• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Exporting Doctors

The Castroit newspaper Granma reported that the Cuban doctors got their salaries raise to $64 from $25 a month. Health professional are the regime top source of hard currency export earnings.

The regime health workers and other professional working abroad bring in $8.2 billion a year in export earnings. By contrast the value of the regimen exports brought by tourism, nickel and remittances together total only $5.6 billion a year.
 
Cuban doctors working oversees earn far more that the ones working at home, but still between 80 to 85 % of their salaries goes to the regimen for their work.

Cuban doctors in Brazil were pay only $1,000 of their $4,000 salary, with the balance going to the Castroit regime. After the incident their salary was raised to $1,245, but 60% of the salary is send back to Cuba and only paid to them if they return to the island. Otherwise they forfeit it.

Obviously this is an “attack on human, individual and labor rights.” The slave labor deal so far is on. Slavery by any other name is still slavery.
 
Cuban doctors working oversees earn far more that the ones working at home, but still between 80 to 90 % of their salaries goes to the regimen for their work.

Cuban doctors in Brazil were pay only $1,000 of their $4,000 salary, with the balance going to the Castroit regime. After the incident their salary was raised to $1,245, but 60% of the salary is send back to Cuba and only paid to them if they return to the island. Otherwise they forfeit it.

Obviously this is an “attack on human, individual and labor rights.” The slave labor deal so far is on. Slavery by any other name is still slavery.
 
In the last two years over 3,100 Cuban doctors have defected to foreign countries despite the risks. They pay a heavy price by doing that, since their families are not allow to leave the island for at least 5 years. The regime retain their passports, medical degree and qualifications making very difficult for them the re-validation process and work in their profession in other countries.
 
Last edited:
The Castroit regime collect more than $6 billion a year from the pay of its health workers. See table 1 for service exports up to 2010.

 
The Castroit regime has for many years been treating the health care personnel as “exportable commodities.” It is a modern day version of trafficking in human beings, a multibillion dollars form of international crime, a violation of human rights. In 2013 the regime earned $10.4 billion exporting professional services, especially in the health sector, to other countries, the same amount brought by total exports, tourism and remittances all together in 2013.
 
Financially, "doctor diplomacy" is an outstanding source of income for Castroit regime economy since MINSAP pays doctors and other personnel only a small fraction of the millions of dollars that are received by the regime.
 
According to the Castroit regime estimate it will collect $8.2 billion in 2014 from the pay of its health workers, making it the largest source of hard currency.

This deal between the Brazilian Government and the Castroit regime, has been denounced in Brazil, an others countries, as forced labor, since under the terms of this contract the Cuban doctors have no power of decision about salary and working conditions. At the same time their passports are retained by the regime and their relative in the island kept as hostages to avoid their defection.
 
ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doctors

The Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “the contracts of the Cuban doctors have the characteristics of slave labor and only serve to finance the Cuban government.” The contract between the Brazilian Government and the Castroit regime is clearly in violation of the UN “Trafficking in Persons Protocol”, and the International Labor Organization “Protection of Wages Convention” of 1949.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

There are a total of 70,000 Cuban doctors. According to MINSAP 30,000 Cuban doctor’s work overseas and another 13,000 have left Cuba. The actual numbers of doctors in Cuba reach 27,000. Of those 10% quit their profession to work in more lucrative jobs, leaving only 24,300 working in their profession. The regime has acknowledged that there is a shortage of doctors and nurses in Cuba. On December 2007 the vice minister of public health, Joaquín García Salaberría, took the highly unusual step of admitting on Cuban television that there were shortages of doctors and nurses. The real per capita of doctors in Cuba is one doctor per 469 people, not one doctor per 160 people as the regime boast.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

The Castroit “doctor diplomacy” involves utilizing Cuban physicians to serve in areas where the Cuban regime has entered into contractual relationships with the expressed intention of providing health care aid and establishing or nourishing diplomatic relations with the host community. The physicians serving in these units are essentially under surveillance all the time and any change in their plans not consistent with the orders given from Havana invariably lead to the involvement of police or paramilitary security forces. It is no wonder that many physicians in such missions defect to freedom.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

Many of the Cuban doctors that accept to work overseas do so as a way to escape from the miserable life in the island. But in many of those countries the doctors find out they are imprisoned in their new assignments. They are send to work in remote communities and restricted means of transportation, and under surveillance all the time. If there are changes in their plans not consistent with the regime guidelines would normally lead to involvement of the police. Because they live their lives in servitude to work in those countries, many doctors in such medical missions defect to freedom. About 10,000 health workers, many of them physicians, have left Cuba in the last 12 years.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

I really don't understand how some people can support such a system or blame those who try to escape it unless they see their rejection of a tyrannical regime as a threat to their own political ideology.

