• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Biden reverses cruel family separation policy and works to reunite traumatized children with their loved ones.

Since there are some who are misinformed, here is some further facts about the family separation program under 45* :



By mid-2017 in El Paso, Texas, the administration had begun its “pilot program,” forcing any adult who crossed the border without permission – a misdemeanor for a first-time offender – into detention. The administration ripped their children from their arms and charged some of them with crimes. By the end of 2017, the administration was separating families along the length of the southern border, including those who lawfully presented themselves to authorities at ports of entry.

Family separation accelerated with the announcement of the “zero tolerance” policy on April 7, 2018. Under this policy, everyone crossing the border – even those seeking asylum – was treated like a criminal. The government took away their children, claiming that they were subject to prosecution. Even families lawfully presenting themselves at ports of entry continued to be separated.

Under the family separation policy and even in 2017, asylum seekers were imprisoned, and accompanying children under 18 were handed over to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), which scattered them among more than 100 Office of Refugee Resettlement shelters and other care arrangement centers across the country. Making matters worse, the government failed to create a reunification system, leaving parents unable to reunite with – or even track – their children.

As the policy went into full swing, advocates fiercely criticized the administration, declaring that the policy was “torturing people.” Former First Lady Laura Bush called the practices “cruel” and “immoral.”

But it wasn’t until June 15, 2018, that DHS publicly acknowledged it had separated nearly 2,000 children from their parents or legal guardians between April 19 and May 31 of that year. This number – which did not account for the thousands separated prior to April 19 – would continue to rise.

Doubling down

In the months following Trump’s order claiming to end the policy, family separations continued – but under other, more clandestine, practices.

By July 2018, parents were directed to choose between leaving the U.S. with their children or pursuing their claims for asylum in the U.S. without their children. That same month, Judge Sabraw noted that at least 463 separated parents may have been removed from the United States without their children.


also:

the official government count of children separated from parents or guardians since 2017 was reported to be 4,368. By February, the administration had separated at least 1,142 additional children from parents at the border since the policy’s “end.” And by mid-May, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement began forcing parents and their children to separate, or risk being detained together indefinitely
Amnesty International later reported that CBP had separated 6,022 “family units” between April 19, 2018, and August 15, 2018 – a much higher number than previously reported by the U.S. government. During that time, children were languishing in tent cities on the border, or were locked behind bars in family detention centers without their parents or guardians.



https://www.splcenter.org/news/2020...rs-after-trump-administration-claims-it-ended
 
So, we can look forward to more human trafficking; Way to go, Joe!!


ICE are the worst human traffickers in existence and they need to be completely abolished, and the Border Patrol completely reformed.
 
https://www.cnn.com/2021/02/02/politics/biden-immigration-execedecessor's hardline immigration policies and try to rectify the consequences of those policies, including by establishing a task force designed to reunite families sep Biden said.
Has Biden put into place safety features that will protect Americans from violent children that have been removed from criminal parents?
ICE are the worst human traffickers in existence and they need to be completely abolished, and the Border Patrol completely reformed.
I think that you need to learn what human trafficking means...

Definition of human trafficking

: organized criminal activity in which human beings are treated as possessions to be controlled and exploited (as by being forced into prostitution or involuntary labor)
 
Family separations were going on long before Trump. This is basically just another dog and pony show.
As had the cross border human trafficking of children, previously thwarted as there was no advantage to the traffickers, will probably also increase.
 
As had the cross border human trafficking of children, previously thwarted as there was no advantage to the traffickers, will probably also increase.
The democrats are already talking about loosening immigration. So we're probably going to see much worse come of this, before we see anything good.

Hopefully I'm wrong in that assumption.
 
The democrats are already talking about loosening immigration. So we're probably going to see much worse come of this, before we see anything good.

Hopefully I'm wrong in that assumption.

There is nothing wrong with immigration. Our country was founded by immigration. Maybe your great grandparents shouldn't have been allowed in, right?
 
Hey quick poll, who the f*** doesn't want to see children reunited with their families asap?
 
The democrats are already talking about loosening immigration. So we're probably going to see much worse come of this, before we see anything good.

Hopefully I'm wrong in that assumption.
You are wrong, as usual.
 
There is nothing wrong with immigration. Our country was founded by immigration. Maybe your great grandparents shouldn't have been allowed in, right?
So long as the immigration is safe and legal, yes. But that is not exactly the case here.
Mainly because our country was also founded on the rule of law, and choosing to not abide by those laws is probably one of the main ways that illegal immigration cuts at that particular root.

