union from the inside her entire career.

I had a group of union thugs at a plant take sledge hammers to my company car at the time because they were on strike when I crossed. I got a new car out of the deal which was great but it still pissed me off to the point that I took the time to visit each one of them individually after the incident. It is amazing how many mice it takes to make one thug.
 
We do pay for everyone's health care now, just in the most inefficient way possible. But this thread is about something else. If I felt I had l taken money I did not deserve I certainly would not keep it. I remember when the conservatives were my moral and ethical compass, now it is not at all uncommon for them to say something like "And why should she do that unless everyone else that is part of the problem did as well?" Not just you, the right wing has completely lost it way. In fact, I remember when they thought an education was important, since they discovered teacher were in the union, not so much. Oh well, unless the Republicans do something soon, they wont be around for me to pick on much longer.
 

We can only take you word on that but since you are a fence sitter giving you a way out either way, we will take the grain of salt with that.
 
Really? did you file a police report? Then you went out and "visited" them? Are you saying you went and beat up "union thugs?" You win. I am done. :roll:
 
Last edited:
What grain of salt? and what fence? I am just not a partisan hack. Try it sometime.
We can only take you word on that but since you are a fence sitter giving you a way out either way, we will take the grain of salt with that.
 
Really? did you file a police report? Then you went out and "visited" them? Are you saying you went and beat up "union thugs?" You win. I am done. :roll:

I gave every one of them the same treatment more or less that I received that day to them. Call the police? are you kidding? small town, this employer made up 60% of the total tax base. That union busted the plant, it has been closed for 4-5 years now.

It was no big deal then, I was 30, it would be much more difficult now.
 
You behaved as thuggishly as they did. How inspired.
 
Unlike your opinions, his opinions are backed up by solid facts which he sourced from BLS:

Union Members Summary

I have a degree in labor relations and law. I have practiced labor law for close to 30 years

I suspect that is far more experience than being a left wing propagandist
 

NOt when the contrary opinions are based on lies or misinformation. this country was well on its way to becoming the greatest country in the world before there were unions
 

Now I think we getting to see the real you, you don't just dislike union workers you have a real problem with liberals in general , do you understand that mot all union workers are liberals? There might actually be one or two libertarians and maybe even some conservatives that are union members
 


In your type written words you state that less then 3% of 4400 committed crimes led to an arrest or conviction. Without a conviction determining who was responsible or even if a crime was committed is impossible. Using your numbers over a twelve year period would mean that 11 maybe crimes where maybe committed by union workers each year, that is what your source labels as "maybe" union violence? Those facts make it look like union workers are as close to being angels as can be found among mortal human beings
 

I would almost be willing to bet that after your visit those union thugs repented for their horrible behavior, turned over a new leaf and never ever committed any act that could be considered as violent,do you know if they joined a boy scout group or church choir?
 
NOt when the contrary opinions are based on lies or misinformation. this country was well on its way to becoming the greatest country in the world before there were unions

So we were not the greatest country in the world before the unions came along? At what point do you think we became the greatest country in the world? Do you think we are now the greatest country in the world?
 

There are a few conservative union members.

As a matter of fact, I know one union member who has more conservative values and actually voted for Mitt Romney. Even though he knew it COULD be detrimental to the union, he thought it would be better for the country as a whole. Of course, I don't agree (I didn't like either candidate), but that's another topic entirely. Lol!
 
So we were not the greatest country in the world before the unions came along? At what point do you think we became the greatest country in the world? Do you think we are now the greatest country in the world?

the industrial revolution in the USA-Eli Whitney etc was pre-Union

Unions did not build our shipping industry

nor the transcontinental railroad

and yes we are even though the left is doing its best to ruin our position
 
NOt when the contrary opinions are based on lies or misinformation. this country was well on its way to becoming the greatest country in the world before there were unions

If you like robber barons. :shrug:
 
It would be on the news smarty.

You must live in a closet, there is a lot of violence in this country that never makes the news.
 
You must live in a closet, there is a lot of violence in this country that never makes the news.

Sure, there's a lot of violence, but not a lot of union violence. Face it, you are making up hyperbole.
 

no, but they never took a bunch of sledge hammers to one of my cars again. That strike lasted for 1.5 years and I crossed many more times.
 
You must live in a closet, there is a lot of violence in this country that never makes the news.

As a matter of fact, I'm still waiting on a link for ALL the violence that union members do in the north east.
 
Sure, there's a lot of violence, but not a lot of union violence. Face it, you are making up hyperbole.

Bull****, my Dad worked for in a union for years at an appliance factory, he came home bloody, never made the news even once. I can't believe there is anyone so naive as to think every union action makes the news.:lamo
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…