• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Danish Govt trials replacing Microsoft 365

Infinite Chaos

DP Veteran
Joined
Oct 28, 2007
Messages
26,666
Reaction score
23,950
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
First trialled in Germany a year or two ago, now another European nation is trying to break free of the vice-like grip of Microsoft.

"Denmark is moving one of its government ministries from Microsoft Office and Microsoft 365 to the open-source LibreOffice.
It’s another sign that large organizations, especially ones in Europe, are trying to move away from locked-down digital services.

Caroline Stage Olsen, the minister for Digital Affairs in Denmark, confirmed that the country’s Ministry of Digitalization is
switching to LibreOffice. The migration from Microsoft 365 and Office will begin in July, and it’s expected to be complete
within a few months."​

LibreOffice Is Replacing Microsoft 365 in Denmark's Government

Denmark's Ministry of Digital Affairs is switching to the open-source office suite.
www.howtogeek.com

Actually think this is great news. If companies and corporations are not careful, the office productivity software market will belong to to Microsoft alone - especially with the heavy integration of TEAMS and Sharepoint. GDPR requirements demand that European nations do their digital processing in Europe and although Amazon and other nations have data centres here in Europe - Amazon Polly for example does its processing in Virginia.
 
They're picking exactly the wrong time. Microsoft today has as coherent and as compelling a product strategy as I've seen them have since the early 90s when they broke free of IBM with Windows 3.0. There is so much cool stuff with Copilot right now, and plenty more coming, any business not on M365 is going to be left behind.
 
Libreoffice is free.
 
Allan said:
Libreoffice is free.
Click to expand...
And you often get what you pay for. The productivity gains from an AI-enabled office application suite are remarkable, and at least for now Microsoft is way ahead of everyone else integrating AI into that environment.

Alan, I believe you said you're retired from business, but I'm sure you can think back to coworkers who used to write those rambling emails and memos, i.e. the ones that cram four sentences of useful information into 5 or 6 pages of text. I cannot tell you what a pleasure it is now to get those bloated documents and just click "summarize."

And then there's the automatic meeting summarization in Teams. If you arrive 15 mins late to a Teams meeting you just type into Copilot's chat window "Summarize the meeting so far" and you're caught up in seconds. Wonderful stuff.
 
That would be useful as hell.

Also an app that punches someone in the face if they use "reply all".

And a power point limit of 5 slides.
 
Allan said:
That would be useful as hell.

Also an app that punches someone in the face if they use "reply all".

And a power point limit of 5 slides.
Click to expand...
Hear hear.

A quick little Copilot demo. I just asked Copiot to summarize the recent news story of NHL player Nick Tarnasky getting into a fight on a golf course, and do it in the form of a sea shanty. Five seconds later:

We sometimes ask it summarize budget meetings in the same way.
 
Lol that fight summary is brilliant
 
While I applaud the idea, I suspect the "retraining" and lack of viable co-op functions, cloud stuff and other things might be a deal breaker. Add in security issues and frankly people who can service systems/customer support..and you have potentially some massive issues. Rolling out LibreOffice to 10s of thousands ain't gonna be easy.

Let's put it this way.. the reason companies don't goto Linux or other open source stuff, is the loss in productivity in the short and medium term while retraining and bug fixing..this far far out weighs paying Micro$oft.

Ironically I think moving to Google Docs in the Google Suit system might be easier and better for large organisations like a government, but even that has its issues.

We shall see how it goes...
 
I know one problem they will have.. how to replace Outlook.
 

I would argue the opposite. EU laws on security and data processes is tying every single corporation out there to Microsoft because they are the only ones who try to guarantee that data processing and personal data is done within the EU or UK only. No other company is trying to get into this sphere and 1) that helps make Microsoft into an even bigger monopoly and 2) sorry about the politics but Trump has shown us the danger of over-reliance on American services.
Europe needs to have its own digital products and services to that when Trump throws us under a bus again with tariffs, we can do something about the huge deficit we have against American digital products and services.

As an American business too - once you have M365 tendrils all around your business and data - you are never leaving, whether you want to or a better alternative turns up.