My great grandfather was born here by the way. While his wife legally immigrated here as a child.
 
There is no court dude. They put them on a bus/plane, read to them a bunch of crap about not coming back, and then tell them to go home. It takes hours or days to process improper entry using civil procedures, not weeks and months like it does for criminal procedures. If they process the illegal immigrants using the civil statutes they don't need to go to court.

What Trump and his idiotic supporters wanted is to make the illegal immigrants suffer. So they began charging them criminally in every single instance. They did this so they could have an excuse to separate their families and so it would scare the shit of them and as a means to discourage future illegal immigrants from coming.
Furthermore, as I understand it, once charged with the 'crime' of illegal entry that 'crime' then prevents anyone with a conviction from ever being allowed in the US under US immigration law. You can't even get a visa to visit the US with a criminal conviction, however minor.
 
https://www.cnn.com/2021/02/02/politics/biden-immigration-executive-orders/index.html

CNN)President Joe Biden signed three executive orders Tuesday that take aim at his predecessor's hardline immigration policies and try to rectify the consequences of those policies, including by establishing a task force designed to reunite families separated at the US-Mexico border.
The latest orders build upon the actions taken in Biden's first days in office and begin to provide a clearer picture of the administration's immigration priorities.

I'm not making new law, I'm eliminating bad policy," Biden said at the White House, flanked by Vice President Kamala Harris and newly confirmed Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas, of the stream of executive orders he's signed as President.
"This is about how America's safer, stronger, more prosperous when we have a fair, orderly, and humane legal immigration system," Biden said.
Is he getting rid of the cages he and Barack Obama built for chaining them?
 
Is he getting rid of the cages he and Barack Obama built for chaining them?


This is the fact of the matter about that particular comment. The metering only began under Trump, as my previous post with a linked article stated, and this is what this article has to say about your claim about Obama and immigrant children being caged.

“They did it. We changed the policy and they built the cages. We did not build the cages.” Did the Obama administration build the cages?

The Obama administration did build the cages Trump alluded to. The facility Trump mentioned was built with chain-link fencing by the Obama administration in 2014 in a warehouse in Nogales, Ariz. The makeshift shelter was built in response to an exodus of unaccompanied immigrant children from Central America. But those children did not arrive with their parents; they were unaccompanied. The shelter was not being used as part of a child separation policy, and U.S. border agents did not separate those children from their parents.


Did the Obama administration separate families at the southern U.S. border?

Yes, U.S. border officials did separate children from their parents on occasion, but it was not as widespread or systematic as it became under the Trump administration, particularly during its “zero-tolerance policy,” which was meant to deter migrants from seeking refuge in the U.S.

What was the “zero-tolerance” policy?

The policy directed U.S. prosecutors to criminally charge everyone who crossed the border without inspection. Parents were then separated from their children when they were taken into custody. Many of these parents were deported to their countries of origin — mostly to El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras. Trump scrapped the policy in June 2018 after a massive public outcry. But separations still occurred under other policies

https://www.latimes.com/california/...ion-debate-fact-check-and-who-built-the-cages
 
This is the fact of the matter about that particular comment. The metering only began under Trump, as my previous post with a linked article stated, and this is what this article has to say about your claim about Obama and immigrant children being caged.

“They did it. We changed the policy and they built the cages. We did not build the cages.” Did the Obama administration build the cages?

The Obama administration did build the cages Trump alluded to. The facility Trump mentioned was built with chain-link fencing by the Obama administration in 2014 in a warehouse in Nogales, Ariz. The makeshift shelter was built in response to an exodus of unaccompanied immigrant children from Central America. But those children did not arrive with their parents; they were unaccompanied. The shelter was not being used as part of a child separation policy, and U.S. border agents did not separate those children from their parents.

Did the Obama administration separate families at the southern U.S. border?

Yes, U.S. border officials did separate children from their parents on occasion, but it was not as widespread or systematic as it became under the Trump administration, particularly during its “zero-tolerance policy,” which was meant to deter migrants from seeking refuge in the U.S.

What was the “zero-tolerance” policy?

