- Joined
- Jul 14, 2012
- Messages
- 16,498
- Reaction score
- 8,165
- Location
- Montreal, QC
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Liberal
I think it is pretty obvious how the US political system handles budgets is broken as evidenced by the constant government shutdowns and the fact that the US can lack a spending plan for even one year due to political squabbling.
Other countries don't have these problems. In the Westminster system budgets are a vote of non-confidence, if the budget fails a majority vote the legislature is dissolved and new elections are held as the government has lost the confidence of the legislature and therefore the people, eventually bringing an end to the squabbling as the election essentially becomes a referendum. But while that happens the previous budget still applies until a new government can eventually pass one, other systems do the same.
How would you fix the current handling of budgets? Should the last real budget passed continue to apply till a new one should be passed? Should Congress be dissolved if no budget is passed?
Other countries don't have these problems. In the Westminster system budgets are a vote of non-confidence, if the budget fails a majority vote the legislature is dissolved and new elections are held as the government has lost the confidence of the legislature and therefore the people, eventually bringing an end to the squabbling as the election essentially becomes a referendum. But while that happens the previous budget still applies until a new government can eventually pass one, other systems do the same.
How would you fix the current handling of budgets? Should the last real budget passed continue to apply till a new one should be passed? Should Congress be dissolved if no budget is passed?