• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Exporting Doctors

Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

Under the Castroit tyrannical regime ‘free choice', is a phrase which has no meaning. Doctors who refuse to become a money making export for the regime, are punishing by lowering their professional status, canceling their internet and email accounts, denied advancement in their careers and punished in other ways. Those who agree to work abroad for less than 25% of the salary negotiated by the regime, which keeps the rest, are reminded of the grave consequences their family members in the island will suffer if they defect.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

The argument that the doctors are provided their education for free by the regime, does not hold water. They in effect are paying for their ‘free’ education by the low wages paid to them by the regime for their entire life, a very high price. The argument that the Cuban doctors have no valid complaints to walk away from their contract, a new form of slave labor, is an injustice that cannot be allow to stand.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

Those doctors who had filed suits to challenge the deal, denounced by a Brazilian judge as a “form of slave labor”, were fire right away by their Cubans supervisor in Brazil and given the option of leave immediately for Cuba or have to wait 8 years to be allow to return to it. Those with families in Cuba, hold as hostages by the regime, face the situation of not seeing their family for 8 years if they did not comply with the demand.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

The Public Health Ministry (MINSAP) has the nerve to announce that it would allow doctor who have defected to come back. Nobody is going to believe in their siren songs. The priority of the regime is to maintain power and control. Doctors are treated as commodities. They don’t see their years of study and dedication reflected in their wages.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

The Castroit regime on December 1, 2015 started once again restrict foreign trips abroad by specialist doctor (cardiologists, surgeons, renal specialists, pediatricians, gynecologists and others). Doctors with those skills doesn’t want to resign themselves to poor pay and professional stagnation. Medical students are not provided with a document with the existing clause stating that they must comply with the immigration laws after graduating. Centralize management and migratory regulation is not a solution. The solution is a democratic system that give the people the right to make their own choices with few restrictions.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

Obviously a number of Cuban doctors in Brazil have decided that they do not want to be treated as slaves. The Brazilian government has allow a number of Cuban doctors to remain in the country after the end of their mission. The Castroit regime decided not to send more doctors to Brazil for fear of desertions and worry its spread to other countries where Cuban doctors work for slave wages. After all the “export of medical services” is the larger source of revenue of the Castroit regime.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

These doctors who are contracted are not 'free' to do so in the legal sense of the word; these contracts are indeed ones of serfdom. 'Free choice' is a phrase which is not respected by the Castroit regime. Doctors who do not choose to be treated like property and become a money making export for the regime are denied advancement in their careers or are punished in other ways. Those that do go abroad are reminded frequently that their spouse or families will suffer should they defect.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc


It's called propaganda with a grain of truth. When I asked this Cuban what her braces cost on her teeth, she replied about $65 for everything. She was totally shocked that my kids braces were about $3,000 or almost 50 times as much. Keep in mind that $3,000 is more than ten years wages on the island.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

Doctors who 'agree' to leave family and loved ones to work abroad in return for receiving less than 25% of the wages earned (the rest go to the Castroit regime) are not doing so freely, they are doing it because they are coerced to or hopping to escape from the island. According to the article doctors who choose to exercise their judicial rights are threatened with exile for eight years.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc


Why would anyone want to return to the economic privation of Cuba before eight years? Scorpions sting because it's their nature. Complaining about reality doesn't change it. Scorpions sting; Communists repress. That's just the way it is.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

According to the Castroit regime when the doctors trained in Cuba’s universities will return home to treat patients “equipped with some of the best medical training in the world.”

SA Health Department has fine out the hard way that they has to retrained the medical doctors trained in the “medical power” universities in Cuba for two more years and take an exam after their retraining to obtain their doctor license, due to the deficiency of their training under the Castroit regime.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

According to a report by the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons, “more than 75% of “doctors” with Cuban “medical degrees” flunk the exam given by the Educational Commission for Foreign Medical Graduates for licensing in the U.S.” No wonder SA has to retrain them.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

The Castroit regime is praise for its “humanitarian” healthcare missions sent to other countries. But in reality the regime, according to the article, will collect $11 billion in 2017 from the pay of its health workers, making it the largest source of hard currency for the regime.

