At what exact moment is it Not okay to kill a child?

[Rockclimber1]

A what month, week, hour, second should you not murder the child?

 

[nota bene]

Why do you ask?

 

[Rockclimber1]

What is magical about 20 weeks that makes it okay to end the life of the baby? Just wondering what the pro choice answer is.

 

[Josie]

What is magical about 20 weeks that makes it okay to end the life of the baby? Just wondering what the pro choice answer is.

That's the point where the evil, rapist parasite transforms into a cute lil baby.

 

[Rainman05]

Well it's never ok to abort a baby. But arguments can be made that if the fetus:

-is under 3-4months
-genetic disease (stuff like down syndrome)
-his parents have no means to support a child
-his mother has been drinking alcohol

Or other such cases... i can't think of them all... abortion is course that you should be allowed to take if you so choose.

 

[Rockclimber1]

That's the point where the evil, rapist parasite transforms into a cute lil baby.

Special moment

 

[Rockclimber1]

Well it's never ok to abort a baby. But arguments can be made that if the fetus:

-is under 3-4months
-genetic disease (stuff like down syndrome)
-his parents have no means to support a child
-his mother has been drinking alcohol

Or other such cases... i can't think of them all... abortion is course that you should be allowed to take if you so choose.

I know folks have their reasons to kill their baby, but we shouldn't be killing our children.

 

[Rainman05]

I know folks have their reasons to kill their baby, but we shouldn't be killing our children.

I agree. But still, we live in an imperfect world, we are imperfect people... so we need legal mechanisms to right our wrongs.

 

[Captain Adverse]

A what month, week, hour, second should you not murder the child?

If you REALLY wanted an answer there are any number of pre-existing threads where pro-choice supporters have given the answer over, and over, and over again.

No point in repeating any in here, especially since you clearly appear to define a child the same as any typical pro-lifer does, from the moment of inception.

 

[Republic Now!]

I agree. But still, we live in an imperfect world, we are imperfect people... so we need legal mechanisms to right our wrongs.

We do, but those shouldn't include sanctioning the the killing of innocents to solve our problems. One example of legal mechanisms to right our wrongs is adoption.

If you REALLY wanted an answer there are any number of pre-existing threads where pro-choice supporters have given the answer over, and over, and over again.

I think he's looking for the justification (IE, why do you set the date you do?), not just "what's the date?"

No point in repeating any in here, especially since you clearly appear to define a child the same as any typical pro-lifer does, from the moment of inception.

You mean conception?

 

[Homer.]

Once the law and medical science says the fetus can survive outside the womb. Until that point, it's not an autonomous being.

 

[Captain Adverse]

I think he's looking for the justification (IE, why do you set the date you do?), not just "what's the date?"

Yes, which has been explained many times in the aforementioned threads. I know because I have provided several myself.

This is a member with a few posts under his belt, yet he starts this type of thread even though there are dozens of similar ones with exactly the information he is looking for. Go figure.

 

[JayDubya]

You mean conception?

Doubtlessly, he meant:

 

[digsbe]

Well it's never ok to abort a baby. But arguments can be made that if the fetus:

-is under 3-4months
-genetic disease (stuff like down syndrome)
-his parents have no means to support a child
-his mother has been drinking alcohol

Or other such cases... i can't think of them all... abortion is course that you should be allowed to take if you so choose.

Why is it ok to kill them in the womb though? As far as human life goes they are equally human when compared to an adult with a genetic disease, down syndrome, FAS, or grown up poor. Why is it acceptable to kill them pre-birth or even viewed as compassionate when it's not acceptable to kill them post birth for the same reason?

 

[Dragonfly]

Just wondering what the pro choice answer is.

Really? You're "just wondering"?

:roll:

 

[GEIxBattleRifle]

That's the point where the evil, rapist parasite transforms into a cute lil baby.

No that's where some pro choicer's believe personhood starts

 

[Josie]

No that's where some pro choicer's believe personhood starts

That's what I said. *smiles sweetly*

 

[Josie]

Why is it ok to kill them in the womb though? As far as human life goes they are equally human when compared to an adult with a genetic disease, down syndrome, FAS, or grown up poor. Why is it acceptable to kill them pre-birth or even viewed as compassionate when it's not acceptable to kill them post birth for the same reason?

Location, location, location!

 

[Manc Skipper]

I know folks have their reasons to kill their baby, but we shouldn't be killing our children.

If you don't want to, you don't have to.

 

[Korimyr the Rat]

Nine days after birth, when the child's family has given it a name and welcomed it into their home.

 

[Korimyr the Rat]

Nine days after birth, when the child's family has given it a name and welcomed it into their home.

 

[Ikari]

Once the law and medical science says the fetus can survive outside the womb. Until that point, it's not an autonomous being.

Cool, I'm gonna go into the hospital and start unplugging machines.

 

[Dragonfly]

Cool, I'm gonna go into the hospital and start unplugging machines.

Families make that choice for their loved ones on an unfortunately regular basis don't they?

 

[Ikari]

Families make that choice for their loved ones on an unfortunately regular basis don't they?

Indeed. Of course the difference here being one at the end of their life vs one at the beginning of their life. Nature being as it is, the fetus would develop into a healthy human (in most cases), where as the brain dead would just die. But why bring nature and biology into this?

 

[SmokeAndMirrors]

Abortion doesn't kill children. Children are young autonomous human organisms. ZEF's are not autonomous.

So the answer is, I suppose, when it becomes a child, at which point it is no longer siphoning from the woman's body.