If you're a business and you have a paid M365 enterprise solution - it is useful, otherwise you are handing your confidential email data over outside of the European digital footprint. As above - there needs to be an alternate European solution for businesses here.

NatMorton said:
And then there's the automatic meeting summarization in Teams. If you arrive 15 mins late to a Teams meeting you just type into Copilot's chat window "Summarize the meeting so far" and you're caught up in seconds. Wonderful stuff.
Click to expand...

As above.

PeteEU said:
I know one problem they will have.. how to replace Outlook.
Click to expand...

You can still have Outlook free accounts.

There needs to be greater competition and alternatives - not less and definitely not American. If Europe hasn't learnt from the Trump experience, then we deserve to be enslaved to the whims, random policies and reverses of an unfriendly, errant and contradictory American President.
 
Infinite Chaos said:
You can still have Outlook free accounts.
Click to expand...
Sigh.. Microsoft and their naming cluster****. Not talking about Hotmail/Outlook, but about the mail program called Outlook in the office package. If they use that, then it is damn hard to find an alternative that is just as "good", and ween them off Outlook. And no, Thunderbird aint it... it is horrible to use. Not to mention Outlook 365 is often integrated with email systems run on Micro$oft software. Moving from that to "open source" servers is a freaking nightmare.

I dont disagree at all. Problem is an European alternative needs to be useable and viable, and LibreOffice aint that in its current condition and Thunderbird aint no alternative to Outlook for bulk email handling. Like it or not, Micro$oft and Google have had a decade of experience and infrastructure they can use to keep customers and prevent competition. It will take time and a lot of money to make alternatives..not sure any companies want to do that.
 
PeteEU said:
Not to mention Outlook 365 is often integrated with email systems run on Micro$oft software.
Click to expand...

Well, we either resign ourselves to the velvet trap and keep quiet when a Trump turns up or we do something about US digital services and digital products.

PeteEU said:
LibreOffice
Click to expand...

Wasn't LibreOffice a version of Open Office (i.e. American?) I know OpenOffice came out of Star (German) but this is part of the problem - European development being bought by American companies and then we are back to square 1 when it comes to digital trade deficit.
 
**** AI.
 

we are using IBM Notes - no problems with that
 
Infinite Chaos said:
Wasn't IBM support for Notes discontinued in 2018?

Bit dangerous...
Click to expand...

I am no expert. But to be honest - I can hardly imagine the use of my street plans for hackers

Kommunaler IT-Dienstleister Südwestfalen-IT

Die Südwestfalen IT ist ein kommunaler IT-Dienstleister mit Sitz in Hemer und Siegen. Der Fokus der Südwestfalen-IT liegt auf dem E-Government.
www.sit.nrw

these guys do safety for most south westphalian cities. And they are quite annoying
 
If Europe wants to get away from American companies, then my suggestion would be to work with the open source community to get nextcloud to the point that it’s a drop in replacement.
 
Slartibartfast said:
If Europe wants to get away from American companies, then my suggestion would be to work with the open source community to get nextcloud to the point that it’s a drop in replacement.
Click to expand...

Now I've had time to look at Nextcloud - it appears several branches of the EU have already started to use nextcloud as a budding alternative to Sharepoint.

EU Governments Are Looking to Nextcloud to Escape Microsoft

EU governments are turning to Nextcloud to provide an alternative to Microsoft SharePoint and Google Workspace.
www.webpronews.com

Even without Trump forcing this to happen - competition is important; all consumers will benefit from there being something that forces Microsoft to stay competitive but Trump's presence sort of pushes it beyond that to having Europe develop its own products and cut down the American digital footprint in Europe.
 
Wait.. competition is important? Not that must go against EU rules or something...no wait.

The problem with competition in the tech space is money. A potential threat pops up, and the big 4 American Tech giants buy it up. Waze, Instagram, Whatsapp and so on.
 
PeteEU said:
Google
Click to expand...

No wonder it reorients itself and goes from 2D to 3D when I don't want it to - that's what ruined Maps for me. If I like the map to orient the direction the car is facing then why does Google think it's clever halfway around a strange new town to suddenly go 3D view or orient to North?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…