BWG said:
Let's see, lily asks the question "What makes the Republicans think that the Democrats are not over 2000 and 2004?"
cnredd responds "hmmmmmmmm.....Let's see if I can take a crack at it..."
cnredd then produces quotes from Debate Politics Forums showing that indeed 11 posters are not over the 2000 and 2004 elections. So far, so good.
But then he adds this statement:
Yup!...Looks like
they're "over it" to me...
Yet, in a thread just the other day, he correctly argued that a few does not represent all.
cnredd said:
"See?...A person on YOUR side of the aisle said something whacky, so you're ALL whacky!"...
BWG,
First off, I'd like to say...EXCELLENT!...
When reading these forums as a forum member, looking to point out indiscrepancies and hypocritical comments should be encouraged...It shows that some members push forward their agenda without logical thought...exposing it shows the other members this, and in the future other members will keep this in mind when reading what was written...
As to this particular comment, you're forgetting the original quote from lily that I responded to...
lily said:
What makes the Republicans think that the Democrats are not over 2000 and 2004?
THAT, BWG, is a generalization...Do you see the words "MOST Democrats"?...Do you see anything indicating, "Only a few are not over it?"...
No, you don't...
lily's statement implies 100%...Obviously a falsehood...
BTW - My use of the word "they're" was referring to those 11 members who've written those comments...Not "all Democrats" as implied by lily's question...That is probably where the misinterpretation lies...read my comment again in that vein and you'll see that makes much more sense...
Also, keep this in mind...
lily did not make that statement ONLY referring to this forum...Her comment was encompassing all Democrats...
If I was able to find 11 JUST on this forum...How many would I find on the whole internet?...100,000?...200,000...maybe a million?...
You're also missing another point...The 11 that I found are ONLY the ones that have publicly voiced the opposite of what lily's question contented on this forum...How many are thinking it WITHOUT publicly writing about it?...If 11 people wrote it, how many agreed?....Surely 100% of the people that are not over it are the ones who wrote it...There can be dozens, hundreds, or possibly thousands of people that view these 11 comments and personally have the same sentiments...
I think you'll agree that those 11 represent a much larger population...
Of course, if asked the question, "Are you over the 2000 and 2004 elections?" to Democrats, the majority will not admit that they are not...It just wouldn't be self-serving...
But even you have to admit that there is a certain percentage that is not over it yet...What that percentage is...1%...5%...10%...20%...we'll probably never know...
But you can deny that it's not 100% as implied by lily's question...
Once again...Loved your thinking...:2wave: