• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Anti-Semitism Row: Now Councillor Suspended (1 Viewer)

gunner

gunner

DP Veteran
Joined
Dec 20, 2007
Messages
6,551
Reaction score
2,881
Location
uk
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
"Labour has been forced to suspend a councillor for anti-Israel comments posted on Facebook as the party continues to be batttered over its handling of the anti-Semitic crisis.

Nottingham city councillor Ilyas Aziz shared a number of posts on the social media site, one suggesting Israel be relocated in the US - the same comments that saw Bradford West MP Naz Shah suspended last week."

Anti-Semitism Row: Now Councillor Suspended

It feels like 'open season' since Corbyn took over the leadership. I wonder who'll be next?
 
Details coming through of another Labour councillor, who apparently says: "Israel is behind the Islamic state". Details will be posted when available.
 
Thank God the British right wing are here to defend Israel from the evil left....:roll:
 
Higgins86 said:
Thank God the British right wing are here to defend Israel from the evil left....:roll:
Click to expand...

Higgs, do you feel the above comments are acceptable?
 
Infinite Chaos said:
Actually, quite a few councillors have already been suspended which are only just coming to light.
Click to expand...

As soon as I posted this Sky News suggested another councillor from Blackburn had suggested: "Israel are behind IS ". Whether it was historic or recent, I'm sure details will follow.
 
If it's Salim Mulla... then this Guido Fawkes page has his past facebook quotes. The same "move Israel to the US" graphic appeared on his page too.
 
Okay, I'm a little confused here guys. Maybe I'm missing something. Or maybe I'm being overly literal, but to me words actually have meaning. Especially in this crazy world we're living in where everything you say and do can instantly end up on the internet for the entire world to dissect and the media to create outrageous headlines out of.

So here's my issue: I see and hear a lot of anti-Israel comments coming from the British left. Why are the headlines calling this anti-Semitism? Why the conflation of two very different terms? Does the media not realize how dangerous it is to do this? Not that I expect anything better from that ****ed up profession these days, but this is tabloid journalism and it pisses me off because most people will take it at face value without any critical analysis of what they're being fed.

That said, just to be clear and to prevent my own words from being twisted or misunderstood, I do not approve of any of these anti-Israel comments. Although I do support the right of all these idiots to voice their ignorant opinions and to deal with the consequences of what they say publicly.

So, can someone point me to an actual anti-Semitic comment or is all of this just anti-Israel drivel? And am I the only one actually bothered by this??
 
Arcana XV said:
...So, can someone point me to an actual anti-Semitic comment or is all of this just anti-Israel drivel? And am I the only one actually bothered by this??
Click to expand...

No you aren't.
 
gunner said:
Weak sauce Andy. So, the right are/have done it, so it is fine for the left too?
Click to expand...

Unsurprising you'd leap at a straw man argument. Go back to my comments on Livingston. By your logic I guess you're happy to ignore anti-semitism that isn't committed by Labourites. Silly argument, isn't it?
 
Andalublue said:
It would appear that on one measure of anti-semitism there is a greater concern that UKIP and Tory party supporters are more of a worry.

Revealed: the most anti-Semitic people in Britain -- and who they vote for - Telegraph
Click to expand...

Wow. Really? That is the question used to measure anti-Semitism? That was one hell of a loaded question.

I have more than one passport. Am I more Swiss, Canadian or Spanish? I don't even know how to begin to measure that. One thing I can tell you though, is that I am not fully either Swiss, Canadian or Spanish. There's a big piece of my identity in all three. If a Swiss person were to say that I am "less Swiss" because of it, I would have to kind of agree.
 
Arcana XV said:
.......................So here's my issue: I see and hear a lot of anti-Israel comments coming from the British left. Why are the headlines calling this anti-Semitism? Why the conflation of two very different terms? ..........................
Click to expand...

I'd say there's a difference between being critical of Israeli policy itself (towards anyone else, yet usually the Palestinians) and advocating the elimination of their state by relocating the whole people to some other place.

The latter is not simply anti-Israel, it's anti Jewish. Alone on account of the nature of the state as anyone should be able to see it, i.e. Jewish homeland.

