• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Canadian sentenced to death in China previously warned by B.C. judge to change his ways

TU Curmudgeon

B.A. (Sarc), LLb. (Lex Sarcasus), PhD (Sarc.)
DP Veteran
Joined
Mar 7, 2018
Messages
61,961
Reaction score
19,061
Location
Lower Mainland of BC
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Centrist
From Global News

Canadian sentenced to death in China previously warned by B.C. judge to change his ways

Years before being sentenced to death by a Chinese court for drug smuggling, a B.C. Supreme Court judge warned Robert Lloyd Schellenberg to change his ways.

Justice Neill Brown told Schellenberg in 2012 that he was lucky to be living in Canada and not caught up in Libya or Syria.

“Your country deserves much better from you,” Brown said. “You are in one of the best places in the whole world to live. You are not caught up in Libya or Syria.”

Brown sentenced Schellenberg to two years jail time minus time served for drug possession for the purpose of trafficking.

COMMENT:-

Not quite such a "clear cut" case as some portions of the media are making it out to be.

I did notice that he was prosecuted for attempting to smuggle drugs OUT OF China.

I also noticed that the appeal of his sentence was one that he, not the Chinese government, initiated.

The problem with appealing a sentence is that gives the courts the power to INCREASE it as well as to decrease it.

PS - Please take note of the fact that none of the governments that are protesting the SENTENCE are complaining about the actual CONVICTION.
 
From Global News

Canadian sentenced to death in China previously warned by B.C. judge to change his ways

Years before being sentenced to death by a Chinese court for drug smuggling, a B.C. Supreme Court judge warned Robert Lloyd Schellenberg to change his ways.

Justice Neill Brown told Schellenberg in 2012 that he was lucky to be living in Canada and not caught up in Libya or Syria.

“Your country deserves much better from you,” Brown said. “You are in one of the best places in the whole world to live. You are not caught up in Libya or Syria.”

Brown sentenced Schellenberg to two years jail time minus time served for drug possession for the purpose of trafficking.

COMMENT:-

Not quite such a "clear cut" case as some portions of the media are making it out to be.

I did notice that he was prosecuted for attempting to smuggle drugs OUT OF China.

I also noticed that the appeal of his sentence was one that he, not the Chinese government, initiated.

The problem with appealing a sentence is that gives the courts the power to INCREASE it as well as to decrease it.

PS - Please take note of the fact that none of the governments that are protesting the SENTENCE are complaining about the actual CONVICTION.

Darwin wins again.
 
From Global News

Canadian sentenced to death in China previously warned by B.C. judge to change his ways

Years before being sentenced to death by a Chinese court for drug smuggling, a B.C. Supreme Court judge warned Robert Lloyd Schellenberg to change his ways.

Justice Neill Brown told Schellenberg in 2012 that he was lucky to be living in Canada and not caught up in Libya or Syria.

“Your country deserves much better from you,” Brown said. “You are in one of the best places in the whole world to live. You are not caught up in Libya or Syria.”

Brown sentenced Schellenberg to two years jail time minus time served for drug possession for the purpose of trafficking.

COMMENT:-

Not quite such a "clear cut" case as some portions of the media are making it out to be.

I did notice that he was prosecuted for attempting to smuggle drugs OUT OF China.

I also noticed that the appeal of his sentence was one that he, not the Chinese government, initiated.

The problem with appealing a sentence is that gives the courts the power to INCREASE it as well as to decrease it.

PS - Please take note of the fact that none of the governments that are protesting the SENTENCE are complaining about the actual CONVICTION.

I think there is little danger of a death sentence being increased.
When people break the law in other countries, they risk being exposed to that countries justice system.
Sometimes those risks are very high.
 
…..When in Rome.....Idiot.
 
I think there is little danger of a death sentence being increased.
When people break the law in other countries, they risk being exposed to that countries justice system.
Sometimes those risks are very high.

The sentence appealed from was 15 years in jail.

Mr. Schellenberg was successful in convincing the courts that 15 years in jail was NOT an appropriate sentence.

Be careful what you ask for, eh wot?
 
The sentence appealed from was 15 years in jail.

Mr. Schellenberg was successful in convincing the courts that 15 years in jail was NOT an appropriate sentence.

Be careful what you ask for, eh wot?

Sorry, I thought the title of the article was "Canadian sentenced to death in China"
SO he was sentenced to 15 years, but appealed and got sentenced to death?
 
Sorry, I thought the title of the article was "Canadian sentenced to death in China"
SO he was sentenced to 15 years, but appealed and got sentenced to death?

Yes indeed.

Of course he can always console himself with the fact that he won't spend the next 15 years in a Chinese prison.

Small comfort that, eh wot?
 
Yes indeed.

Of course he can always console himself with the fact that he won't spend the next 15 years in a Chinese prison.

Small comfort that, eh wot?

I have known people who it seemed like the only luck that had was bad.
 
I have known people who it seemed like the only luck that had was bad.

You might be interested in

INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL OF HOLEOLOGY

- Lesson 1 -

BEFORE the hole is too deep to climb out of - STOP DIGGING!

- Lesson 2 -

There is no "light at the bottom of the hole".

- Lesson 3 -

When you see something that looks like the "light at the bottom of the hole"

!!! - CHECK FOR MAGMA - !!!

- Lesson 4 -

A perfectly constructed hole of sufficient depth will eventually fill with water and drown you! - If you stay in it long enough.

- Lesson 5 -

A large number of badly constructed holes in the wrong places is NOT a substitute for the right hole at the right place.

- Lesson 6 -

Attempting to dig a hole in solid granite with a wooden shovel is considered to be a BAD idea!

- Lesson 7 -

Trying to teach a fish to dig holes in the snow is best left to experts. (And there aren't any.)

- Lesson 8 -

You CAN dig a hole in the water. - - - It's called a 'boat'.

- Lesson 9 -

When trying to dig a hole in a swamp, your chances of success are not improved by digging more than one.

- Lesson 10 -

The easiest way to find a hole is to close your eyes and run rapidly in a random direction.

This is known as the "Politician's Method".

- Lesson 11 -

The easiest way to determine the depth of a very deep hole is to jump into it, head first.

This is known as the "State Department Method".

- Lesson 12 -

The easiest way to ensure having an adequate sized hole, is to give everyone a small hole and trust that they will all contribute their hole to the one you want.

This is known as the "Socialist Distribution Method".

- Lesson 13 -

The easiest way to ensure that everyone has enough holes is to make sure that all the holes are owned by a small number of people.

This is known as the "Capitalist Distribution Method".

- Lesson 14 -

The easiest way to ensure that you have the right sized hole is to make all the holes the same size.

This is known as "Setting Standards".

- Lesson 15 -

The easiest way to end the awful carnage caused by people running around blindly and then leaping head first into very deep holes is to ban holes.

This is known as "Protecting People's Rights".

- Lesson 16 -

The easiest way to ensure a vibrant and dynamic "Hole Construction Industry" is to pay inefficient producers to produce more holes than the market can absorb.

This is known as the "Industrial Support Method".

- Lesson 17 -

By definition,

• any holes produced in other countries where labour costs are lower are "subsidized".
and
• any holes produced in this country with the assistance of government cash grants are NOT "subsidized".

This is known as "Economics".

- Lesson 18 -

No other country may possess holes - unless they bought them from this country and they don't have anything that this country wants or they do have something that this country wants and are willing to give it to this country at a fire sale price.

This is known as "International Relations".

- Lesson 19 -

By definition,

• any group that comes to power by winning a popular election and that wants to keep the benefits of their country's holes for the people of that country is 'Totalitarian and Communist';
and
• any group that comes to power by using armed force to overthrow the previous government and that wants to ensure that the benefits of that country's hole accrue to the businesses of this country is 'Free and Democratic'.

This is known as "Political Science".

- Lesson 20 -

Regardless of fact and history, THIS country invented holes, has the only real holes in the world, and has better holes than anyone else.

Anyone disputing this statement WILL report to the Principle's office for detention.

This is known as "Patriotism".

- Lesson 21 -

It IS possible to drain the water out of a boat by drilling a hole in the bottom of it - provided that you keep moving fast enough and never stop.

This is known as the "No 'Exit Plan' Method".

- Lesson 22 -

It IS ALSO possible to drain the water out of a boat by drilling a hole in the bottom of it - provided that you don't have the boat in the water.

This is known as the "No Clue As to Purpose Method".

- Lesson 23 -

The problem of water flooding into the bottom of the hole from below is seldom solved by increasing the rate at which the hole is extended downwards.

Professor Emelio Xavier Cavator's Expansion

The only proven way to avoid having problems whilst digging holes in swamps is not to dig them at all (unless you really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really, have to - and even then to get in, dig, and get out as fast as you can).
 
Back
Top Bottom