Since 2003, when Venezuela agreed to provide 53,000 barrels of oil per day in exchange for a number of medical services, the regime has cut the number of doctors operating on the island and sold their services abroad.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

Since 2003 service exports have been the primary source of foreign currency of the regime. Cuban health professionals generate billions in tax revenue by working for the regime while overseas.

See table below from Oficina Nacional de Estadísticas de Cuba (ONE).

TABLE 1. Cuba’s service exports in millions of dollars
Year-----------------------Service exports
-------------------------(Excluding tourism)

2003---------------------------845.4
2004-------------------------1,520.8
2005-------------------------4,151.6
2006-------------------------4,432.5
2007-------------------------5,715.4
2008-------------------------6,219.5
2009-------------------------5,680.2
2010-------------------------7,441.6
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Source Anuario Estadístico de Cuba (Statistical Yearbook) for 2009, 2010 and 2011.
Oficina Nacional de Estadísticas (ONE), República de Cuba.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

From 2006 to 2016, more than 8,000 Cuban doctors benefited from the “Cuban Medical Professional Parole” program that allows them to settle in the United States. The program was eliminated in January 2017 by the Obama administration.

The new Brazilian immigration law of November 2017, could benefit Cubans doctors who have abandoned the More Doctors mission and have an expired temporary visa. These doctors are considered deserters and are not allow to return to Cuba for 8 years. They can request “permission for residence with a temporary visa on humanitarian grounds”, since the Brazilian government wouldn’t allow them to work as doctors due to pressure from the Castroit regime. Hopefully this new migration law would allow them to work in their profession again.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

United Nation statistics show that Cuba’s health, education and standard of living levels grew under a democratic-capitalist system during the period 1902–58.

In 1957 Cuba ranked in 13th place worldwide in infant mortality rate; 32nd in life expectancy at birth; 25th in maternal mortality ratio; 26th in physician density per population; 16th in dentists; 14th in midwives; 26 in pharmacists. In the Americas ranked 6th in nurses, and 3rd in hospital beds.

In 2007, under the Castroit regime, Cuba ranked in 34th place worldwide in infant mortality rate; 43rd in live expectancy at birth; 68th in maternal mortality ratio; 1st in physician density per population (based in total number of doctors, not the actual numbers of doctors in Cuba serving the population). The regime hasn’t provided data in the number of dentists; midwives and pharmacists.

Reference link: http://www.ascecuba.org/c/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/v22-stusser.pdf
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

There are a total of 70,000 Cuban doctors. According to MINSAP 30,000 Cuban doctor’s work overseas and another 13,000 have left Cuba. The actual numbers of doctors in Cuba are around 27,000. Of those 10% quit their profession to work in more lucrative jobs, leaving only 24,300 working in their profession. The regime has acknowledged that there is a shortage of doctors and nurses in Cuba. On December 2007 the vice minister of public health, Joaquín García Salaberría, took the highly unusual step of admitting on Cuban television that there were shortages of doctors and nurses. The real per capita of doctors in Cuba is one doctor per 469 people. This would rank Cuba in 57th place in physician density per population.

Cuba's infant mortality rate is kept low by the regime’s tampering with statistics, by a low birth rate of 12.5 births per 1000 population, and by a staggering abortion rate of 77.7 abortions per 1,000 women (0.78 abortions per each live birth. Data based on official statistics from the Cuban government). Cuba had the lowest birth rate and doubles the abortion rate in Latin America. Cuba's abortion rate was the 3rd highest out of the 60 countries studied. (The Incidence of Abortion Worldwide | Guttmacher Institute)
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

Another health parameter linked to infant mortality, is the maternal mortality rate. Cuba’s maternal mortality rate is 33 deaths per 1,000 live births. This health statistic is high despite the fact that Cuba has the lowest birth rate in Latin America. The doctors are supposed to suggest abortion in risky pregnancies and, in some occasions, must perform the interruption without the consent of the couple. Cuban pediatricians constantly falsify figures for the regime. If an infant dies during his first year, the doctors often report he/she was older (infant mortality rate is define by the number of deaths during the first year of life per thousand live births). Otherwise, such lapses could cost him severe penalties and his job.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