There is an equal difference between lambasting (say) Hamas policy (of wanting to destroy) and advocating that all Palestinians be assimilated into neighboring Arab countries, except in the latter case any accusation of that stance being Islamophobe would somehow miss the mark. Wouldn't make it any less disgusting though.

In other words one can be critical of Israel and its policies and to construe such critical stance as being anti-semitic is rubbish. Call for the elimination of the state in the process though and don't whine at the flak that'll come.
 
gunner said:
Higgs, do you feel the above comments are acceptable?
Click to expand...

I just think this whole thing is being blown out of proportion and it sets a dangerous precident at what we can/can't say about Israel.
 
Higgins86 said:
I just think this whole thing is being blown out of proportion and it sets a dangerous precident at what we can/can't say about Israel.
Click to expand...
Well, see my post just prior to yours where I've attempted to outline differences.

I'd agree though that labels are being thrown around recklessly.
 
Andalublue said:
It would appear that on one measure of anti-semitism there is a greater concern that UKIP and Tory party supporters are more of a worry.

Revealed: the most anti-Semitic people in Britain -- and who they vote for - Telegraph
Click to expand...

Kind of supports the comment I made in another post. The percentages in this poll aren't that far apart between the major parties.

William Rea said:
...I don't understand what those who are criticising Labour actually want? My question was perhaps thinking that the number of Muslims in Labour was part of the problem? PEW research suggests that perhaps 10% of the British public view Jews unfavourably are you suggesting that all of these people are in the Labour party and no other political party in Britain?...
Click to expand...
 
More importantly can anyone think of a specific policy from Labour that could be deemed anti-Semitic? I can't think of any in recent memory.
 
Chagos said:
I'd say there's a difference between being critical of Israeli policy itself (towards anyone else, yet usually the Palestinians) and advocating the elimination of their state by relocating the whole people to some other place.

The latter is not simply anti-Israel, it's anti Jewish. Alone on account of the nature of the state as anyone should be able to see it, i.e. Jewish homeland.

There is an equal difference between lambasting (say) Hamas policy (of wanting to destroy) and advocating that all Palestinians be assimilated into neighboring Arab countries, except in the latter case any accusation of that stance being Islamophobe would somehow miss the mark. Wouldn't make it any less disgusting though.

In other words one can be critical of Israel and its policies and to construe such critical stance as being anti-semitic is rubbish. Call for the elimination of the state in the process though and don't whine at the flak that'll come.
Click to expand...

I'm trying to keep within the restrictions of discussing the merits of this outside of the IP Forum so in general terms, I would argue that, unless it is made in a 'satirical' way, it is a ridiculous comment to make post hoc but, it is not a crime to think it and, I don't believe that it is up to us try to control what others can think or express unless it has a direct causal link to actual harm; I can see that it might also be hyperbole to try to make a point.

In general, attack the ridiculous comment but for goodness sake stop trying to police what we are allowed or not allowed to think or say.
 
Arcana XV said:
Okay, I'm a little confused here guys. Maybe I'm missing something. Or maybe I'm being overly literal, but to me words actually have meaning. Especially in this crazy world we're living in where everything you say and do can instantly end up on the internet for the entire world to dissect and the media to create outrageous headlines out of.

So here's my issue: I see and hear a lot of anti-Israel comments coming from the British left. Why are the headlines calling this anti-Semitism? Why the conflation of two very different terms? ...
Click to expand...
I did a string on this 6 Years ago.
Actually was thanked by Andalublue for it in one of his posts.
http://www.debatepolitics.com/middle-east/68064-anti-semitism-anti-zionism-crosses-line.html

Beside my prelude discussion, the main content was:
A piece on this by Alan Dershowitz on HuffingtonPost. July 2005.
When Legit Criticism Crosses the Anti-Semitism Line
Also like the quote by Thomas Friedman.

The EU commission/eumc considers comparison of Israel to Nazi Germany anti-semitic.
Not to mention, many anti-semites just use simple/transparent substitution.
It's not any less ansitisemitic because someone substitutes 'Zionist' or 'Israel' for 'Jew/Jewish.'
ie 'Jewish Bankers' is now 'Zionist Bankers'; Jewish Control is now ZOG, etc.
aka 'Proxy anti-semitism', the 'New anti-semitism.'
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)
Back
Top Bottom