• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Ethno-Nationalist Putin Uses the Language of Genocide

Litwin

Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
Sep 2, 2017
Messages
33,607
Reaction score
5,193
Location
GDL/Sweden
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Centrist
“Self-purification.” “Spit out traitors.” This is language that precedes a genocide.




pootler.png
 
He's a monster, I live for day he goes down.
 
All the things that precede a genocide is 1)systematic, and 2)comes from the in-group.

While there is oppression of civilians by government forces in russia, certainly, there's no indication of any in-group/out-group dynamics here, either in putin's statement or otherwise.

The closest we see to this is between Russians and the Chechens situation. Even then, there's no evidence that Russia is going to genocide chechens anytime soon(chechens aren't even pro-west).

this is just ridiculous fear porn.
 
“Self-purification.” “Spit out traitors.” This is language that precedes a genocide.




View attachment 67380579


Okay.

Putin WAS the reincarnation of Hitler.

NOW, he is the reincarnation of Hitler AND Stalin.

There are absolutely no redeeming qualities in any or all of these three.
 
Here's a worthy reply from Arnie:

 
Here's a worthy reply from Arnie:



I read the lies by editing that you have posted in your sig line.

You should be ashamed.
 
whats about my qestion ? I Ilyin´s one
Man, I don't even watch RT, nor could I if i even wanted to(althought redacted tonight is still posting videos on youtube, apparantly).

Both Ukraine and Russia are very corrupt countries. Them killing each other only benefits the US.

however, leave it to Biden to **** it up, and hand Russia to China on a silver platter.

Now, china not only has its own factories and financial sector, they also have their own gas station
 
i asked you about Pootler´s fav philosopher Ivan Ilyin ? can you give me your answer ?
I'll give you an answer, but i must know something first....you call this man a fascist philosopher, so my question is, how popular is he among fascists groups? KKK, skinheads, richard spencer, and the like? How many actively refer to him? If I go to stormfront, will i see many articles or threads about him and his ideas?
 
how popular is he among fascists groups?
stay on topic ivan, we speak about your fav Muscovy , so how IS HE POPULAR IN MUSCOVY´s leadership ? do you have an answer ?
 
stay on topic ivan, we speak about your fav Muscovy , so how IS HE POPULAR IN MUSCOVY´s leadership ? do you have an answer ?
I am on topic. You asked about ivan, and i asked about just how well followed he is.

How many "fascists" even know who he is? Do YOU know who he is?
 
How many "fascists" even know who he is?
here we go :

Ilyin is quoted and mentioned not only by the president of Russia, but by the prime-minister Medvedev, foreign minister Lavrov, several of Russia’s governors, patriarch Kirill, various leaders of the United Russia Party and many others besides.

It is about more than just quotes here and there. Ilyin’s books were recommended as a must read by two of the Kremlin’s “grey cardinals” – Vladislav Surkov and Vyacheslav Volodin. Mikhael Zygar, in his book “All the Kremlin’s Men,” claims that it was precisely these works of Ilyin that influenced Putin’s definition of traditional Russian values. We could argue for a long time whether this means that he is just one of the “approved Kremlin philosophers,” or something much bigger, but I would like point out something simpler to prove: Ilyin — who the state has been promoting for the last 15 years as a genuine Russian philosopher, exemplary statist and true Russian patriot — is a very dubious historical figure to draw inspiration from, even an inappropriate person just to quote. He was a proponent of fascist ideology; a trait he did not renounce even after the end of the Second World War.
pootler.png
To get around this awkwardness, Ilyin’s works tend to be divided into two categories. The first one is made up of his works on Russian statehood and spirituality, which are considered respectable and worthy of quoting by the head of the state and others. The second category: dubious texts about fascism that Putin does not quote, so can be ignored. No such divide, in essence, exists between these categories, only that he is just being more explicit in the second category. Ilyin is in fact quite consistent; his ideas of spirituality and the Russian state are closely linked to his positive views of the regimes of Hitler, Mussolini, Salazar and Franco.

Ukraine vs Russia - Page 143 - Google Books Result​

https://books.google.se › books



Olexander Hryb · 2021 · ‎Political Science
... President Putin not only quoted the fascist Eurasianist Ivan Ilyin three ... a new Moscow shrine, organized by Patriarch Kirill in 2009 (Snyder 2016).
 
here we go :

Ilyin is quoted and mentioned not only by the president of Russia, but by the prime-minister Medvedev, foreign minister Lavrov, several of Russia’s governors, patriarch Kirill, various leaders of the United Russia Party and many others besides.

It is about more than just quotes here and there. Ilyin’s books were recommended as a must read by two of the Kremlin’s “grey cardinals” – Vladislav Surkov and Vyacheslav Volodin. Mikhael Zygar, in his book “All the Kremlin’s Men,” claims that it was precisely these works of Ilyin that influenced Putin’s definition of traditional Russian values. We could argue for a long time whether this means that he is just one of the “approved Kremlin philosophers,” or something much bigger, but I would like point out something simpler to prove: Ilyin — who the state has been promoting for the last 15 years as a genuine Russian philosopher, exemplary statist and true Russian patriot — is a very dubious historical figure to draw inspiration from, even an inappropriate person just to quote. He was a proponent of fascist ideology; a trait he did not renounce even after the end of the Second World War.
To get around this awkwardness, Ilyin’s works tend to be divided into two categories. The first one is made up of his works on Russian statehood and spirituality, which are considered respectable and worthy of quoting by the head of the state and others. The second category: dubious texts about fascism that Putin does not quote, so can be ignored. No such divide, in essence, exists between these categories, only that he is just being more explicit in the second category. Ilyin is in fact quite consistent; his ideas of spirituality and the Russian state are closely linked to his positive views of the regimes of Hitler, Mussolini, Salazar and Franco.

Ukraine vs Russia - Page 143 - Google Books Result

https://books.google.se › books


Olexander Hryb · 2021 · ‎Political Science
... President Putin not only quoted the fascist Eurasianist Ivan Ilyin three ... a new Moscow shrine, organized by Patriarch Kirill in 2009 (Snyder 2016).
1647736821718.png
 
Back
Top Bottom