• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

DP Star Wars Film Ranking Game

+2 Empire Strikes Back
+1 A New Hope
-1 The Last Jedi
-2 The Phantom Menace

The Empire Strikes Back 108
Return of the Jedi 104
The Last Jedi 101
Rogue One 101
A New Hope 101
Revenge of the Sith 100
The Force Awakens 99
Attack of the Clones 93
The Phantom Menace 92
 
+2 Empire Strikes Back
+1 A New Hope
-1 The Last Jedi
-2 The Phantom Menace

The Empire Strikes Back 110
Return of the Jedi 104
A New Hope 102
Rogue One 101
Revenge of the Sith 100
The Last Jedi 100
The Force Awakens 99
Attack of the Clones 93
The Phantom Menace 90
 
+2 Empire Strikes Back The story and character arcs in the movie kept my girlfriend (Now Wife's) interest high enough that she watched the last 4 movies in the series. Not my favorite until I got older and my tastes in movies changed.
+1 A New Hope (Han Shot First Edition)
- 1 Attack of the Clones The acting in this movie seemed very wooden and drawn out. I have a hard time watching it.
-2 The Last Jedi Despite some great scenes and a good overarching theme, the poor writing, needless plot detours, and misuse of multiple characters and plot points to subvert things for the sake of subversion... this movie killed my enthusiasm for upcoming SW movies. I guess I can still be excited about Rebels.

The Empire Strikes Back 112
Return of the Jedi 104
A New Hope 103
Rogue One 101
Revenge of the Sith 100
The Force Awakens 99
The Last Jedi 98
Attack of the Clones 92
The Phantom Menace 90
 
+2 Empire
+1 A new Hope
-1 Phantom Menace
-2 The Last Jedi

The Empire Strikes Back 114
Return of the Jedi 104
A New Hope 104
Rogue One 101
Revenge of the Sith 100
The Force Awakens 99
The Last Jedi 96
Attack of the Clones 92
The Phantom Menace 89
 
+2 A new Hope
+1 Revenge of the Sith
-1 Attack of the Clones
-2 The Force Awakens - For throwing out everything with meaning from the original trilogy. Stupid bull**** movie
 
+2 Revenge of the Sith: My favorite SW movie, and the first SW movie I ever saw in theatres. Order 66 really made me sad.

+ 1 Rogue One: Fun movie, Battle of Scarif was amazing.

-1 Attack of the Clones: Anakin and Padmé relationship. 'Nuff said.

-2 The Force Awakens: Mostly a rehash. Wanted something new.
 
Psychoclown said:
No one can explain why Anakin took such risky, highly telegraphed route of attack when he could've just hopped off the little floaty thing and charged up the hill.
Click to expand...

I have to partly disagree here - having the high ground in a swordfight is actually a pretty significant advantage. The vast majority of swings happen below the shoulder to minimize exhaustion from swinging a weapon around. All of Anakin's attacks would have been right at Obi Wan's chest height, while all of Obi Wan's attacks would have been swinging straight for Anakin's head - everything Anakin would have done on the low ground would be more tiring, while Obi Wan's job would have been easier in every regard.

Anakin was still a retard for jumping like he did.
 
Updated standings ...

The Empire Strikes Back 114
A New Hope 106
Return of the Jedi 104
Revenge of the Sith 103
Rogue One 102
The Last Jedi 96
The Force Awakens 95
Attack of the Clones 90
The Phantom Menace 89
 
+2 Empire
+1 A New Hope
-1 Phantom Menace
-2 The Last Jedi

The Empire Strikes Back 116
A New Hope 107
Return of the Jedi 104
Revenge of the Sith 103
Rogue One 102
The Force Awakens 95
The Last Jedi 94
Attack of the Clones 90
The Phantom Menace 88
 
+2 Return of the Jedi
+1 Empire
-1 Attack of the Clones
-2 The Last Jedi

The Empire Strikes Back 117
A New Hope 109
Return of the Jedi 106
Revenge of the Sith 103
Rogue One 102
The Force Awakens 95
The Last Jedi 92
Attack of the Clones 89
The Phantom Menace 88
 
+2 Empire
+1 A New Hope
-1 Phantom Menace
-2 The Last Jedi

The Empire Strikes Back 119
A New Hope 110
Return of the Jedi 106
Revenge of the Sith 103
Rogue One 102
The Force Awakens 95
The Last Jedi 90
Attack of the Clones 89
The Phantom Menace 87
 