Freedom and liberty are the highest human yearning. Without personal liberty you have nothing. Security at the cost of personal liberty isn’t worth it. Castros’ tyranny has always been a despotic monarchy. Only useful idiots believe otherwise.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

The Castroit tyrannical regime has for many years been treating the health care personnel as “exportable commodities.” It is a modern day version of trafficking in human beings, a multibillion dollar form of slavery, a violation of human and labor rights.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

The international community should not be cowed into respecting the rights of a regime that does not respect the rights of its people.

State capitalism seems alive and well in the Castroit regime with money to be made selling the services of its doctors at the expense of its own country's medical needs.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

The left defines and produces economic justice wherever they are in power. It is that system of universal poverty, except for the elites, that leads people to leave their families and their homeland in order to seek something better.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

Recent news stories have highlighted the growing trend for Cuban doctors to defect to foreign countries. The more doctors program pays about $4,255 per month salary to each doctor in the three year program. From this $4,255 Cuban doctors receive $1,125 per month. The Castroit regime retain the remaining $3,130, a 74% of the total salary.

Since 2003 service exports have been the primary source of foreign currency in Cuba. See table below.

 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

Cuban doctors in in the island earn little more than $25 a month. These doctors, to make ends meet, supplement their income by having side jobs in the informal economy. Cuban doctors generate billions in tax revenue by working for the regime while overseas.

Since 2008, the regime has cut the number of doctors operating on the island and sold their services abroad. From August 2013 to June 2015, the Castroit regime has collected over $1.4 billion from the Brazilian government in exchange for the services of 11,456 Cuban medical professionals. The Castroit regime estimate it will collect $9 billion in 2015 from the pay of its health workers, making it the largest source of hard currency.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

According to the Venezuela newspaper El Universal, over 300 Cubans doctors defected from Venezuela in 2013 and 700 in 2014. During the same years approximately another 1,290 Cuban doctors from other foreign missions, including Brazil, had defected too, for a gran total of 2,290 defections in two years.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

Since 2007 close to 5,500 Cuban doctors have defected to the United States while serving on aid missions abroad. The labor of Cuban doctors abroad can be depicted as “state sponsored marketplace in human trafficking” carried out by the Castroist regime. (EEUU revisa programa para médicos desertores — Telemundo 51)
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

Brazil set up a “remedial course” for Cuba trained doctors. Other countries have also required them to take additional exams. Beyond the problems with the course load countries noted that Cuba trained doctors lacked knowledge of modern techniques and treatments.

Medical education in Cuba has been deteriorating. Costa Rican officials reviewed the Cuban medical school curriculum and found that 25-30% of courses required for medical students in Costa Rica were not given. The failure rate in certification exams just proves the point.

The reason that Cuban doctors lack new technology is not the embargo. For over 15 years Cuba has been able to freely import medicines and medical equipment from the US.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

The regime has chosen not to import medicines and medical equipment from other countries, including the U.S., for the hospitals reserved for the Cuban people, creating a medical apartheid system in the island. The hospitals for the elite and medical tourists are well stocked with everything from medicines to new technology. One has to be extremely naive to believe that the “embargo” is the reason the Cuban hospitals reserved for the people lack everything from medicines, bed sheets, equipment, etc., while in the hospitals for the medical tourist all of the above is available.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

Yet President Obama keeps close ties with the Castroit regime. Repression remains unpunished and severe violation of human rights keep occurring in the case of health professionals. How come that the Castroit regime is not sanctioned for keeping alive at all costs this despicable method of slavery. On the contrary, it is supported by other regimes signers of the declaration of human rights of the UN. Until when will have the Cuban health professionals to withstand this slavery?
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

It is obvious the exploitation has been carried out for years, which the doctors accept because “of the wolf a hair”, since it is worse to stay in Cuba being destitute and without hope of improving their status. There are currently very few professors of renown in the hospitals, there are now "teachers" that formerly had not been able to qualify as such.
 
Re: ReThe Brazilian “National Federation of Physicians”, has said, “th: Exporting Doc

The Castroit regime is characterized since its inception by exceedingly criticizing any form of capitalist society, is not more than the worst of the worst exploiters and enemies of the working class, since it is a one-party system with strict control of all the media that does not allow freedom of speech and expression of the people and their right to a dignified life with the fruit of their labor.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…