In all nations with high emigration rates longevity rates skew high. This occurs because the birth is recorded but the death gets recorded in the nation migrated to. So it seems like fewer people die. A nation with high longevity but with high emigration has little to boast about with regards to longevity figures. During the last 57 years, 2.7 million Cubans have emigrated/born abroad. The actual island population is 11.2 million. The 2.7 million represent 19.5% of the total population, a high emigration rate. This is one of the reasons of the high life expectancy.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

In 1958 Cuba had 370 medical centers in service (Mesa Lago and Hernandez, 1964, p. 160) among 72 public hospitals, 28 polyclinics, 140 mutual aid clinics and cooperatives, and 130 private medical institutions that provided an additional 15,000 beds for a total of 36,140 beds for a population of 6.63 million, equivalent to one bed per 183 per inhabitant. In the 72 public hospitals assistance was free. Private healthcare facilities covered 40% of the population. There were 200 state operated “First Aid Clinics” (Casas de Socorro) in 52 of the 130 municipalities, and assistance was fee.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

United Nation statistics show that Cuba’s health, education and standard of living levels grew under a democratic-capitalist system during the period 1902–58.

In 1957 Cuba ranked in 13th place worldwide in infant mortality rate; 32nd in life expectancy at birth; 25th in maternal mortality ratio; 26th in physician density per population; 16th in dentists; 14th in midwives; 26 in pharmacists. In the Americas ranked 6th in nurses, and 3rd in hospital beds.

In 2007, under the Castroit regime, Cuba ranked in 34th place worldwide in infant mortality rate; 43rd in live expectancy at birth; 68th in maternal mortality ratio; 1st in physician density per population (based in total number of doctors, not the actual numbers of doctors in Cuba serving the population). The regime hasn’t provided data in the number of dentists; midwives and pharmacists.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

The outstanding indebtedness is over the last 8 month no years That is, from September 2017 to March 2018. The Castroit regime is praise by the mainstream media for its “doctor diplomacy” humanitarian mission worldwide. But in reality doctor diplomacy is no more than a trafficking in slave labor, which has become the regime greatest export, bringing more than 8 billion a year. Cuban doctors working abroad receive less than 25% of the wages earned and the rest go to the Castroit regime. A portion of their earnings are retained in Cuba and can be collected only if they return to the island.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians�, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

The article “Why The Unqualified Cuban Doctors Will Kill The Ghanaian People.” (Opinion | Why The Unqualified Cuban Doctors Will Kill The Ghanaian People), expressed great worry about the lack of expertise displayed by Cuban doctors. In Uganda, the expense involved in hiring 200 Cuban slave doctors caused such an uproar that the government had to reduce the number to 40. Go HERE (Uganda: Only 40 Cuban Doctors Ready for Uganda Jobs, Says Minister - allAfrica.com) for details on this kerfuffle.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians�, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

Despite the end of the parole program by the Obama administration that welcome medical professionals to the United States, Cuban doctors continuous to flee from other countries and keep going north to the U.S. border with no guarantees that they will be granted asylum. Hopefully a new parole program could be work out with the Trump administration.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians�, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

The Cubanization of Uganda’s health system would have the following effects:

1. Uganda’s doctors went on strike demanding the fulfilment of their demands. The Minister of Health proposed the hiring of doctors from Cuba to replace them.

2. Criticism of the plan to import doctors from Cuba. There is not lack of doctors, since Uganda’s doctors are leaving the country looking for better working conditions. So far 9% of doctors have migrated from Uganda.

3. The government pay about $ 5,000 per doctor/month, of which 70% goes directly to the Castroit regime. The government pay the Cuban doctors $1,500 (of which the regime keep half of it until they return to Cuba), excluding housing, transport and security allowances which adds to the expenses, while only pay the Uganda doctors $1,220.

4. The Uganda Medical Association (UMA) says “the comprehensive cost for importing Cuban doctors likely outweighs benefits.” Added that the language barrier is a problem too.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…