Revenge +2
Last Jedi +1
Strikes back -1
New Hope -2


The Empire Strikes Back 118
A New Hope 108
Return of the Jedi 106
Revenge of the Sith 105
Rogue One 102
The Force Awakens 95
The Last Jedi 91
Attack of the Clones 89
The Phantom Menace 87
 
+2 Empire
+1 A New Hope
-1 Phantom Menace
-2 The Last Jedi

The Empire Strikes Back 120
A New Hope 109
Return of the Jedi 106
Revenge of the Sith 105
Rogue One 102
The Force Awakens 95
The Last Jedi 89
Attack of the Clones 89
The Phantom Menace 86
 
Psychoclown said:
+2 Empire
+1 A New Hope
-1 Phantom Menace
-2 The Last Jedi

The Empire Strikes Back 120
A New Hope 109
Return of the Jedi 106
Revenge of the Sith 105
Rogue One 102
The Force Awakens 95
The Last Jedi 89
Attack of the Clones 89
The Phantom Menace 86
Click to expand...

This is really important to you huh
 
+2 Empire
+1 A New Hope
-1 Phantom Menace
-2 The Last Jedi

The Empire Strikes Back 122
A New Hope 110
Return of the Jedi 106
Revenge of the Sith 105
Rogue One 102
The Force Awakens 95
Attack of the Clones 89
The Last Jedi 87
The Phantom Menace 85

Nilly said:
This is really important to you huh
Click to expand...

Star Wars is serious business. :)
 
+2 Empire
+1 RoTJ
-1 TFA
-2 The Last Jedi

The Empire Strikes Back 124
A New Hope 110
Return of the Jedi 107
Revenge of the Sith 105
Rogue One 102
The Force Awakens 94
Attack of the Clones 89
The Last Jedi 85
The Phantom Menace 85
 
REvenge of the Sith +2
The last Jedi +1
A New Hope -1
Empire Strikes back -2

The Empire Strikes Back 122
A New Hope 109
Return of the Jedi 107
Revenge of the Sith 107
Rogue One 102
The Force Awakens 94
Attack of the Clones 89
The Last Jedi 86
The Phantom Menace 85
 
+2 Empire
+1 A New Hope
-1 Phantom Menace
-2 The Last Jedi

The Empire Strikes Back 124
A New Hope 110
Return of the Jedi 107
Revenge of the Sith 107
Rogue One 102
The Force Awakens 94
Attack of the Clones 89
The Last Jedi 84
The Phantom Menace 84
 
Psychoclown said:
I basically ignored the Space Jesus stuff (and of the things I mentioned, it was probably the least annoying or problematic) and did watch the other two prequels which got better (a little) but never came close to matching up to the original trilogy. What was implied in Revenge of the Sith, that Darth Plageius created Anakin by manipulating the force kind of made up for it, but the old EU then rejected that theory and told us the force itself conceived Anakin as a countermeasure to Plageius and Sidious's manipulations, bringing us back to Space Jesus. But now the old EU has been set aside, so I'm not sure where that stands. The new EU is kind of odd in that it builds on and references things from the old EU, but its hard to know what from the old EU is still considered cannon unless it is explicitly referenced or mentioned.
Click to expand...
They set aside the old EU so they could make up a new one and copywrite/trademark it.

They'll gladly include what bits of it they want to.
 
+2 Empire
+1 A New Hope
-1 Phantom Menace
-2 The Last Jedi

The Empire Strikes Back 126
A New Hope 111
Return of the Jedi 107
Revenge of the Sith 107
Rogue One 102
The Force Awakens 94
Attack of the Clones 89
The Last Jedi 83
The Phantom Menace 82
 
+2 Empire
+1 A New Hope
-1 The Last Jedi
-2 Phantom Menace


The Empire Strikes Back 128
A New Hope 112
Return of the Jedi 107
Revenge of the Sith 107
Rogue One 102
The Force Awakens 94
Attack of the Clones 89
The Last Jedi 82
The Phantom Menace 80
 
+2 Empire
+1 A New Hope
-1 Attack of the Clones
-2 The Last Jedi


The Empire Strikes Back 130
A New Hope 113
Return of the Jedi 107
Revenge of the Sith 107
Rogue One 102
The Force Awakens 94
Attack of the Clones 88
The Last Jedi 80
The Phantom Menace 80
 
+2 A New Hope
+1 Return of the Jedi
-1 Revenge of the Sith
-2 Phantom Menace

The Empire Strikes Back 130
A New Hope 115
Return of the Jedi 108
Revenge of the Sith 106
Rogue One 102
The Force Awakens 94
Attack of the Clones 88
The Last Jedi 80
The Phantom Menace 78

They are now perfectly ordered. Balance has been brought to the force.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom