• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

DeSantis slams NCAA and Lia Thomas, declares Florida swimmer 'rightful winner'

no, that has not been shown to be a blanket case for all individuals in all sports. Lying and saying otherwise won't make it true. lol
It's proven science lol. You've been shown numerous citations in the other thread showing males have a biological advantage over females for strength, size, endurance etc. And that is quite clear for Mr. Thomas.
 
It is about basic fairness. To go from being ranked 500th and then to win championships just because you changed genders is inherently unfair


Its discrimination
One person.

This is a panic over a single person.

A whole political movement being based on the panic over a single human swimmer.

Laws are being passed in states to stem the tide against what amounts to a danger posed by literally tens of people a year.

All to shit on trans kids.

For votes.
 
It's a demonstrated statement of fact, as evidenced by Mr. Thomas lol
no, its simply not LMAO its just you saying it
 
The right-wing's racism and misogyny is always someone else's fault.

The bigots are the real victims here.
This is just stupid politics for the Democrats.

Over 1500 men have ran a 4 minute mile. Not one woman in history has. The world record vo2 max for a man is 96, for a woman it is 77. The world record squat for a man is 1080 pounds, for a woman it is 570 pounds.

We have gender separated sports for a reason, it is so we can have competitive women's sports. If you allow male-to-female transgendered athletes to compete in women's sports, then we will destroy a lot of women's sports.
 
I wonder if she has made a complete transition? If so then she should be allowed; if not then she still has masculine tendencies and shouldn't be allowed. It really does make a difference if transgenders; male or female have had a complete transition to their revised gender
What are those? Musculature changes upon fully transitioning? How about arm length? How about muscle twitch?
This lady went from middle of the pack as a man, to first place as a woman immediately upon being allowed to compete.
 
It's proven science lol. You've been shown numerous citations in the other thread showing males have a biological advantage over females for strength, size, endurance etc. And that is quite clear for Mr. Thomas.
no, that has not been shown to be a blanket case for all individuals in all sports. Lying and saying otherwise won't make it true. lol
 
no, its simply not LMAO its just you saying it
Quite clearly demonstrated fact. It's hilarious watching you deny basic biology though.
 
It’s like everyone has already forgotten about Mack Beggs.
 
no, that has not been shown to be a blanket case for all individuals in all sports. Lying and saying otherwise won't make it true. lol
It's been shown to you numerous times that Males have a biological advantage over females in strength, endurance and size.
 
One person.

This is a panic over a single person.

A whole political movement being based on the panic over a single human swimmer.

Laws are being passed in states to stem the tide against what amounts to a danger posed by literally tens of people a year.

All to shit on trans kids.

For votes.
All this to shit on women


Women who had to fight for title 9. Women who have had to fight discrimination their whole lives.


Now the argument is....well its only a little more discrimination....you can handle it.



Its awful
 
All this to shit on women


Women who had to fight for title 9. Women who have had to fight discrimination their whole lives.


Now the argument is....well its only a little more discrimination....you can handle it.



Its awful
Gov Cox is correct.

He vetoed a law that would affect four children in his state.

This is a complete over reaction for votes.

It is 100% transparent
 
Quite clearly demonstrated fact. It's hilarious watching you deny basic biology though.
Says "you" and zero facts
let us know when you can produce this scientific community consensus that all transfemales have an unfair advantage in all sports . . .ready .. go!

who bets this request is dodged and more failed retarded lies are posted LMAO
😂🍿
 
here are two pics of the person in the OP. they are either in consecutive years or maybe two years apart.


Trans Swimmer Lia Thomas Arrogantly Bragged About How 'Easy' Her Race Was
 
Gov Cox is correct.

He vetoed a law that would affect four children in his state.

This is a complete over reaction for votes.

It is 100% transparent
If it was a thousand trans athletes would it be wrong?


Is discrimination ok if it only affects a small number?


