• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Recent content by maquiscat

  1. maquiscat

    Olympic Committee study finds trans women disadvantaged in several athletic areas

    I've been saying this for years. Instead of sex or gender or age, base it on ability. I asked someone in another thread (maybe also another forum) does a woman who hits with 200 lbs of force somehow hit lighter than a man who hits with 200 lbs of force? They never answered.
  2. maquiscat

    What if you had sex with a man who transitioned to a woman and didn't realize it until afterwards?

    Why can't we say that all people with the Y chromosome is a male, even if they are born with a vagina? Which part is the determination for biological sex; Genitals or chromosomes? Or maybe we use he SRY presence. A lack of an SRY gene means that you are female, since the SRY gene is what...
  3. maquiscat

    What if you had sex with a man who transitioned to a woman and didn't realize it until afterwards?

    No but here is one with some quote. I already have money down on a bet with one of the spouses at which parts you will latch onto. I'm going to wait on this until I see what your response is to the above First off all, we are already talking about a rare condition to start with. But rare...
  4. maquiscat

    What if you had sex with a man who transitioned to a woman and didn't realize it until afterwards?

    Yes. The issue here isn't what typically happens and the label that goes with that typical configuration. The question is what are the exceptions, what label do they get, and which sex should they be treated as?
  5. maquiscat

    What if you had sex with a man who transitioned to a woman and didn't realize it until afterwards?

    I had been addressing specifically the lubrication part of that post. While the rest can be argued as opinion, that part you were factually wrong about. But to be fair, the procedures that allow that now were not always available until their relatively recent development. As to the rest, being...
  6. maquiscat

    What if you had sex with a man who transitioned to a woman and didn't realize it until afterwards?

    That doesn't address my point. Gender roles are social constructs, as shown by how they change over time, while gender itself is not. The use of gender roles and which ones a person fulfills does nothing to indicate their gender. I noticed that you avoided the post with the question on this...
  7. maquiscat

    What if you had sex with a man who transitioned to a woman and didn't realize it until afterwards?

    If we found that the presence of a kitten did reduce or eliminate epileptic symptoms then we would have that as a treatment. Maybe later we find that the presence of a kitten stimulates a production of a chemical in the body that we can then synthesize, and eliminate the need for the kitten...
  8. maquiscat

    What if you had sex with a man who transitioned to a woman and didn't realize it until afterwards?

    Shifting the goal post. You only previously claimed that a trans woman's vagina could not self lubricate. I showed otherwise. You made no prior claims on any other aspect. Delmarva. Well we would have been one by now, if it were not for that one vote. But in using that "likely", you are...
  9. maquiscat

    What if you had sex with a man who transitioned to a woman and didn't realize it until afterwards?

    This is also incorrect. There are plenty who maintain their gender as matching their biological sex who also fit themselves into the roles that are opposite for the time (given that the actual roles change over time). The roles that you wish to assume in society are not an indicator of whether...
  10. maquiscat

    What if you had sex with a man who transitioned to a woman and didn't realize it until afterwards?

    That would be a great argument if that were universally true. Reality is that many trans women don't get their penis removed because they didn't need to go that far to alleviate their GD. Continuing to have that penis doesn't make them any less of a trans woman. The level of intensity of the GD...
  11. maquiscat

    What if you had sex with a man who transitioned to a woman and didn't realize it until afterwards?

    Not necessarily true, especially since we have been finding that the brain structures of transgender people are closer to that of the sex their gender normally pairs with than that of their own biological sex.
  12. maquiscat

    What if you had sex with a man who transitioned to a woman and didn't realize it until afterwards?

    First it wasn't until the 15th century that gender was first used as a euphemism for biological sex. Even then it didn't have frequent use as such until the 20th century, where it then became so much of the common language that it shifted to synonymous instead of euphemistic. Secondly, science...
  13. maquiscat

    What if you had sex with a man who transitioned to a woman and didn't realize it until afterwards?

    I'll ask the same of you as I have others. Is it your claim that a person with an XY chromosomes pair is a male even if born with a vagina, or that an XX chromosome pair person is female even if born with a penis? Actually the SRY gene is what causes that development and it can detach from the...
  14. maquiscat

    What if you had sex with a man who transitioned to a woman and didn't realize it until afterwards?

    That is what the major of the transgender community and supporters are claiming. It's the opponents who are claiming otherwise.
  15. maquiscat

    What if you had sex with a man who transitioned to a woman and didn't realize it until afterwards?

    Actually there are procedures in which the new vagina can lubricate naturally. It's not the same fluid as a cis woman produces, but it's lubrication and no more harmful to either party, that what a female's vagina produces. Some of this would have to be subjective. After all we have a problem...
See more
Back
Top Bottom