The policy directed U.S. prosecutors to criminally charge everyone who crossed the border without inspection. Parents were then separated from their children when they were taken into custody. Many of these parents were deported to their countries of origin — mostly to El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras. Trump scrapped the policy in June 2018 after a massive public outcry. But separations still occurred under other policies

https://www.latimes.com/california/...ion-debate-fact-check-and-who-built-the-cages
I consider the LA Times a non credible source
 
I consider the LA Times a non credible source


Seriously? That tells me everything I need to know about you. It is not that facts have a liberal bias, it is that liberal people are more willing to learn and read about facts and closed minds are biased against that. Such a shame.
 
Yes. Why were these “illegals” treated so nicely? We need to send them back with bruises and stories of the harsh American rule! That will teach those damned rapists! In the mean time we should create “camps” where we can “concentrate” them, in the future. Long live American power and rule over the poor countries! Let’s extract their resources and give nothing back. Yes, yes, mua aaa mua aa!
Can't answer the questions, can you? Neither could CNN - which is why they scrapped the creative writing piece and went with something else.
 
https://www.cnn.com/2021/02/02/politics/biden-immigration-executive-orders/index.html

CNN)President Joe Biden signed three executive orders Tuesday that take aim at his predecessor's hardline immigration policies and try to rectify the consequences of those policies, including by establishing a task force designed to reunite families separated at the US-Mexico border.
The latest orders build upon the actions taken in Biden's first days in office and begin to provide a clearer picture of the administration's immigration priorities.

I'm not making new law, I'm eliminating bad policy," Biden said at the White House, flanked by Vice President Kamala Harris and newly confirmed Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas, of the stream of executive orders he's signed as President.
"This is about how America's safer, stronger, more prosperous when we have a fair, orderly, and humane legal immigration system," Biden said.
Awesome! Im so glad to see progress like this.
 
Simply put, everything you said here is bullshit. Befire you posy crap like this do some himework so that you don't come across as an idiot.

Care to elaborate how I'm wrong??? Go ahead and try to do so without looking like that idiot your talking about
 
We don't have to separate families for a minor crime. Unlawful entry is no different than misdemeanor trespassing. Some of these families are separated forever. It's evil, and I am so glad Trump is no longer President.

How would you feel if your family was all broken up because of a speeding ticket or something.

There we disagree .......A foreign national (illegal alien) Breaking into a country and illegally crossing a sovereign border is no minor crime and not even remotely as minor as a speeding ticket.

There is a valid reason that countries have things like borders, customs agencies and passports.

Countries have a security interest in controlling there borders and knowing exactly who is coming in.

And when you have literally hoards of foreign nationals not just crossing a border illegally but coming here demanding citizenship and access to government institutions and handouts....something has to be done.

And Trump took a serious situation and treated it like the serious situation it actually is.

And Barrack Obama also took it seriously to a large degree...which is why he instituted such things as separating children from adults...for there protection of course...and mass deportations of people caught illegally crossing into our country. (there's a reason he was referred to as the deporter in chief) Obama deported more illegal aliens then Trump did.

Frankly....Senile Joe is NOT doing these kids any favor.
 
There is of course an answer to this....if you don't want to risk being separated from your children (providing they are actually your children...most are not) DON'T COME HERE!
 
There is of course an answer to this....if you don't want to risk being separated from your children (providing they are actually your children...most are not) DON'T COME HERE!

Your side doesn't get to make that call anymore. :)
 
First of all, how can you know they are the child's parents? In fact, there were 500 children that Fed found the REAL parents but they did not want to have them back. They wanted them to stay at the US

One should have vetted before any separations took place. The separations were carried out without regard for family considerations. Those were human rights abuses. Quite frankly, those who authorized or carried out such abuses should be held accountable. Unfortunately, that does not appear very likely.
 
Hey quick poll, who the f*** doesn't want to see children reunited with their families asap?
Biden, for one. Setting up a task force to "explore" the issue is not an "asap" move.
 
Biden, for one. Setting up a task force to "explore" the issue is not an "asap" move.
That is the most anti-logic EO. So, Biden admin first needs to separate the child from adults to assure they are real "loved ones."
 
So long as the immigration is safe and legal, yes. But that is not exactly the case here.
Mainly because our country was also founded on the rule of law, and choosing to not abide by those laws is probably one of the main ways that illegal immigration cuts at that particular root.

My great grandfather was born here by the way. While his wife legally immigrated here as a child.

Republicans can no longer make the argument that they're only against illegal immigration, considering that under Trump they supported curbing legal immigration as well.
 
Back
Top Bottom