They said that about gay marriage at one time
 
Says "you" and zero facts
No, says biology.
let us know when you can produce this scientific community consensus that all transfemales have an unfair advantage in all sports . . .ready .. go!
Strawman
who bets this request is dodged and more failed retarded lies are posted LMAO
😂🍿
Males have biological advantages in strength, endurance and size. This is not debatable. This is proven biology.

 
Gov Cox is correct.

He vetoed a law that would affect four children in his state.

This is a complete over reaction for votes.

It is 100% transparent
It's political malpractice for Democrats to side with male-to-female transgendered women in women's sports. You can say that there are not that many male-to-female transgender athletes, but there are not many top tier athletes period. By definition, a top tier athlete is a 1 in a million athlete.

Over 1500 men have ran a 4 minute mile. Not one woman in history has. The world record vo2 max for a man is 96, for a woman it is 77. The world record squat for a man is 1080 pounds, for a woman it is 570 pounds.

If you are in a major city and go to a gym that area power lifters train in, you will likely at some point see a local lifter squat more weight than any woman in history has and the same is true for deadlifts.
 
This is a contentious issue and I understand both positions. This example will probably end up as something that history will remember. That being said, DeSantis is just projecting himself into the narrative for exposure, imo.



Glad I know Ron "Little Adolph" DeSantis can multitask the BS or else I might begin to think he doesn't have any real Governor thingies to attend to!
 
What are those? Musculature changes upon fully transitioning? How about arm length? How about muscle twitch?
This lady went from middle of the pack as a man, to first place as a woman immediately upon being allowed to compete.
  • Decreased libido. This will begin one to three months after starting treatment. ...
  • Decreased spontaneous erections. ...
  • Slowing of scalp hair loss. ...
  • Softer, less oily skin. ...
  • Testicular atrophy. ...
  • Breast development. ...
  • Redistribution of body fat. ...
  • Decreased muscle mass.
 
here's another sport where men/former men will crush women...


How the U.S. Women's National Soccer Team Captured Our Hearts - E! Online
 
No, says biology.

Strawman

Males have biological advantages in strength, endurance and size. This is not debatable. This is proven biology.

just like i said, NOTHING that makes your claim statement of facts and your retarded strawman bites the dust, thanks for proving me right AGAIN LMAO

question, who here is arguing that "in general Males who have not transition do NOT have biological advantages in strength, endurance and size."

did ANYBODY here say that? is so please quote them

anybody want to go double or nothing that no quotes will be provided of anybody factually saying that and nothing will be provided showing the scientific community consensus that all transfemales have an unfair advantage in all sports
to easy and so much fun LMAO
😂🍿
 
here's another sport where men/former men will punish women...


The U.S. Women's Ice-Hockey Team's Hard Road to the Winter Olympics Finals  | The New Yorker
 
here's another sport where men/former men will send women to the hospital


USA Rugby Women's National XV Stars & Stripes Rosters - djcoilrugby


Women's rugby players train with U.S. National Team | The Dartmouth
 
just like i said, NOTHING that makes your claim statement of facts and your retarded strawman bites the dust, thanks for proving me right AGAIN LMAO
I stated males have a biological advantage. You said they didn't. I provided proof that they do. You whine and do your little troll game. It's hilarious.
question, who here is arguing that "in general Males who have not transition do NOT have biological advantages in strength, endurance and size."
Males who DO transition, still have a biological advantage, as you've been shown.
did ANYBODY here say that? is so please quote them

anybody want to go double or nothing that no quotes will be provided of anybody factually saying that and nothing will be provided showing the scientific community consensus that all transfemales have an unfair advantage in all sports
to easy and so much fun LMAO
😂🍿
Nobody has any obligation to address or refute arguments you make up, pull from our ass, and attribute to others.

Meanwhile, as I correctly stated, males have a biological advantage over females. Trans females, are males. It's biology.
 
Back
Top Bottom